Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

I mean seriously, literally everyone in this thread except for like Mog has started ganging up on me. Like choo choo Ness switched off Jacbob at the last second and pushed trundle and is inactive!!!!!

Nobody else seeing this? C'mon.
 
I mean seriously, literally everyone in this thread except for like Mog has started ganging up on me. Like choo choo Ness switched off Jacbob at the last second and pushed trundle and is inactive!!!!!

Nobody else seeing this? C'mon.

it's really just toad and vanessa really pushing for your lynch to be fair, i think others are willing to hear you out
 
I mean seriously, literally everyone in this thread except for like Mog has started ganging up on me. Like choo choo Ness switched off Jacbob at the last second and pushed trundle and is inactive!!!!!

Nobody else seeing this? C'mon.

It’s not as strong as the punchy thing, otherwise I would note that

- - - Post Merge - - -

And I still would rather lynch bianca or Chele, but I mean I would def prefer you lynches over punchy ffs

- - - Post Merge - - -

Although punchy essentially resigning from doing anything, pisses me off because he is just asking for death
 
Toads do you have other reasons for scumreading Chele other than her counting the votes instead of participating actively
 
Hi everyone. I would like to remind everyone that since I’m going by the rules stated in the setup section of post 2, Day Three will be the final phase I will replace players. After that I’ll have to modkill

So if you need to leave the game for any reason, please let me know so I don’t have to modkill your spot.

Tae has been prodded for inactivity.
 
Ness your inactivity is fair, aside from the other points you mentioned though you are also likely to be mafia based on PoE on who is left, as many of the remaining players are being townread.

unravel, Heyden and Mog are pretty townread across the board, Rune/Kallie is being mostly townread after Rune's reaction now I believe, everyone townreads me except Mog and Toads, Toads we are conflicted on but I personally think he is town. Dedenne is also mostly townread across the board as far as I know.

So the scumpool in my eyes is you/Punchy/tae (who is probably going to be modkilled)/Chele/Bianca. And Chele and Bianca will be clear imo if Punchy flips scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean seriously, literally everyone in this thread except for like Mog has started ganging up on me. Like choo choo Ness switched off Jacbob at the last second and pushed trundle and is inactive!!!!!

Nobody else seeing this? C'mon.

Oh and Jacbob also townleaned you for seemingly no reason, which some people find suspicious

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ness when you have time could you make a reads list

- - - Post Merge - - -

please
 
''Reads and other stuff come later since I'm at school but hot damn do some of the people that are on me right now are reaching with this push on me.''
 
Also, Night Two will be ending tonight at 10PM EST (See countdown in OP). If you would like to change your action, you have until then.
 
Last edited:
I'll elaborate later but here is a hot take: heyden/tae/toadsworthy/biancasbotique have the scum in them. Some of these players that are being super townread need to be reevaluated.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and I guess Punchy or Chele are alternatives in that list, but I'm not so sure about either of them at the moment.
 
I'll elaborate later but here is a hot take: heyden/tae/toadsworthy/biancasbotique have the scum in them. Some of these players that are being super townread need to be reevaluated.

That is a very hot take indeed I am interested in hearing this
 
:(

I figured I might go instead of Punchy. Reticence on the Jacob vote was my downfall. Oh well, let's go win this town!!
 
Chele’s day one posts asked a lot of questions but I don’t really see what any of it has done... and have we gotten full reads for her on everyone? Her questions seemed directed mostly at punchy to build up a case and she’s doing that thing where she hyper focuses on one person the whole time to avoid giving reads on anyone else. If her and punchy are scum together then wtf, I highly doubt punchy is scum which means she could be picking on him. Her and Jacobs interaction was like nonexistent too which looks like subconscious bussing on their part.

The doing votes end of day looks like trying to be active with doing as little content wise as possible and really rubs me the wrong way. Combine that with how she was the one to jump at showing the numbers for lynches and kills and it looks like trying to look townie, but upon reading through... it doesn’t get us much and all I know of her from this game is that she really wants punchy dead

I’m fonna do reads later with analysis of possible partners before the end of the night. Stay tuned
 
im ignoring all meta stuff because im not going to go back and read 20 games nor do i really remember most of you.

also

Stop ****posting I have to read through all of this

Vanessa's N1 defense of herself as king.

Interesting. I know others disagreed at the time, but imo I townread her for this.

Lord Dolby and Lord Trundle were found murdered last night. Their loyalty to the King shall not be forgotten.

LOL OWNED. trundle youre so cocky lmfaooo i need to introduce you to my friend because you both are so arrogant.

i mean if punchy does flip maf don't their kp get reduced? maf is gonna try anything to save him even if it looks RLY shady, maybe that was unfortunately rune's job : (

KP doesn't matter if the rest of the team goes down for trying to save it. also, "was"?

You?re sussing me for coasting through EoD, but how about Rune. She participated less than I did.

You two are different people. In two different situations. It's not easy to just compare like that.


If punchy flips scum I think obv lynch toads next, they're WAY too buddy-buddy.

With the fact they are already down 1 mafia, and in the event that they lost another mafia, Toad being mafia as well is unlikely. That would be risky and if scum!Toad knows he cannot change town's mind, there is no point in him trying to save Punchy. Yes, the KP may go down. Yes, Punchy may be some important role. But that doesn't matter if you end up exposing the rest of the team.

