Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[toadsworthy]

one thing that makes me think punchy might be mafia is that he hasn't claimed yet - he would normally have claimed a long time ago, i think, if he was town

This is honestly a better point than anything else I hear right now

 

[Dolby]

one thing that makes me think punchy might be mafia is that he hasn't claimed yet - he would normally have claimed a long time ago, i think, if he was town

Tbf, he only claims early when blue I think

 

[Antonio]

I don't think punchy is scum. His meta is quite similar to the previous game, despite his reactions to being Lynched. I'm placing my vote on Trundle this time around because him voting for Vanessa was weird to me. I need to catch up though, btw.

 

[toadsworthy]

i'm not patronising him, or at least i'm not trying to, i'm actually trying to understand him, even defending him by saying isn't his play much like this as town (erratic and clumsy) so

Yeah and I just said it was. He literally boos around from person to person thought to thought like every game. And then something he does locks him in by PoE and he coasts, whether he is scum or not. Hence why I looked at more of what he was saying than doing because it’s not indicative of him at all... if you read the games from then it’s what happened

 

[Dolby]

Is it on the people who haven’t played in a year?

For one of them, Bianca is one of the few semi-regular players left if we don't count this game

But he doesn't source his meta, and I doubt that he's even reread those games

 

[PunchyTheCat]

HI PEOPLE

so if you don't think that I'm mafia and you want to save my slot vote Jacob, he's the highest wagon that's not me.

 

[amazonevan19]

HI PEOPLE

so if you don't think that I'm mafia and you want to save my slot vote Jacob, he's the highest wagon that's not me.

Any reason to vote him besides saving your ass?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

desparate times call for desparate measures

 

[toadsworthy]

The single thing (well, two) that I actually dislike most about Punchy is that he's locking all of his reads with small statements about year old meta, and his evidence doesn't match up 25% of the time

You’re applying rules of analysis for a typica player when this is freaking punchy we’re talkig about

 

[EpicGamer12]

desparate times call for desparate measures

can you claim?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

can you claim?

lordy no

(I'm vanilla and that's why I didn't claim js)

 

[toadsworthy]

For one of them, Bianca is one of the few semi-regular players left if we don't count this game

But he doesn't source his meta, and I doubt that he's even reread those games

Does punchy really ever quote meta? Idk I dont really see punchy as scum because it?s literal the same **** each time with him. He very well could be and I?m falling for it again, but idk where y?all are pulling this in context to punchy

 

[amazonevan19]

Frankly it seems a lot of people are voting/sussing Jacob because he dares express opinions contrary to groupthink. Though I found his thinking to be a bit lazy, it's also day 1 and I don't see a super strong reason to sus him aside from contrarian thinking, which...isn't AI to me atm.

 

[Jacob]

How about everyone just votes who they think is mafia. Mafia can hide in bandwagoning against me or anybody

Vanessa doesn't have to vote the majority, I'm sure the kingmaker made her king because whoever she votes is a reflection on her alignment too one way or another

 

[amazonevan19]

could the anti punchy tags be removed please? It only feeds into an atmosphere of negativity and hurts Punchy's feelings.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Frankly it seems a lot of people are voting/sussing Jacob because he dares express opinions contrary to groupthink. Though I found his thinking to be a bit lazy, it's also day 1 and I don't see a super strong reason to sus him aside from contrarian thinking, which...isn't AI to me atm.

your argument here is a bit fallacious because you're assuming that voting jacob is groupthink, when in reality only 2-3 people are voting him. the groupthink right now is voting punchy

 

[Dolby]

Frankly it seems a lot of people are voting/sussing Jacob because he dares express opinions contrary to groupthink. Though I found his thinking to be a bit lazy, it's also day 1 and I don't see a super strong reason to sus him aside from contrarian thinking, which...isn't AI to me atm.

What

Jacob is sus because the reasoning behind his Unravel/Mog/Trundle push make no sense

- - - Post Merge - - -

How about everyone just votes who they think is mafia. Mafia can hide in bandwagoning against me or anybody

Vanessa doesn't have to vote the majority, I'm sure the kingmaker made her king because whoever she votes is a reflection on her alignment too one way or another

We already ****ing are

 

[Biancasbotique]

could the anti punchy tags be removed please? It only feeds into an atmosphere of negativity and hurts Punchy's feelings.

have a feeling punchy put the punchy die there almost sure of that

 

[Dolby]

Also his tone is weird

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hot take, Punchy/Jacob is s/s

 

[toadsworthy]

I

Frankly it seems a lot of people are voting/sussing Jacob because he dares express opinions contrary to groupthink. Though I found his thinking to be a bit lazy, it's also day 1 and I don't see a super strong reason to sus him aside from contrarian thinking, which...isn't AI to me atm.

I scumread jacob last game for the same thing and he was blue.... people are saying so and so is lazy, or so and so is erratic... when those people are known to just be lazy and erratic. Hence why if you read what they say moreso then it can be more helpful right now since we don’t have anything else to go off of. Like people saying punchy is erratic punchynis maf, don’t know punchy