Mafia Super Smash Bros: Mafia! Game over! Mafia wins!

[Geoni]

I'm placing my vote on Call Me Daniel. Here are the reasons.

1. He claimed a veteran with 3 night lives. This is a very blatant lie, as that would be overpowered in a game with 18 or so players.

2. As I mentioned earlier, he flip flopped on StarryWolf (even though he doesn't seem to be able to read his own posts and admit it) super hard and basically realized that after Endless and I were pushing Starry he would just get it over with so as to look like a town player because he knew Starry was mafia.

3. We will be a lot closer to finding mafia this game regardless of his flip.

1 is a logical response. My response too.

2 is Trundle trying to take credit where it isn't due. Endless was the true pusher there, you bandwagoned imo and you still try to accuse another player of bandwagoning.

3 uh...well I'll see how you guys did. My guess is no.

-pg 59

- - - Post Merge - - -

I've had my doubts about Daniel since he and Starry began.... well... the 'salt train' for lack of a better expression.
Anytime someone shares their view on him, and if he's seen as mafia by them, he'll immediately flip and defend his position. Not to mention you were for random lynching (since if no one else votes, cheese will get lynched unless he unvotes), and now he's against it, saying it's not good. He's doing an awful lot of flip-flopping, even if he is a townie.

Here's where Daniel's lynch began. From this point forward I'm reading for people who tried hard to make the Daniel lynch happen, they're kinda sus in hindsight although I'm kind of cheating here. Especially considering there was a vig and time to test those 3 life claims out seeing that it's still unclear who vig is.

-pg 59

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yes I admit I was inactive in the beginning, that was because I wasn't into the game that much in the beginning, and I really wanted to make up for that. Plus I'm not experienced or was able to give much helpful input. The only reason I claimed to randomly lynching was because of the fact that there wasn't any discussion or evidence that was broght up after day 2 started, and that's the first outcome that came up in my head. To be fair, I honestly had a scummy feeling about you, before anyone brought put their claims, but I didn't want you lynched too early because I was interested in what you'd bring to assist with townies.

'I was interested in what you'd bring to assist with townies'

What does that even mean? Continuing not to give reads on things you promised here too. I've still got 20 pages to go and I'm going to end for the night soon, so I'll give you that. But still. I'm not going to accept coasting even though I'm leaning towards accepting your newbtells.

-pg 59

- - - Post Merge - - -

I said I'd consider it, but some of the things he brought up even if it wasn't that good of a claim I actually thought about.
Honestly I'm thinking of the outcomes depending on who I lynch. I think I'll stick to voting on lynching Daniel, unless someone brings up something that catches my eye, since the outcomes of lynching Daniel are actually better, or at least in my head they are.

How, in your head, were the outcomes better? Curious into reading how you explained that away or how you will.

-pg 60

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm starting to wonder where pillow bunny is, they said they were reading but disappeared after.

also this, at the point of pg 60

- - - Post Merge - - -

Aaand I'm reading Ender's ISO on Kit, I'm going to guess this is what made her panic out as the cop.

I'm also done for the night tbh, and at this point of my review I'm not liking nintendofan because of that randomly placed 'uh...', Trundle because of the bandwagoning accusations (can't wait for him to flip over being called a hypocrite), and I'm kinda getting bad vibes from pillow but that's just one of those 'this person is dangerously inactive and could be mafia coasting' kind of vibes. Oath had been coasting up until this point and promises that he gave reads more recently, will read into that. I'm holding monkey accountable for responding to some of the things I asked them, some stuff is leaving a bad taste in my mouth and they're consistently making excuses.

Only townreads rn of alive are Kit, Luca, and Haydenn. Not finished yet though.

- - - Post Merge - - -

...Oh yeah and Cory. Forgot he's my fellow replacement. No reads on him...like always he's really good at not being able to be read.

 

[Monkeyd99]

Okay, yes I promised a case, but I don't know where to start. I wanted to post a case because a lot of people were questioning inactives (which I was in the beginning) and bringing up that they wanted the inactives to post something useful.

The randomly lynching an inactive only came to my mind since day 2 happened on new years eve, new years day and the day after that, or about. No one was very active, not even Ness for that matter, and I didn't know who to point fingers at since I have only ever played mafia on another form 2 years ago and I didn't know what to base my claims on.

The Dolby claim was over a joke post from before the game started so thats about the end of it.

About being interested in Daniel, in the beginning he seemed like an interesting character, I couldn't really for sure tell if he was scum or not, that's why I put the 'I was interested in what you'd bring to assist with townies' into my argument.

should I lynch Kit or Daniel? Honestly either one is okay with me, because if Kit is Mafia that's awesome if not then Daniel stands a higher chance in being mafia, if Daniel is mafia that's awesome, if he isn't then Trundle stands a higher chance of being mafia but Trundle and Daniel currently strike me as playing like townies so I'm not sure honestly.

