Rank Your Villagers!

[thisisausername]

6. Kidd - nothing wrong with him i'm just salty that i didn't get the smug that i wanted from the campsite
5. Nana - nothing wrong with her either! she was a random move in and normals are kind of boring so
4. Cookie - she was a random move in too, i'm not a big fan of peppies and cookie's face kind of annoyed me but she grew on me!! and now i think she's super cute
3. Biff - i wanted teddy, bud or samson in his place but he grew on me, we're buddies now
2. Egbert - found him on an island, he's so cute and he's the only one on my island who does the naruto run
1. Frita - i love her design, and she's also the only one who has sang on my island, i've caught her singing like twice now ik she loves it lol

 

[Bk1234]

I just started, so I only have two:
2. Frita
1. Hamlet

 

[skylucario]

10. Annalisa. Her design is cute but doesn’t ‘match’ her personality well enough for me, and I don’t feel attached to her at all
9. Vivian. I actually love the snooty villagers (and her catchphrase!! piffle. so cute) but her design is kinda boring and i’m not that attached to her.
8. Cube. He’s never felt like my villager as i’m saving him for a friend
7. Katt. I feel attached to her bc she’s my starting villager, but she’s by far my ‘meanest’ villager. She made Cube cry!! She is kinda cool otherwise.
6. Sly. Idk what it is about him. I just love him and the jock personality fits him so well. He’s also special to me bc he’s one of my starting villagers.
5. Sheldon! He was a random move-in from someone’s void, and he’s just...so cute. His facial expressions are hilarious, too. He looks so distraught when he can’t catch a fish
4. Tutu! She has grown on me since she randomly moved in. I thought she looked awkward at first, but now I find her to be so cute! Also, peppies are great
3. Baabara! She was in my NL town, too, and I love snooty villagers.
2. Marshal! I am obsessed with him. I talk to him a bit too much; he’s gotten the black cloud twice so far...but i can’t help it...he’s too cute
1. Butch!!! My favorite since WW, and crankies are my favorite personality overall <3

 

[Vea]

10. Penelope. She was a random move in and tbh she's okay, but I'd be happy to let her go.
9. Puddles. She's really nice, I just guess I don't like frogs.
8. Claudia. Another pink random move in. I think there's a theme here lol.
7. Snooty. I hated her at first but she's really growing on me.
6. Marina. She just moved in so I'm sure she'll move up the list as I get to know her.
5. Keaton. I like that he sings at night and his house is super weird.
4. Sylvana. She was one of my first islanders and I've just grown attached to her.
3. Ankha. She's just such a diva, I love her ~
2. Dom. I don't normally like jocks but his peppiness suits his appearance.
1. Beau. His personality is so cute and he eats the flowers I give him!

This has been a fun read. c:

 

[Bk1234]

4. Tutu! She has grown on me since she randomly moved in. I thought she looked awkward at first, but now I find her to be so cute! Also, peppies are great

Tutu just moved in today for me! I love her, she's really cute ❤

Update:
1. Erik
2. Hamlet
3. Tutu
4. Nana (moving in tomorrow)
5. Frita

 

[Believe]

1. Prince
2. Fang
3. Kyle
4. Freya
5. Coco
6. Poncho

as far as who I'm planning to keep at the moment

 

[insomniak]

10. Hippeux. Eat rocks, piss hippo.
9. Static. He's okay. Looks a bit odd, but nice enough.
8. Raymond. Found him on an island, shrugged, and said "Welp, might as well get the hype cat." Still haven't found the hype.
7. Annalisa. She's alright, looks nice, but pretty boring.
6. Whitney. Nothing against her, but she's kinda bland.
5. Cherry. She's cool and looks hella nice.
4. Apollo. One of my favorite villagers in the series.
3. Broccolo. He's so high up just because I love the other for bigger reasons, he's still one of my faves. He's funny and cute, love him.
2. Sprinkles. I'd say she's my best friend in game, she's so sweet and nice.
1. Scoot! I searched for him for so long, I was so happy when I finally found him.

