Should I kick out Julia, Twiggy, Phoebe or Flora to add Monique on my island?

[Cosmic-chan]

So I'm sick of birds. I have too many. Should I get rid of one for Monique? Or keep them? Phoebe was my first villager ever. Twiggy was like my third. Flora I found on an awesome nmt island and Julia was random. (Disregard the fact Flora is here twice that was a mistake. ovo; I don't hate her that much.)

 

[senbeiiscool]

I chose Twiggy because of my own personal preference but I would choose between Flora and Twiggy since they're both the same personality type

 

[kojuuro]

You have flora twice on your poll, so I guess flora?? (tho she's really cute!!) There are a lot of bird villagers here though, so if you want to change up your species, I don't blame you. They're all super cute though (but i'd prob pick twiggy in the end)

 

[Blueskyy]

Twiggy is cool. I wouldn’t kick out any of them for Monique. Voted for a Flora anyway.

 

[Cosmic-chan]

You have flora twice on your poll, so I guess flora?? (tho she's really cute!!) There are a lot of bird villagers here though, so if you want to change up your species, I don't blame you. They're all super cute though (but i'd prob pick twiggy in the end)

Ack I do have Flora twice!! I feel dumb,,I cant fix it. I do love Flora a lot,, I did just set her house up with nice decorations,, it's just so hard to choose! I might give one of them away for stuff idk

 

[Lokidoki]

Who are all you villagers? That's a lot of ostriches hehe

Twiggy and Flora are both peppies, does dialogue bother you? If you love ostriches i vote Twiggy shes kinda boring.

 

[Cethosia]

I would actually say Phoebe, just because of the starter house. I have her and her house is literally a volcano. If you don't care about that however, I would say Flora or Twiggy. Julia is really pretty

 

[Cosmic-chan]

Who are all you villagers? That's a lot of ostriches hehe

Twiggy and Flora are both peppies, does dialogue bother you? If you love ostriches i vote Twiggy shes kinda boring.

There the same in terms of personality type so it's getting kinda old but Flora is cuter

Post automatically merged: May 10, 2020

Everyone says Twiggy but my sister says don't get rid of her,,

 

[starlightsong]

Okay, so:

• I like Twiggy's design the least of those, however her house is cute. Idk if house design influences you or not though! Also if she was your first peppy she'll have a default house which is different from her "real" one but is also cute imo.
• Flora, as much as I love her, has a terrible house in this game
• Phoebe despite being a fave of mine lowkey also doesn't have the best house in NH to me--her wallpaper and flooring look awesome but she only has like, 3 pieces of furniture so it looks kinda barren. But you got her a starter so then it depends on if you like her starter house or not.
• Julia has both an awesome design and a cute house so I'd basically say any of them except for her would be my choice!
• Personally I would probably keep Julia, then Phoebe, and then either Twiggy or Flora depending on your preference since both of them are peppies but Phoebe and Julia have different personalities.

Honestly I don't even like Monique though so if it were me I would just keep all of them, but you said you're sick of birds and you want Monique! So I ended up voting to get rid of Twiggy since character design influences me more than house design. Hope my thought process here makes sense to you lol.

 

[Cosmic-chan]

Okay, so:

• I like Twiggy's design the least of those, however her house is cute. Idk if house design influences you or not though! Also if she was your first peppy she'll have a default house which is different from her "real" one but is also cute imo.
• Flora, as much as I love her, has a terrible house in this game
• Phoebe despite being a fave of mine lowkey also doesn't have the best house in NH to me--her wallpaper and flooring look awesome but she only has like, 3 pieces of furniture so it looks kinda barren. But you got her a starter so then it depends on if you like her starter house or not.
• Julia has both an awesome design and a cute house so I'd basically say any of them except for her would be my choice!
• Personally I would probably keep Julia, then Phoebe, and then either Twiggy or Flora depending on your preference since both of them are peppies but Phoebe and Julia have different personalities.

Honestly I don't even like Monique though so if it were me I would just keep all of them, but you said you're sick of birds and you want Monique! So I ended up voting to get rid of Twiggy since character design influences me more than house design. Hope my thought process here makes sense to you lol.

This is the most helpful thing i've read all day! I'm so keeping Julia. At first I hated her because she's a bird but honestly her house and design. Flora is cute but her house is weird,, Twiggy is cute,, my sis likes her Phoebe is eh,,

 

[brockbrock]

I'm not a big Twiggy fan. I always shutter whenever she shows up on a NMT trip. I would say get rid of her, though Phoebe not in her original interior is a shame (unless you don't like the lava theme, in which case maybe having the starter interior is better).

 

[starlightsong]

This is the most helpful thing i've read all day! I'm so keeping Julia. At first I hated her because she's a bird but honestly her house and design. Flora is cute but her house is weird,, Twiggy is cute,, my sis likes her Phoebe is eh,,

Yeah Flora's house is really cute in New Leaf but in NH it's so weird and barren lol like there's just 4 flamingo figures and that's basically it? It somewhat dissuades me from taking her home if I find her on an island even though I think she has an adorable design. If your sister likes Twiggy then maybe you could keep her and get rid of Phoebe as long as you don't mind having the 2 peppy birds, or kick Flora instead although I did see where you said you set up her house with nice decorations so you might not want to!

 

[Xara]

i personally would get rid of flora ;u;

 

[Cosmic-chan]

I'm considering Phoebe,,