Regardless, I do not view Toad as scummy for defending Punchy.

idk if it's u or rune that's maf : ( it's sad

Why is Vanessa scummy now at this point to you?

i guess maybe mafia are so desperate they told rune just to go pick a random slightly scummy person : ( but that would make run mafia ofc. ok i'm gonna go now i'm driving myself insane

Mafia should know it would be suicide for one of their members to make such a mistake. If anything, a more logical choice would be to lynch Tae for being essentially inactive at that point.

I'm honestly going to say Rune probably chose Evan because she had some kind of gut feeling. If rune was mafia, and is obviously under stress and anxiety atm, she would have followed what mafia would have said. I don't think mafia (being 2 other people with Rune) would make such a big mistake. Rune was seen as null or slight townlean, and lynching someone totally random is odd.

If mafia wanted to make it seem believable, they would have told Rune to either kill Tae (could say gut feeling for the inactivity), Bianca, or Ness. I understand that Rune suspected Evan and therefore an argument could be made that "oh she just doubled back and went with her gut!" If it was this thought out, mafia would be telling Rune to calm down and to just explain why.

The fact that Rune panicked and left the game should tell you all (since I already know rune/I are town) that no one was helping her. No one has been coaching her on what to say. She was just anxious and alone.

edit: By the time I wrote all of that I got to the point in the thread where everyone backed off of rune. lmfao. I'm not deleting that tho. I can't believe I just wasted writing a psuedo defense for myself smh.

did u just confirm him as townie?? lmao SCUMSLIP
How is that a scumslip?


Dolby said this
https://www.belltreeforums.com/show...es-Night-Two&p=8090762&viewfull=1#post8090762

very early on, and I've kept it in my mind.

I understand Dolby's perspective, but without his thoughts I would have actually townread Toad and Punchy. I am doubting myself, but I townread Toad for now. I will elaborate on this once day comes.

Chele for my scum lean.


townread on Bianca

blahblah antonio

I read a LOT about Trundle and Ness. In response to some people thinking they were fake almost, Ness's posts looked genuine to me for some reason. Trundle not so much, but he's been nailing into our heads this isn't his normal gameplay so whatever. No way they're maf together

I feel like Chele is the most town because from what I've seen they're pushing with some good in game evidence, not a lot of meta which is the easy route in this game right now


I find Jacob's lean on Chele interesting. Chele does not question Jacob either.
Also I bolded the part where Jacob mentions Ness, I am currently null on Ness but I thought it would be interesting since Ness is the hot topic so far.


You state that Bianca has a scummy tone rn, but the thing is that her tone seems like she is Town. She is answering questions and isn't keeping to herself much (that's something that scum Bianca would do). Although she mostly says "lynch inactives!", at least she contributes tbh. Also I agree on her part when she said that she's more good on day 2-3, because in one of the games where I was mafia (bleh), Bianca was like the most useful townie, and she didn't really have an informal or formal tone. She stepped up in the game towards the last few days, and we could sorta tell why she's not indulged in conversation right now. We are still at that awkward early game conversation stage in all honesty.
Also if not Bianca, then who'd you want to lynch?

Hmm, they defend Bianca together. How sweet <3

Tbh, I haven't really seen anything from her besides wanting to lynch Punchy. But I also read really fast so maybe I missed a bit. But I never saw Chele say anything about Jacob. Or anything too strong of an opinion. (feel free to correct me if i am wrong)

As for the other 2, if Chele = scum then bianca = scum. The other person I'd consider is Heyden, but Heyden did probe Bianca a little bit at the beginning (which then gave Jacob the chance to defend Bianca).

Also, since I am such a nice person and volunteered my time to play, can someone help me with my calculus hw. thanks pm me on discord rofl
 
That was insane fast reading omk thank you kallie
You and toads have a good point on Chele only focusing on punchy and not really giving other reads, as well as not interacting with Jacob. If punchy is not scum she could definitely be scum
 
vanessa is scummy because she jumped on ness the second toad did, bc her jacob reaction felt forced, she claims to want punchy lynched but if push comes to shove i don't think she has any real intention of lynching him since she scumreads ness/bianca more. and now she's jumping on chelle too, all her scum reads are based on her just copying someone's else's opinion, granted she does come up with her own evidence later but it feels incredibly wrong to me

it's not really a strong scum lean, but i do find her suspicious. i'd still rather toad and punchy go first

- - - Post Merge - - -

anyway staying up until 4am every night is taking its toll on me so i'm leaving this thread for a while, i'll probably be back for end of day but i guess i might have just fell asleep (3am for me remember)
 
I think I went after ness first

- - - Post Merge - - -

I was also literally the first person to say Bianca was scummy

- - - Post Merge - - -

People just forget what I do in every game and say I am sleeping or copying other people when I'm not always. And when I am, it's because I am actually considering other peoples ideas and not being stubborn like people often are on this site in mafia. Idk why that's a bad thing

- - - Post Merge - - -

*sheeping not sleeping
 
I think I went after ness first

- - - Post Merge - - -

I was also literally the first person to say Bianca was scummy

- - - Post Merge - - -

People just forget what I do in every game and say I am sleeping or copying other people when I'm not always. And when I am, it's because I am actually considering other peoples ideas and not being stubborn like people often are on this site in mafia. Idk why that's a bad thing

- - - Post Merge - - -

*sheeping not sleeping

i haven't played with u before it's nothing personal : ( it's not a bad thing but it is when toad is mafia and ness is town to me u kno, i appreciate you take into account other people's opinions
 
Back
Top