Torn Between 3 Villagers

[koikoi]

So I need help. I have aquired most of my dream villagers but I keep finding ones that I love and now I’m trapped with 10 villagers and don’t know which one to let go.

I have:

- merengue (normal)
- fauna (normal)
- diana (snooty)
- whitney (snooty)
- zucker (lazy)
- octavian (cranky)
- marshal (smug)
- marcie (normal)
- sherb (lazy)
- julian (smug)

... the 3 in bold are the 3 I am trying to figure out who to let go because I need Sparro (random dreamie I know, but I love him). I had Julian in new leaf but I’m kind of outgrowing him. Plus Julian and Sherb are both blue/kinda similar in a way and Sherb just seems cuter. I just found Sherb and Marcie on a nook island and they are both so cute Who would you let go?

 

[chrisbeta03]

marcie because you already have 2 normals as opposed to one lazy and one smug

 

[cloudmask]

if you're outgrowing julian, i would say he's the one to let go. i'm personally avoiding having nh villagers that i've already had in previous games. i think it's more fun to get to know some new guys!

 

[koikoi]

marcie because you already have 2 normals as opposed to one lazy and one smug

Thats true. I love Marcie though I have a soft spot for the normal villagers

 

[tybalt_cake]

i would choose marcie , tbh

 

[Ace Marvel]

Since you had Julian (who I love) in NL and you are outgrowing him, maybe it's the right choice.

 

[Xara]

i’m voting for julian as he’s my least favourite out of the 3 and you seem to currently like sherb and marcie more than him ;u;

 

[Stil]

Considering you already have 2 normals, I would let Marcie go.

 

[koikoi]

Since you had Julian (who I love) in NL and you are outgrowing him, maybe it's the right choice.

I love him too! I don’t know what it is lately I just keep finding all these random villagers that I love too. I wish we could have more than 10 villagers. I do have a bunch of the same villagers I had in new leaf, that could be part of the problem - I need a change

 

[Ace Marvel]

I love him too! I don’t know what it is lately I just keep finding all these random villagers that I love too. I wish we could have more than 10 villagers. I do have a bunch of the same villagers I had in new leaf, that could be part of the problem - I need a change

Also as a plus, you will see a lot more of actions/sell/giveaways of Julian than from the other two, if you change your mind, Sherb right now is the most expensive.

 

[koikoi]

Also as a plus, you will see a lot more of actions/sell/giveaways of Julian than from the other two, if you change your mind, Sherb right now is the most expensive.

That’s true. I don’t think I could afford buying Sherb tbh

 

[Minimasher]

I think either Marcie or Julian. If you are outgrowing Julian maybe it would be good to let him go. Or maybe Marcie because having three normals can be a bit boring and it might be better to mix the personalities a bit more

 

[Annika.]

Sounds like your choice is Julian, you should stick with what your gut tells you.

 

[koikoi]

I think either Marcie or Julian. If you are outgrowing Julian maybe it would be good to let him go. Or maybe Marcie because having three normals can be a bit boring and it might be better to mix the personalities a bit more

Yeah I have a problem hoarding the normal villagers! :”(

 

[chibski]

It sounds like internally you've already decided on Julian, even if you don't feel like you have. And that's okay! It's so easy to get attached to villagers, but I guarantee that once you find a dreamie to replace him, you'll feel good about your decision not to mention that Julian is a rather popular villager and you could definitely get a decent amount for him if you get him in boxes!