• The results of the egg decorating contest have been announced! Everyone's designs were amazing! Congratulations to our winners!

The Villager Advisory Thread

I can't choose who to keep, Poppy or Coco. Currently I have three normal's in town, so I need to let go of one of them. At first, I wanted to keep Coco, but now I'm not so sure. They are both so adorable! xc

Judging by your avatar, you like Coco more :3 I would keep Coco because she is so unique.
 
Personal Faves

Karen,

Which villagers are among your personal favorites?

(You can explain why, if you feel like doing so, but I do ask that you name at least one male and one female.)

Candy83
 
Out of all my villagers who do you think is my best and my worst? It won't make me change my opinions on my villagers, I just want to know what you think.
 
Karen,

Which villagers are among your personal favorites?

(You can explain why, if you feel like doing so, but I do ask that you name at least one male and one female.)

Candy83

Blaire is my favorite female...she's really funny. Like she's so self-absorbed but then she'll come to my house and be like omg you're amazing
Male favorite is Ribbot! Too many reasons to list why. He is my top favorite.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Out of all my villagers who do you think is my best and my worst? It won't make me change my opinions on my villagers, I just want to know what you think.

In order, best to worst: Ribbot, Skye, Hopper, Marina, Ankha, Rolf, Rory, Hans, Pinky.(She moved into my town twice on a patch of flowers)
 
Hi. I would like your opinion on the best Cranky Wolf villager :). I had Wolfgang before but he suddenly left when I stopped playing for a week :(. Thanks ^^
 
Oh this thread was such a good idea Karen! Thank you :3

Who do you think are some of the best jock villagers? I eventually want to have a jock in my town (I'm going to have a hard time deciding who to kick out though. Oh well, I guess I'll worry about that when it's time.) I don't really like any of the popular-ish ones like Genji, Kid Cat, Rudy or Bam. I think I mostly like unpopular, harder-to-find jocks, so I guess it might be a challenge to actually get one of them. I had Mac in my last town and I loved him a lot, so I'm thinking about trying to get him again. But I also really like Leonardo, and Sly also seems super cool - a camouflage alligator. :O
And I also sort of like Teddy. That would be harder though because I'd have to cycle 8 or so more villagers out if I wanted to get him. He was a starter who I quickly got rid of without really thinking about it. Ugh, stupid past Me. -_- Why do you do these things to me?
So what are your thoughts? Maybe I'll just go with the first jock I find in my campsite :p

Or maybe I won't get a jock. I don't know if I could bear to kick one of my babies out of town ;o;

- - - Post Merge - - -

Eh, sorry that was long ._.
 
Last edited:
I'm making a wood-land themed town. c:
Which villagers do you think would fit my town? I'm planning on keeping Beau. :D
 
Last edited:
I wish this would get stickied and that they'd merge all the stupid "X vs Y" threads into this <3

Yeah they should stickie a thread so that anyone can post for villager advice and anyone can answer it ~ this way different time zones get it too ect ect ect.
 
Karen... Can I join your team? I'm not sure if I'm meant to post suggestions, and I did, but it want to do it to others too. Is it allowed?
 
Karen... Can I join your team? I'm not sure if I'm meant to post suggestions, and I did, but it want to do it to others too. Is it allowed?

Of course! Anyone can

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hi. I would like your opinion on the best Cranky Wolf villager :). I had Wolfgang before but he suddenly left when I stopped playing for a week :(. Thanks ^^

Chief is awesome. ;D

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh this thread was such a good idea Karen! Thank you :3

Who do you think are some of the best jock villagers? I eventually want to have a jock in my town (I'm going to have a hard time deciding who to kick out though. Oh well, I guess I'll worry about that when it's time.) I don't really like any of the popular-ish ones like Genji, Kid Cat, Rudy or Bam. I think I mostly like unpopular, harder-to-find jocks, so I guess it might be a challenge to actually get one of them. I had Mac in my last town and I loved him a lot, so I'm thinking about trying to get him again. But I also really like Leonardo, and Sly also seems super cool - a camouflage alligator. :O
And I also sort of like Teddy. That would be harder though because I'd have to cycle 8 or so more villagers out if I wanted to get him. He was a starter who I quickly got rid of without really thinking about it. Ugh, stupid past Me. -_- Why do you do these things to me?
So what are your thoughts? Maybe I'll just go with the first jock I find in my campsite :p

Or maybe I won't get a jock. I don't know if I could bear to kick one of my babies out of town ;o;

- - - Post Merge - - -

Eh, sorry that was long ._.

I don't really like any of the popular Jocks either :x
My favorite jock is Ribbot! I mean come on -- a ROBOT FROG. You can't ask for anything more! But other than Ribbot I think Axel and Poncho are really cute :x Costeau looks funny xD but the other villagers you mentioned are awesome too xD
 
ACK! Astrid's moving in on my second game? I hear that she's a terrible townie, her place is in an ok spot and I don't have any snooty characters. Opinion please? Should I start getting rid of her right away? I don't want to redesign the town if she's as bad as I heard.
 
I seek some advice on two problems.

First, I can't decide which of the two snooty's I currently have in my town (Astrid & Purrl) to keep. Purrl's cute and everything, but Astrid was one of my starting five, and I really like the interior of her house. Plus, I want some variety in my town, since three of my permanent villagers so far are cats.

Second, I'd like an opinion on which uchi villager I should have in my town. Rocket's my resident uchi right now, but I don't care that much for her. I was originally thinking about Mira, but I also kind of like Phoebe and Fuchsia.
 
ACK! Astrid's moving in on my second game? I hear that she's a terrible townie, her place is in an ok spot and I don't have any snooty characters. Opinion please? Should I start getting rid of her right away? I don't want to redesign the town if she's as bad as I heard.

I would start getting rid of her :x have you seen what she looks like? D: I guess she would go well with Pietro lol but yeah...start getting her out. there's plenty of other villagers better than her

- - - Post Merge - - -

I seek some advice on two problems.

First, I can't decide which of the two snooty's I currently have in my town (Astrid & Purrl) to keep. Purrl's cute and everything, but Astrid was one of my starting five, and I really like the interior of her house. Plus, I want some variety in my town, since three of my permanent villagers so far are cats.

Second, I'd like an opinion on which uchi villager I should have in my town. Rocket's my resident uchi right now, but I don't care that much for her. I was originally thinking about Mira, but I also kind of like Phoebe and Fuchsia.

If you want to have variety, then keep Astrid and get rid of Purrl. XD

Mira is AMAZING. You won't regret that ;D I like her interior. This is biased, cuz I have her in my town.
 
Could I receive opinion on my villagers? :)

I enjoy your layout of villagers, they are each a different personality type (there are 9, so you have two Normals) and I think you can go along with them well. I think you'll be fine with them, it's nice and varied with the animals and personalities.
 
Last edited:
How DARE you criticise my starry kangaroo! .. Don't listen to them Astrid, you're amazing. <3

Feel free to rate my villagers :)

And also, who do you prefer, Fauna or Merengue?
 
Back
Top