Rodeo or Roscoe?

[koopasta]

So, I'm going through a crisis trying to figure out my tenth villager. I'm choosing in between Rodeo and Roscoe, and I seriously have no idea who I want. Each one has features I like! For Rodeo, he's a bull, which is an underrated species by itself. Plus, I have a ton of popular villagers, so using one that's not so popular would balance it out. His design is also very cute, and I don't have any lazy villagers. For Roscoe, however, I think he would pair very well with Julian, who I also have in my town. I have a soft spot for horse villagers AND cranky villagers, and the idea of a black horse is something I really love. If you're wondering how well they'd fit with my others, my other villagers are Cece, Vich?, Antonio, Chrissy, Francine, Julian, Sprinkle, Lobo, and Fuschia. Whoever gets to 5 votes first gets in the town, I guess!

 

[MapleSilver]

I think they're both good villagers, but I slightly prefer Rodeo.

 

[Nunnafinga]

I'm pretty biased in Rodeo's favor because he's been in my town for about three years and he's one of my best villagers.I also think he matches your other villagers better than Roscoe.

 

[Halloqueen]

I am also going to throw my support behind Rodeo. While Roscoe is cool and would pair well with Julian, like you said, bull villagers are pretty underappreciated and it would be a nice change of pace. I'd also go for him because you already have a Cranky villager with Lobo but no Lazy villagers. Overall, Rodeo just seems like the better option.

 

[Mr_Persona]

I'm going to agree on Roscoe and because in my opinion I like horse villagers but it matters to you who would you like more.

 

[Dorian]

I love both these fellas, but I'm with Nunna. I'd go with Rodeo

 

[smonikkims]

Roscoe gets my vote fairly narrowly!

 

[PPUAlchemist]

I vote Rodeo because the bull needs more loves~

 

[koopasta]

All right, Rodeo got five votes! Rodeo it is!

 

[Tri]

I was too late to vote for you, Roscoe!! D:

Aw well. Hope Rodeo fits your town better.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

ew rodeo ew

Roscoe all the way!!

 

[koopasta]

Well.. turns out I overlooked something. I didn't have any smug villagers, and I can't accept that, as smug is one of my favorite villager types. So, turns out I'm not using either. I've chosen either Ken or Eugene as the last villager, and there's no debating, I'm gonna get whoever shows up first. Sorry, guys!

 

[Hat']

Roscoe, my man, forgive me.