Villagers That Have Disappointed You?

[mermaidvivian]

I don't hate her by any means, but I don't love Fauna in the same way that so many other people do. She's very sweet and fun to talk to, but her personality isn't very compelling to me, I guess..?
I love Bruce, but I (accidentally!) got in his way a couple times when he was trying to catch a bug and he got super angry. :-/ I guess I kind of have a grudge now.

 

[Xara]

Marshal. He's cute and all, but just..I was a bit disappointed.

 

[Altarium]

Marshal. He's cute and all, but just..I was a bit disappointed.

Oh, absolutely. I never got the hype around him, but each to their own I guess.

 

[Whisper]

I had Whitney in one of my towns she was ok even though I like snooties I couldn't really get myself to like Whitney. I guess its because she is a wolf since the way the wolves' models look really bother me.

 

[lulu112]

Phoebe she isn't what I was expecting from what people say about her

 

[SilkSpectre]

I had Whitney in one of my towns she was ok even though I like snooties I couldn't really get myself to like Whitney. I guess its because she is a wolf since the way the wolves' models look really bother me.

I don't like the way the wolves look and wasn't going to get any til I saw Whitney. She's so pretty.

For me, Cheri. I just don't think I like peppies so I stopped forcing myself to have one just for the pwps.

Also, I totally want Phoebe just because she's a phoenix and uchis never disappoint me.

 

[HopeForHyrule]

Marshal. He's cute and all, but just..I was a bit disappointed.

So much this. I had him in my town for a short time, but now he's happily living in one of my hubby's towns. There are smugs that I just find more delightful than him. Namely O'Hare.

Most of the tier one villagers I don't understand the almost obsessive love they get.

 

[Buttonsy]

Kiki, I absolutely adore how she looks in the older games, but in New Leaf, they made her eyes look all squishy and changed her mouth and she just looks... slightly off now. Which really sucks, because I have a witchcraft themed town and a black cat would be perfect for that...

 

[Charlise]

Mira... I'm just leaving it at that.

 

[maplecheek]

Kiki, I absolutely adore how she looks in the older games, but in New Leaf, they made her eyes look all squishy and changed her mouth and she just looks... slightly off now. Which really sucks, because I have a witchcraft themed town and a black cat would be perfect for that...

I totally agree!

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I personally love marshal, he is one of my favourite smugs, just adore his simple design. I love the smugs anyway though, have never been disappointed with one. Different strokes and all that

Deirdre really disappinted me. She was one of the few uchi whose design I actually liked. I ended up just keeping her for the PWP's and then getting her out as soon as I could. Turns out I don't like the uchi personality, sadly. I just don't 'get' them, I guess.
She was cute enough and matched the other villagers I had at the time, but I just couldn't take to her

 

[Greggy]

Beau. He's cute but he's such a butt to deal with. I won't explain further otherwise this thread will end up becoming a salt mine.
Victoria was also disappointing. I like Victoria's design the most when it comes to Peppy villagers, but she was boring that I didn't bother to befriend her despite staying for the town for a long time.

 

[namiieco]

Beau's design got boring after a short while, though I do like how cute his dialogue can sometimes be.

 

[BlackCatCrossing]

Dude, I am obsessive over Juliam toh. I cri everi tim i remeber how long I have to cycle for him.
Eh, I feel like Drago kinda disappointed me. I love dragons, and I wanted something more. Phoebe is meh with being a phoenix, just dislike her, which is annoying cause they're unique.

 

[NearMiss]

For me it was Bianca. Sure, she was cool when she first decided to move in. But since then, she has really lost her cool factor. I use to think of her as the best preppy villager, but now I'd prefer Rosie anyday.

 

[maplecheek]

Actually, several of the Tier 1/2 were disappointing. Marshal, Merengue, Zucker.

I got them from campsite and one was an adoption because I thought I would like them due to their universal desirability.

But realized that Zucker was creepy to me because of the way he walked. Marshal was cute, but I don't know why he is so popular, and Merengue is awesome, but not to the extent that I wanted to keep her.

So I gave them up for adoption.

 

[Becca617]

Merengue, I know she's cute and sweet and adorable, but she really didn't do anything special. I'm kind of feeling the same way about Fauna, because normal villagers often bore me but I need at least one normal.

 

[Awesomeness1230]

I don't know why, but Diana never really grew on me. I guess I got bored of her.

 

[Pinkbell]

None, Don't expect to much - I know what I'm getting I wish I could have more villagers though :C