 

[Balverine]

10 - Boris, he snuck in from a friends' town when I had an empty plot lol. I really don't like pigs and he's one of the less appealing ones anyways.
9 - Fuchsia, She was one of my original villagers and I definitely don't hate her, but I'm not a big fan of the uchi personality and something about a hot pink deer is unappealing to me lol
8 - Sylvana, not bad at all, just one of my lesser favs out of my others. She's cuter among the squirrel villagers, so not upset to have her.
7 - Tiffany, again, I really like her, I'm just trying to rank everyone out of 10 LOL. only complaint is i wish she had a nose xp
6 - Rudy, a good boy, but i took him in because i didn't want someone stinky moving in lol
5 - Audie, I really like her, but don't really care for peppy villagers. only complaint : P
4 - Kiki, i love her and try to keep her in my towns!
3 - Zell, my favorite of the smug villagers! his house is super cool in this game and i love that he wants to be a movie star lol
2 - Biff, I really don't know why I am attached to him lol, i don't normally like hippos at all. He was one of my firsts in new leaf and i love him very much
1 - Lobo! My boy in every game he has appeared in <3 best boy and best wolf

 

[nyx~]

10. Antonio- I'm not a huge fan of the jock personality (which is kinda weird since my fave is a jock) but for some reason he just really doesn't appeal to me.
9. Nan- The one curly hair on her head has always bothered me (idk why) and she was random so I didn't choose her
8. Deli- When I first saw him he was in a rain jacket and hat and I thought it was so cute but then he changed into his regular clothes and just reminds me of a grandpa (no offense Deli)
7. Pippy- Again nothing really actually wrong with her I just prefer others.
6. Poncho- He's really cute and I mainly just wanted a bear cub, but again with the constant "I'm gonna workout" comments that drive me insane.
5. Pashmina- I had her at one point in New Leaf and was really fond of her so I was glad she was one of my originals in this game.
4. Fang- Had him way back in City Folk and really grew to love him since he annoyed my mom with his attitude so when I had the chance to get him again, I went for it.
3. Bob- Cats are my favorite and I fell in love with his laziness in New Leaf when he moved in.
2. Zell- I have a weird obsession with the male deer in the series and his personality was the one I needed in my town so I chose him of my favorites. Won't be surprised if my other faves Lopez and Bruce move into La Tortuga at some point.
1. Kid Cat- MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE. He moved in pretty early into me playing New Leaf and I instantly fell in love with his cute racing outfit. Once again, I'm not that much of a fan of the jocks but something about him just really pulled me in. He's lived in my New Leaf town for 5+ years now and I always go back and check that he's still there. As soon as I could use amiibos I invited him to the campsite. Although, I do have to say his shirt in this game kinda put me off at first since it looked like he was wearing a t-shirt over his track suit but I've learned to like it.

 

[DovahTobi]

8. Klaus. He is without a doubt one of the weirdest villagers I've ever had. He does weird things, says weird things, and makes this weird face at me all the time. He is very entertaining though.
7. Drago. This breaks my heart since previously he was a top five favorite villagers of all time for me and I legit screamed for joy when I saw his name on the "sold!" sign... but idk he's just not that interesting on my island :\ I like him though.
6. Truffles. She just moved onto my island the other night so I don't have much to say about her, but she's cute. As I've only had her "in boxes" lines and egg day lines, this is subject to change.
5. Phoebe. One of my starters. She's cool, but gets annoyed if I talk to her too much. She's the one I see the most, doing stuff around the island and staying up late.
4. Broccolo. Surprisingly I like him more than Drago, though they have the same personality type. He's just super adorable and so cute. He's been on my island less than Drago but I've gotten more personality from him.
3. Melba. She's just so adorable and sweet and talks about books all the time. She is always up to something, and I love her. She probably pings me the most.
2. Buck. This took me by surprise. One of my starters, and I thought the smug villagers were supposed to be the flirty types but man, Buck is the flirtiest villager I've ever had xD but he's really nice and is super active on the island. He also sends me the most gifts in the mail.
1. Fang! My cranky little book loving wolf. He is always reading with those cute lil glasses on ;o; he really takes an interest in my outfits the most.

Overall I do like my villagers, but as of right now the only ones I'd make stay are Fang, Buck, and maybe Phoebe (since she's a starter). And maaybbe Klaus just because he's so weird.

two: iggly. he's the cutest thing ever im so glad that i love my founding villagers!!

