Top 10 horse villagers?

[silver_shroud]

Normal- Savannah
Peppy- Victoria, Winnie
Snooty- Annalise
Uchi- N/A
Lazy- Papi, Elmer
Jock- Buck
Cranky- Roscoe
Smug- Colton, Julian

I'm thinking that this is going to be the villager set that I'll be aiming for. My only reservation is that Ed won't be in the lineup. I'm still a bit on the fence about Buck since his design is not all that appealing, as others have pointed out. I do have all the jock PWPs unlocked already, so now I guess it's just a matter of deciding if I want all the available horse personalities represented...

 

[ssvv227]

I still think that Ed would be more appealing than Buck. You can also get Buck early on in the process of obtaining all your horses so you can cycle him out if you don't like him.

 

[silver_shroud]

Yes, I feel like Ed, Colton, and Julian would just be an ultra glam trio. But you're right, I can always give Buck a chance to prove his merit first and see how things go!

 

[Jinglefruit]

With my horse town I initially cut out the 3 'horse' villagers that weren't actually horses; Julian, Savannah and Papi.


But then I realised I didn't like Colton much, and Papi was attempting to move out of my other town, so I kicked out Colton and took him instead. (Because Papi is my 2nd fav villager)
And then, I forgot to plot reset Buck, and eventually decided I preferred a neater town over keeping him. And I took Savannah in just because she happened to be going free on the Villager trading board at the time.

So I didn't really stick to my plan, but the lesson here is you have 3 back-ups if/when something goes wrong.

 

[MagicalCat590]

Savannah and Ed are the best <3

 

[Shimmer]

I'd leave out Buck, Peaches and Ed.

I love Savannah, Annalise and Victoria. c:

 

[Karminny]

Roscoe, Winnie, Victoria and Papi are horses you should get. Idk the rest

 

[nintendoanna]

Get JULIAN!

 

[CJODell62]

I'd say either Papi or Clyde. Both are lazy villagers, and both of them are adorable.

 

[cosmic-latte]

Roscoe, Julian, Colton, Papi. I have Roscoe available for free in my cycle town if you want to reserve him

 

[Stacie]

I used to have Ed and Julian in town and I gotta say they look super adorable with each other since their colouring is so similar
Of course you might also want variety too so that might be no good!

Since Papi and Savannah are designed to look like an okapi and zebra I's say leave them out (they're so cute though aaa, I really like the horse villagers haha).

 

[Viva Xocolatl]

I love Papi and Peaches, but I doubt they are popular

 

[buzzing]

savannah, papi and winnie are definitely top 3 imo... im not sure about the rest tho. I like Roscoe, i guess!

 

[ThePayne22]

I'd say leave out Ed, Peaches and Clyde, they are one's that would double with other personality types and I wouldn't care for them visually.
Here's a list of the Personalities & Horses:

Normal- Savannah
Peppy- Victoria, Winnie
Snooty- Annalise
Uchi- N/A
Lazy- Papi, Elmer
Jock- Buck
Cranky- Roscoe
Smug- Colton, Julian

TBH I would want an Uchi, but There aren't any Horse Uchi's, but this town line up looks pretty neat. I'd love to visit when you get them settled.

Yeah, I like this setup the best as well.

Though Iv'e had Buck in a town before and I don't like him, so I could see replacing him with Ed. Best of luck with everything and I'm curious to see what you pick. ^^

 

[MagicalCat590]

I'd say leave out Ed, Peaches and Clyde, they are one's that would double with other personality types and I wouldn't care for them visually.
Here's a list of the Personalities & Horses:

Normal- Savannah
Peppy- Victoria, Winnie
Snooty- Annalise
Uchi- N/A
Lazy- Papi, Elmer
Jock- Buck
Cranky- Roscoe
Smug- Colton, Julian

TBH I would want an Uchi, but There aren't any Horse Uchi's, but this town line up looks pretty neat. I'd love to visit when you get them settled.

How about using a deer uchi? I mean, I know it's an horse town, but they're both in the same family, I think, and they're similar enough to get away with it, IMO.

 

[Javocado]

Julian
Roscoe
Papi
Peaches

/thread

 

[Rasha]

I'd leave out Annalise, Ed and Victoria

 

[PlasmaPower]

I wanna eat Julian. I wonder what he tastes like.

 

[Aestivate]

Papi and Roscoe

 

[lars708]

So, I've got an all-horse village currently in the works and am trying to decide on which three horses to exclude, since there are 13 to choose from and sadly only ten spots. The horses include Annalise, Elmer, Julian, Savannah, Papi, Peaches, Ed, Buck, Roscoe, Colton, Winnie, Victoria, and Clyde. For visual reference, you can see them here: http://animalcrossing.wikia.com/wiki/Horse

Which ones do you think should be invited in and which should be put out to pasture, so to speak?

I just really like Savannah (That is what she is called right?) she's the only horse i have ever had so that might also be the reason why i like her that much! Hahah!