Being a mayor I think we should be called mayor . I think it makes the main character stand out. I mean honestly it is us after all that does all the work and spending.
My villagers call me "June Bug". Shep started it - he asked me if he could call me June Bug and I thought that was awesome since I was born in June (God I LOVE Shep so much!!!) Then the others asked if they could call me June Bug too. If another nickname is suggested I always turn it down flat. I like being June Bug
I don't have any nicknames yet in my current game. Only just started playing New Leaf this past Friday. I had one be a real wench in Wild World once, though. Was shaking trees and got stung by bees, so one of the girls rushes over right after saying "I have the perfect nickname for you, it's written all over your face! Want to hear it? Hon!" I just thought "Gee, thanks for calling me "honey" after I get stung by bees. -_-"
None of my villagers have given me nicknames yet, but in my old file, I had Hugh call me "K-bear." Then Benedict heard about it and started calling me that, too.
I usually don't mind the nicknames they call me, since my name starts with a C even the lame ones like C-star aren't too bad. I dunno haha! I'll try to tell them to call me sweetie or something though haha. I wish somebody would call me shmoopy already because that is the silliest name I have ever heard in all Animal Crossing ahaha!
Also,
4/9 villagers are still starting. *sigh* when will they ever move out?