The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[xSuperMario64x]

9.8/10 very wholesome and fantastic, it would be perfect if you had Zucker
Here I'll try to rank them:
1. Filbert
2. Octavian
3. Flora
4. Skye
5. Marina
6. Lopez
7. Maple
8. Tangy
9. Sprinkle
10. Bob

My villagers:
Leopold, Pietro, Filbert, Bea, Sydney, Pashmina, Chief, Cousteau, Pango, Claudia

 

[SliceAndDice]

Sweet setup you got there. I'd rank them like this:
1. Filbert 2. Pietro 3. Chief 4. Pashmina 5. Bea 6. Cousteau 7. Claudia 8. Sydney 9. Leopold 10. Pango

These are my villagers right now. Love them all, but Cole, Vivian and Wolfgang are probably not staying.

 

[Lavamaize]

Lots of great villagers: heres my ranking:

1. Sherb
2. Wolfgang
3. Raymond
4. Vivian
5. Vesta
6. Dom
7. Reneigh
8. Pietro
9. Chrissy
10. Cole

My villagers include, Croque, Sherb, Ankha, Teddy, Willow, Lyman, Marshal, Shari, Patty, and Punchy. I am currently trying to get rid of shari, patty and punchy.

 

[Meelie]

Here’s my personal list! Please tell me your opinions too!!

10. Savannah
9. Annalise (sorry I just don’t like the horses!)
8. O’Hare
7. Camofrog
6. Erik
5. Antonio
4. Cheri
3. Marina
2. Felicity
1. Teddy

 

[WaileaNoRei]

My personal list. Interested to see other opinions.

10. Chops
9. Deirdre (only cause she has a bunch of ugly clothing from previous island..)
8. Friga
7. Zucker
6. Julia
5. Aurora
4. Audie
3. Gabi
2. Erik
1. Poppy

1. Zucker
2. Julia
3. Friga
4. Audie
5. Deirdre
6. Erik
7. Aurora
8. Poppy
9. Gabi
10. Chops

This was a very tough one except for 1 and 10!

I love zucker, that cute little weirdo.

 

[Xara]

Here’s my personal list! Please tell me your opinions too!!

10. Savannah
9. Annalise (sorry I just don’t like the horses!)
8. O’Hare
7. Camofrog
6. Erik
5. Antonio
4. Cheri
3. Marina
2. Felicity
1. Teddy

10. savannah
9. o’hare
8. camofrog
7. annalise
6. antonio
5. erik
4. teddy
3. cheri
2. felicity
1. marina

 

[Xara]

My villagers include, Croque, Sherb, Ankha, Teddy, Willow, Lyman, Marshal, Shari, Patty, and Punchy. I am currently trying to get rid of shari, patty and punchy.

10. shari
9. croque
8. lyman
7. teddy
6. ankha
5. willow
4. sherb
3. patty
2. marshal
1. punchy

 

[VelveteenCat]

9.8/10 very wholesome and fantastic, it would be perfect if you had Zucker
Here I'll try to rank them:
1. Filbert
2. Octavian
3. Flora
4. Skye
5. Marina
6. Lopez
7. Maple
8. Tangy
9. Sprinkle
10. Bob

My villagers:
Leopold, Pietro, Filbert, Bea, Sydney, Pashmina, Chief, Cousteau, Pango, Claudia

1. Pietro
2. Pashmina
3. Claudia
4. Pango
5. Bea
6. Chief
7. Sydney
8. Filbert
9. Leopold
10. Cousteau

Sweet setup you got there. ☺ I'd rank them like this:
1. Filbert 2. Pietro 3. Chief 4. Pashmina 5. Bea 6. Cousteau 7. Claudia 8. Sydney 9. Leopold 10. Pango

These are my villagers right now. Love them all, but Cole, Vivian and Wolfgang are probably not staying.
View attachment 274057

1. Pietro
2. Vesta
3. Cole
4. Raymond
5. Vivian
6. Wolfgang
7. Dom
8. Chrissy
9. Reneigh
10. Sherb

Lots of great villagers: heres my ranking:

1. Sherb
2. Wolfgang
3. Raymond
4. Vivian
5. Vesta
6. Dom
7. Reneigh
8. Pietro
9. Chrissy
10. Cole

My villagers include, Croque, Sherb, Ankha, Teddy, Willow, Lyman, Marshal, Shari, Patty, and Punchy. I am currently trying to get rid of shari, patty and punchy.