Iggly is my all time favorite villager ^o^

 

[Minimasher]

10. Tucker - It's not that I really dislike him, I just don't find him to interesting. I barely see him around the island and if I do he's usually sitting down

9. Olaf - I used to really dislike Olaf, especially when I saw that he was the mandatory smug villager that showed up at my campsite. But I've grown to like him a bit more now that he's been on my island a while

8. Coco - I do like Coco a lot because of how sweet she is. However I love seeing emotion in the villagers faces but I obviously can't in Coco's face which is why I'm not her biggest fan

7. Diana - I find Diana's design really cute and sweet however she can be a little bit boring. I would rather her have her show her true snooty side and act as snarky as possible

6. Pekoe - Cub villagers are one of my favourite species and Pekoe is definitely one of my favourite cubs. She is so adorable and kind and has a beautiful looking interior. I don't really have anything negative to say except the fact that I barely see her out her house, she's only ever out to water her flowers

5. Reneigh - Reneigh is my favourite uchi villager and I definetely love her. I love the uchi personality as it makes her seem to really stand out from my other villagers

4. Bluebear - Bluebear is a tiny blue bear cub whose happy all the time. What's not to love about her? The only sad thing is, is that she was my original peppy and doesn't have her own furniture

3. Daisy - I absolutely love Daisy she is very adorable and kind to everybody. I love how her purple ears are actually noticeable now as they weren't in New Leaf. Her interior is very gorgeous and she is always happy to see me visit. I often find her singing to her radio, which makes me adore even more

2. Ozzie - I'll be honest, i didn't even know Ozzie existed until I met him at a mystery island. After hanging out with him everyday we have become best friends which brought me to the conclusion to put him on my dreamies list. Ozzie is by far the cutest koala in my opinion and he's all in all, a fantastic snack buddy

1. Moe - Moe is my all time favourite villager and has been since New leaf. I was lucky enough to be gifted him by one of my friends who was trying to get him to move out. I'm so thankful for this as Moe and I have many fantastic memories of each other. I can't wait to spend many more days hanging out with him on island life

 

[Soigne]

10. reneigh: she is quite literally the ugliest person on my island. i can't wait to get rid of her.
9. broccolo: he's alright, but he was a random move-in & when he asks to leave i will let him.
8. sprinkle: i thought i'd like her, but she's a little overbearing in her design. i look forward to her departure.
7. lyman: the koala villagers are adorable! he just happens to be my least favorite koala.
6. tank: neither here nor there. run of the mill. he's fine.
5. rooney: i invited him to my island because of rooney mara and that's it.
4. tybalt: sooo cute! i love him so much. i decorated his house with a waterfall and a bit of a secluded feel. only the best for tybalt
3. maddie: i've never seen her before, so she turned out to be a real treat. she's cute, but a bit basic. i may replace her.
2. deirdre: she's the newest in town (replaced keaton). she's very lovely.
1. fauna: super cute! i'm so glad she moved to my island.

 

[skogkyst]

Not ranked - Blanche. She just moved in today so I haven't gotten the chance to actually get to know her.
9. Marina
8. Octavian
7. Agent S
6. Cherry
5. Huck
4. Bill
3. Bruce
2. Zucker
1. Fauna

Updated ranking:

10. Agent S
9. Marina
8. Cherry
7. Octavian
6. Huck
5. Blanche
4. Bill
3. Zucker
2. Bruce
1. Fauna

 

[Jared:3]

I kinda like all my villagers however I like some more than others:
10. Ruby- I just invited her from an island but she looks cute and I love her house design, she's low on the list because I barley know her.
9. Audie- The reason why Audie is so low is because I have 3 peppy villagers on my island, and I already have another wolf villager so I hope she leaves with that default DIY furniture!
8. Mitzi- I love cats however she isn't my favorite as I prefer other normal villagers over her such as Tia and Marina and I prefer Ankha as another cat villager so she's going to be replaced, also she has the DIY furniture so she can leave!
7. Papi- He has grown on me however I prefer to have stitches as my only lazy so he can move out if he wants but I have nothing against him!
6. Cherry- I actually love cherry as she is one of my favorite Uchi villagers however she has the default DIY furniture which is heartbreaking because I wouldn't boot her if that weren't the case, also Fuchsia is another Uchi villager I prefer over her.
5. Marina- I love her and she's staying the only thing is that I wish she would stop singing because it can get annoying!
4. Marshal- He's adorable and he was my 2nd camper and I'm glad I invited him to live in my town but I prefer Julian as a smug but Marshal is just fine!
3. Stitches- he's amazing, I found him on an island and I immediately grabbed him because he's amazing and so cute I couldn't leave him on that island by himself at all!
2. Fang- I love Fang, I wanted Wolfgang as my cranky but when I saw fang on an island I snatched him up, he's really chill and I adore him!
1. Flora- My favorite peppy and my 2nd favorite villager after Ankha, I love flamingo's and I love her peppy personality because it goes so well with her and she's never leaving my town!

