Should I let a third "normal" villager into my town?

[Squiver]

Bettina is in my campsite. She's a cutie, and her color scheme might fit the autumnal/pastoral thing I'm going for with my town, but I already also have Lolly and Nan. I don't know if having three villagers of the same personality type will get annoying.

What do you think? I need advice!

 

[Raffy]

It depends if you like the Normal Personality.
If you don't like them, it will probably get annoying having 3 of them.

 

[Mega_Cabbage]

I think you should. If you haven't gotten annoyed by having two normals by now, then a third probably won't make much of a difference.

 

[inkling]

I have asked myself this question a few times. What I think if you really like all 3 villagers then go ahead and do it. I don't think it'd get annoying bc even though they're all the same personality they will still show originality. I find there's more variation among the normal villagers anyways. For example, Flurry seem completely different from Lolly. They had different sayings, etc.

 

[Idfldnsndt]

I've had three normal villagers in my town at once before and it's perfectly fine, i dont think the dialogue gets boring or anything like that.

 

[Snowfell]

Personally I think it gets a little boring if there's more than two of any type at once. I would keep her in mind if Lolly or Nan ever move out though, because I don't cycle for villagers so I always like to have an alternate to look for in case someone does move out without pinging me. But that's just me.

 

[Squiver]

Well, I decided to get her. I'm still not sure, but I figure it's easier to have her, decide I don't like her, and get rid of her, than it would be to find her again if I ever decided I definitely need her for my town.

We'll see! Thank you everyone!

 

[kuseiro]

I have four normals in my town and it gets... quite bland. I'm currently working on my second town and have limited it to 2 villagers per personality type at most \o/

Glad to see you're going with it though <: Bettina is a cutie

 

[TheGreatBrain]

I have Bettina in one of my towns. I didn't plan on getting her, but when she showed up in my campsite, I just couldn't resist. I really like her, and I'm so glad I have her in my town.

 

[eeveelovee]

Normal personality is my favourite, in my opinion. Theyre humble and bookish and wont get mad when you refuse to run them an errand. Lol

 

[erikaeliseh]

i have 4 normals! i love them

 

[zeoli]

What could it hurt to have another normal villager? I know from my experience with the same personality types, I haven't gotten annoyed with the same text. But I just kinda expect it, ya know? If you're easy to get annoyed, then don't do it. If you aren't or are unsure, might as well give Bettina a try! If you DO end up getting annoyed, you don't always have to keep the three and just get rid of the one you like the least! Hope my two cents helped.

 

[CJODell62]

I have three normal villagers in Granada. I'd say wait for a popular normal like Lolly or Maple.

 

[Biskit11]

Yea I love having four lazies.

 

[ams]

No, I have three and they're all cute but I need to get rid of one for some dialogue variety. I always forget to talk to at least one of them when I play.

 

[cannolis]

I wouldn't, that seems pretty boring. I don't allow more the two of the same personality type in my town.