This is basically what I said in my head. There was also the fact that Kit claimed cop, and not really anyone was defending Daniel well, so I just kept my vote and went to bed. Though then after that they brought up nintendofan, and I wish I'd changed my vote after, when I woke up after it turned night.

Ask me anything if that'll help you read me as townie, and I am really a newbie, even if you don't believe it that well.

 

[Cory]

please actually attempt to be useful

oh like you are being useful

 

[oath2order]

oh like you are being useful

Moreso than you.

 

[Cory]

I do some stuff later

- - - Post Merge - - -

*i'll

 

[Kit]

I've got some information
Well not really
I was Rb'd as I suspected, Mafia has a consort ^_^ (Or we have a really dumb escort)
I was told to inspect the following people, Trundle, Nintendofan, Haydenn
Make of that what you will

 

[Cory]

Who ever is the doctor good job because you weren't an idiot and didn't out

 

[Monkeyd99]

I've got some information
Well not really
I was Rb'd as I suspected, Mafia has a consort ^_^ (Or we have a really dumb escort)
I was told to inspect the following people, Trundle, Nintendofan, Haydenn
Make of that what you will

So at least 1 of those three are mafia.... maybe more than one. If I make an assumption I can't really support it but I'm putting my money on Haydenn.

 

[Kit]

So at least 1 of those three are mafia.... maybe more than one. If I make an assumption I can't really support it but I'm putting my money on Haydenn.

Oh & you

 

[Monkeyd99]

Oh & you

The fact that basically everyone forgets me, except Dad I think is the only one who gave any reads about me at all.

 

[Geoni]

Everyone in this game is saying they'll do stuff later. You're all coasting scumbags. Now, if you don't mind, I'm not going to swoop in and make my reads/decisions until later tonight and I won't be responding much to the ten pages I didn't get to last night outside a few quotes because god that was exhausting.

Also I like how monkey's larger post on page 83 is their thoughts on Daniel vs Kit speaking as if they're still alive until the last paragraph. And they didn't go back and edit before they posted or something. idk, just the way it's worded. Either way, that's a huge newbtell right there and tbh outside of Kit monkey is my largest townread in this game alongside Luca.

 

[oath2order]

wow ok

 

[Geoni]

So the big behavior quirks that I don't like have stood the test of reading just a few more pages: I don't like nintendofan and Trundle, something about the both of them give me a bad vibe. So on the note of nintendofan, I don't like their response to monkey here:

Do you guys wanna just randomly lynch one of the inactives? We don't have much to go off of today, and day 2 ends in 12 hours or about.

Uh...

nintendofan's response here is to monkey's quote I provided above. What I don't like about this is that now that I've townread monkey as somebody who is authentically playing as a new player who is making weird posts that come from the place of not having played before, along with their reaction to me and that this is obvious to mafia as somebody who can be manipulated, the moment that a new player says something as anti-town as this, mafia would take it as an opportunity to get a mislynch on somebody where they can. They haven't followed through with it given there is time, but I can see mafia appearing and trying to make it happen. Furthermore, the only activity they've had since that 'uh' post is them making excuses for their activity, which to me comes off as giving reason to coast until the person who wants to lead against monkey comes around. Furthermore, the Kirby claim doesn't sit right with me, but mostly because if I was host I'd make Kirby a jack of all trades and give it to Dad because Kirby was his main for all three smash brother games.

Also, I'm still waiting for Trundle to reappear and respond to what I brought up - where is he? I still stand by that he's a hypocrite in his bandwagoning accusations against Daniel that he used as his reason to vote for him.

Seeing that Monday is going to be a super busy day for me irl, I'm placing my vote on nintendofan at the moment but might change depending on how somebody responds to me.

 

[oath2order]

Kirby WOULD be a jack of all trades, good call there

 

[Geoni]

There have been four smash games, I'm sorry. But I don't care about the new one b/c I have melee.

 

[oath2order]

nobody got anything?

 

[ZetaFunction]

nobody got anything?

Is it just me, or did this game die?

Since no one is obviously gonna be posting stuff today, if I'm free later today/tonight, I'll try to reread everything and give my opinions about what's happened so far. No guarantees (in case something pops up); I have suspicions right now, but I just wanna reread and confirm them before I share anything.

 

[oath2order]

**** it, I'm sus of Trundle just going off the first kills. He would kill Tom.

 

[Monkeyd99]

I liked Dad's claim of Nintendo's suspicious behavior but I have my doubts, I don't really have anything to say now. And the game probably died when a bunch of the active players were either lynched or killed.

 

[Trundle]

Hey guys, I don't really have much to say in defense to this. I am not mafia but in truth, if I were, I would kill Tom. I'm not sure where Dad is saying I was bandwagoning on StarryWolf when I was the first one to bring up suspicions of her. I didn't feel the need to reiterate my points because I had already said them. Either way, a day one lynch is a day one lynch and we did good on it.