1. Willow
2. Ankha
3. Punchy
4. Shari
5. Marshal
6. Croque
7. Teddy
8. Patty
9. Lyman
10. Sherb

Here’s my personal list! Please tell me your opinions too!!

10. Savannah
9. Annalise (sorry I just don’t like the horses!)
8. O’Hare
7. Camofrog
6. Erik
5. Antonio
4. Cheri
3. Marina
2. Felicity
1. Teddy

1. Felicity
2. Antonio
3. Marina
4. Erik
5. O'Hare
6. Cheri
7. Teddy
8. Savannah
9. Annalise
10. Camofrog

These are mine: Groucho, Tabby, Lucky, Annalisa, Cherry, Chops, Olaf, Olivia, Felicity, Gloria.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Sweet setup you got there. ☺ I'd rank them like this:
1. Filbert 2. Pietro 3. Chief 4. Pashmina 5. Bea 6. Cousteau 7. Claudia 8. Sydney 9. Leopold 10. Pango

These are my villagers right now. Love them all, but Cole, Vivian and Wolfgang are probably not staying.
View attachment 274057

1. Cole
2. Dom
3. Sherb
4. Vesta
5. Raymond
6. Chrissy
7. Wolfgang
8. Pietro
9. Vivian
10. Reneigh

Cute group! Hope to see who you eventually replace those three with.

Post automatically merged: Jun 14, 2020

Here’s my personal list! Please tell me your opinions too!!

10. Savannah
9. Annalise (sorry I just don’t like the horses!)
8. O’Hare
7. Camofrog
6. Erik
5. Antonio
4. Cheri
3. Marina
2. Felicity
1. Teddy

1. O’Hare
2. Marina
3. Savannah
4. Erik
5. Teddy (his eyebrows are amazing!)
6. Felicity
7. Cheri
8. Camofrog
9. Antonio
10. Annalise (I also do not like the horse, with the one exception being Savannah)

 

[LaFra]

Sweet setup you got there. ☺ I'd rank them like this:
1. Filbert 2. Pietro 3. Chief 4. Pashmina 5. Bea 6. Cousteau 7. Claudia 8. Sydney 9. Leopold 10. Pango

These are my villagers right now. Love them all, but Cole, Vivian and Wolfgang are probably not staying.
View attachment 274057

1) Sherb
2) Dom
3) Raymond
4) Wolfgang
5) Reneigh
6) Vivian
7) Vesta
8) Pietro
9) Chrissy
10) Cole

 

[SliceAndDice]

1. Cole
2. Dom
3. Sherb
4. Vesta
5. Raymond
6. Chrissy
7. Wolfgang
8. Pietro
9. Vivian
10. Reneigh

Cute group! Hope to see who you eventually replace those three with.

Post automatically merged: Jun 14, 2020

Thank you. Glad to see some love for Cole
Wolfgang is gone now and I'm hoping to replace him with Murphy, but he seems almost impossible to get.

1. O’Hare
2. Marina
3. Savannah
4. Erik
5. Teddy (his eyebrows are amazing!)
6. Felicity
7. Cheri
8. Camofrog
9. Antonio
10. Annalise (I also do not like the horse, with the one exception being Savannah)

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Lots of great villagers: heres my ranking:

1. Sherb
2. Wolfgang
3. Raymond
4. Vivian
5. Vesta
6. Dom
7. Reneigh
8. Pietro
9. Chrissy
10. Cole

My villagers include, Croque, Sherb, Ankha, Teddy, Willow, Lyman, Marshal, Shari, Patty, and Punchy. I am currently trying to get rid of shari, patty and punchy.

1. Willow
2. Croque
3. Shari
4. Ankha
5. Punchy
6. Sherb
7. Marshal
8. Teddy
9. Lyman
10. Patty

 

[Xara]

My villagers:
Leopold, Pietro, Filbert, Bea, Sydney, Pashmina, Chief, Cousteau, Pango, Claudia

10. claudia
9. chief
8. leopold
7. filbert
6. pango
5. bea
4. pietro
3. sydney
2. cousteau
1. pashmina

 

[Verecund]

My villagers:
Leopold, Pietro, Filbert, Bea, Sydney, Pashmina, Chief, Cousteau, Pango, Claudia

1. Filbert
2. Claudia
3. Sydney
4. Pashmina
5. Bea
6. Pango
7. Chief
8. Leopold
9. Pietro
10. Cousteau

These are my villagers right now. Love them all, but Cole, Vivian and Wolfgang are probably not staying.

