The Villager Advisory Thread

[KermitTea]

This is the place where you can ask for opinions on villagers, such as:
-who you should keep
-which villager is better
-best/worst villagers
etc..anything to do with villagers

Anyone and everyone can ask questions or give opinions!

Hopefully this will help decrease many similar threads

 

[Darumy]

ofinally

To start off: Bianca or Bangle or Tutu? Since I let go of Merry haha ;_;

Please try to stay within the three unless you can make a really good case for another cutie!

 

[Stalfos]

I'm thinking of ditching Tucker and replacing him with Rasher (who I really like). Problem is this will mess up the balance in my town since I would have 3 crankies and no lazy. Suggestion?

 

[KermitTea]

ofinally

To start off: Bianca or Bangle or Tutu? Since I let go of Merry haha ;_;

Please try to stay within the three unless you can make a really good case for another cutie!

It depends, do you prefer boy or girl villagers? I'd go with Bianca, I had her in my campsite and she's a real cutie, very sweet and come on -- white tigers are cool. //sorry, Bangle

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm thinking of ditching Tucker and replacing him with Rasher (who I really like). Problem is this will mess up the balance in my town since I would have 3 crankies and no lazy. Suggestion?

TBH it doesn't really matter (IMO) whether you have all the personalities in your town, unless you need PWPs or something. I think Rasher is a lot cooler than Tucker, and I totally understand your decision.
Another suggestion is to find a cool lazy other than Tucker that you like?^^;

 

[Stalfos]

TBH it doesn't really matter (IMO) whether you have all the personalities in your town, unless you need PWPs or something. I think Rasher is a lot cooler than Tucker, and I totally understand your decision.
Another suggestion is to find a cool lazy other than Tucker that you like?^^;

Thanks for the input. I'm leaning towards replacing Tucker with Rasher.

 

[AppleCracker]

Frita or Petro?

By the way... The mods might make this one of those stickied threads

 

[KermitTea]

Frita or Petro?

By the way... The mods might make this one of those stickied threads

Judging by your signature, it seems like you have a lot of boy villagers -- so Frita would even that out. However, you do need a smug it seems, and Pietro does brighten up your town (I have him in my cycling town, and tbh he's a lot better than I thought he would be). I like Pietro more, because he's really unique as long as you're not scared of clowns ;D

 

[AppleCracker]

Judging by your signature, it seems like you have a lot of boy villagers -- so Frita would even that out. However, you do need a smug it seems, and Pietro does brighten up your town (I have him in my cycling town, and tbh he's a lot better than I thought he would be). I like Pietro more, because he's really unique as long as you're not scared of clowns ;D

I'm stupid I meant Stinky or Punchy

 

[KermitTea]

I'm stupid I meant Stinky or Punchy

Lol no problem! Okay, looking at your sig, you have like 3 lazy villagers. In terms of looks, I much prefer Punchy. However, if you're looking for PWPs, go with Stinky because he has a jock personality.

 

[KermitTea]

bump ^^

 

[purple Satori]

I'm back at 10 villagers because my 10th spot keeps getting filled when I take a long bus trip.

I've noticed I don't have a smug villager ( I actually never had one) and having a free spot for campers is nice.

Should I try to get rid of Cherry or Sally. The other 8 I like too much to ever let go.

Sally is my 3rd normal villager though I love normals, they are so nice.
Cherry is the new girl in town and I'm trying to get a bus stop in my town since I love riding the bus and I feel my town needs this project.

Being told you have to say goodbye to one of your friends to make a new one is never an easy choice.

 

[KermitTea]

I'm back at 10 villagers because my 10th spot keeps getting filled when I take a long bus trip.

I've noticed I don't have a smug villager ( I actually never had one) and having a free spot for campers is nice.

Should I try to get rid of Cherry or Sally. The other 8 I like too much to ever let go.

Sally is my 3rd normal villager though I love normals, they are so nice.
Cherry is the new girl in town and I'm trying to get a bus stop in my town since I love riding the bus and I feel my town needs this project.

Being told you have to say goodbye to one of your friends to make a new one is never an easy choice.

Ahh that's a hard decision! Sometimes change is good though, because with a new personality you can unlock a bunch of new PWPs. I say let go of Sally because a) you have three normals and, b) you can give cherry a chance Uchis are very nice and caring, and they really remind me of normals! I have Mira and Lolly who live next to each other, and both of them are super nice.

 

[Gizmodo]

Good idea to get Flurry for my food town as a mcflurry? (replacing Molly who will be moving to my first town)
I adore HAMSTERS THEY ARE SO CUTE, but dont want to move Apple from her home of 8 months so Flurry seems a good shot

 

[purple Satori]

What would be the best way to hint to Sally that she needs to go without time traveling. I already have her picture thanks to my 2nd player. Do I just stop talking to her and hope she leaves or shower her with gifts/letters until she leaves or do I just have to wait until she decides she wants to leave.

I don't want to time travel because my Pokemon game throws a fit when I change the clock.
Also thanks for the help.

 

[KermitTea]

Good idea to get Flurry for my food town as a mcflurry? (replacing Molly who will be moving to my first town)
I adore HAMSTERS THEY ARE SO CUTE, but dont want to move Apple from her home of 8 months so Flurry seems a good shot

Flurry would be a good choice for a food town ^_^ reminds me of cream and sundaes and yuminess

- - - Post Merge - - -

What would be the best way to hint to Sally that she needs to go without time traveling. I already have her picture thanks to my 2nd player. Do I just stop talking to her and hope she leaves or shower her with gifts/letters until she leaves or do I just have to wait until she decides she wants to leave.

I don't want to time travel because my Pokemon game throws a fit when I change the clock.
Also thanks for the help.

Ahh that's a hard one. It is really just all on luck lol. If you have villager pics from her, I think you can ignore her. I think it would be good to experiment - eg. Ignore some villagers and talk to some, see who pings etc.

 

[ATotsSpot]

I've never met Static, but I adore the squirrels, AND I like bright colors so he's kind of a dreamie. I do miss having a grump around. However, my daughter has Gaston who I think is pretty awesome, and I also love the bunnies. Who would you choose?

 

[Zeiro]

Drago or Barold?

 

[KermitTea]

I've never met Static, but I adore the squirrels, AND I like bright colors so he's kind of a dreamie. I do miss having a grump around. However, my daughter has Gaston who I think is pretty awesome, and I also love the bunnies. Who would you choose?

Looking at your sig right now, you have 4 bunnies and 3 squirrels ~ If I were you, I would get Static and see if you like him ^_^ since you have Gaston in your daughters town, you can compare the two and get the one you feel is better.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Drago or Barold?

Ahh they're both really good in their own ways! Does your town have a theme or something? Drago's house is very Imperial style while Barold's is more modern. You could choose depending on the theme of your train station or town hall.

 

[ATotsSpot]

Thank you, Karen.

 

[Bearica]

I'm trying to decide on if I want to keep Molly in my 2nd town or get Maple instead. I already have 2 bear cubs I plan on keeping (Bluebear and Tammy) and I don't want too many repeats of the same animal. I had Molly in my main town for about a week or two before giving her away to make room for another villager. I do really like her, but I also really like Maple. I definitely do want Flurry otherwise I wouldn't be having this issue aha.