1. Sherb
2. Raymond
3. Chrissy
4. Reneigh
5. Vivian
6. Vesta
7. Cole
8. Wolfgang
9. Dom
10. Pietro

My villagers include, Croque, Sherb, Ankha, Teddy, Willow, Lyman, Marshal, Shari, Patty, and Punchy. I am currently trying to get rid of shari, patty and punchy.

1. Marshal
2. Sherb
3. Patty
4. Punchy
5. Willow
6. Ankha
7. Lyman
8. Teddy
9. Shari
10. Croque

Here’s my personal list! Please tell me your opinions too!!

10. Savannah
9. Annalise (sorry I just don’t like the horses!)
8. O’Hare
7. Camofrog
6. Erik
5. Antonio
4. Cheri
3. Marina
2. Felicity
1. Teddy

1. Felicity
2. Savannah
3. Cheri
4. Erik
5. Annalise
6. Camofrog
7. Marina
8. Antonio
9. Teddy
10. O'Hare

These are mine: Groucho, Tabby, Lucky, Annalisa, Cherry, Chops, Olaf, Olivia, Felicity, Gloria.

1. Felicity
2. Olivia
3. Annalisa
4. Gloria
5. Lucky
6. Groucho
7. Cherry
8. Olaf
9. Chops

 

[deleted]

I have new addition on my island so I want to do this again. Here is my personal rating.

1. Eunice
2. Hornsby
3. Kabuki
4. June
5. Willow
6. Audie
7. Biskit
8. Sprinkle
9. Marina (I have too many normal villagers and she’s my least favorite of them)
10. Hamlet (I want him gone)

I would say that 2–8 are fairly equal. I love most of my villagers. Eunice is my absolute favorite, though.

 

[Magus]

View attachment 274057

Here how I'll rank them :
1. Vesta
2. Cole
3. Sherb
4. Pietro
5. Vivian
6. Raymond
7. Reneigh
8. Dom
9. Wolfgang
10. Chrissy

I really like your villagers ! And I have a recent obsession with Vesta lol
The only one I strongly don't like is Chrissy...

These are mine: Groucho, Tabby, Lucky, Annalisa, Cherry, Chops, Olaf, Olivia, Felicity, Gloria.

So :
1. Olivia
2. Tabby
3. Annalisa
4. Cherry
5. Lucky
6. Groucho
7. Gloria
8. Olaf
9. Felicity
10. Chops

I like that your list is uncommon and so quite unique ! Plus I can sense your visual universe/tastes because of it and I appreciate that.
Personally I don't really like Olaf, Felicity and Chops though.

 

[Thanedd]

Currently these are mine

Phoebe, Drago, Gayle, Sprinkle, Ribbot, Naomi, Amelia, Twiggy, Leopold and Gruff

 

[Xara]

These are my villagers right now. Love them all, but Cole, Vivian and Wolfgang are probably not staying.
View attachment 274057

10. reneigh
9. wolfgang
8. chrissy
7. dom
6. raymond
5. vesta
4. sherb
3. cole
2. pietro
1. vivian

 

[WaileaNoRei]

9.8/10 very wholesome and fantastic, it would be perfect if you had Zucker
Here I'll try to rank them:
1. Filbert
2. Octavian
3. Flora
4. Skye
5. Marina
6. Lopez
7. Maple
8. Tangy
9. Sprinkle
10. Bob

My villagers:
Leopold, Pietro, Filbert, Bea, Sydney, Pashmina, Chief, Cousteau, Pango, Claudia

1. Pashmina (people seem to take really cute videos and pictures of her on their islands!)
2. Pango
3. Sydney
4. Claudia
5. Leopold (reminds me of Lionel, for obvious reasons, who was my forced smug. I really grew to like him, even though he has now moved on).
6. Bea
7. Cousteau (weirdly cute, my
8. Chief
9. Filbert
10. Pietro

What a unique group! I’d never even heard of Sydney!

 

[Wolfie]

Here are mine (though Sylvia is leaving soon and I am working on getting two new ones)

1) Leonardo
2) Sylvia
3) Apollo
4) Ellie
5) Stitches
6) Butch
7) Rosie
8) Julian
9) Nate