 

[ali.di.magix]

10. Twiggy - I don't hate her, I just don't love her. I don't like her design very much, and her house doesn't match her at all (mostly because she was one of the 3 that moved in after the starters). She's okay for a peppy I guess, but there are waaaay better options imo.
9. Nate - I'm sorry but he has a god awful design and could've puked when I first discovered who he was. But he's not actually too bad and he's kinda grown on me. Like Twiggy though, there's way better lazy villagers out there.
8. Admiral - he's okay I guess. Just would rather have another cranky over him.
7. Tad - although he's quite low in my ratings, I actually quite like him! His interior is so cute! He's a wee cutie <3
6. Vesta - one of my og's from New Leaf, it's good to have her back!
5. Whitney - I've loved her from New Leaf, so naturally I quite like her in NH.
4. Megan - she is such a cutie, I love her design and house!
3. Raymond - he was my forced campsite villager and honestly couldn't have asked for better. He's a pretty cool cat to say the least.
2. Audie - she probably would've been first, but I've only had her for short amount of time. Other than that I flippin' love her. She's so gorgeous, her house is perfect, and she fits perfectly in my island <3
1. Phoebe - she's my best friend I love her <33 Her design and house are perfect too. She love to tell me all the gossip of the island haha.

 

[Danoa]

10. Roscoe - A random move in that decided to glitch so at this time I don't like him because I can't even talk to him.
9. Drake - Don't hate him, but I don't love him either. He's just kinda there.
8. Chadder - I like his look and name because I think they're funny, but talking with him just isn't really enjoyable.
7. Friga - She's not been on my island to long so I feel I haven't really gotten to know her to well, but so far I've enjoyed her more than Drake and Chadder.
6. Samson - He's okay.
5. Cyd - Love his look, but compared to my other cranky he is sorely lacking.
4. Peanut - Like her a lot more than I originally thought I would. Would be better if she didn't have the default peppy house. It was also funny when she got fleas and then denied it. lol
3. Skye - She maybe would have beat Marina or at least tied if she wasn't my first normal and her house wasn't the default.
2. Marina - She's adorable and I love her house too.
1. Walt - Color me surprised. I wasn't sure if I'd like Walt or not when I invited him, but I have absolutely loved having him. At this time I have no intention of letting him move out. I love his house, his clothes, and his dialogue. I only invited him because I kind of wanted a kangaroo and I don't like the female ones. The little ones in the pouches are kinda creepy to me. Plus I feel like they should be named unless they're not real, in which case that makes it creepier because they emote when the big one does. I feel like I'm going down a rabbit hole or should I say a kangaroos pouch, so I'm going to stop there.

 

[hikaricities]

10. Piper: she's just sort of "meh" to me right now. I don't like her design too much and to me, she looks more like a snooty than a peppy. Pretty weird that she hasn't grown on me since I love peppy villagers.
9. Big Top: I honestly don't have any thoughts on him. He moved in after Axel and Tia so at this point I'm just tired of elephant villagers lol.
8. Axel: don't like him or dislike him, but I do appreciate how he's given me lots of DIYs.
7.Ankha: honestly don't have much of an opinion of her too. I need to talk to her more! But I do like her design.
6. Flip: just moved him in so still don't know how to feel about him but he's pretty cute! Loved the dialogue he gave while he visited my campsite. He's more endearing to me than Axel so I like him more.
5. Klaus: I was going to let him go and I still feel a bit iffy about him, but I'm starting to warm up to him! I loved his home and his design is pretty cool. I'm sure all smugs do this but I also love how he says "ciao" and "buongiorno" sometimes. Since I'm studying Italian it made me happy to see!
4. Tia: I got her through amiibo so it feels like we already have an established friendship which is cute! But same as Sylvana, haven't really been able to get a proper opinion on her since all she talked about was the eggs from coconut trees and Piper's upcoming birthday.
3. Sylvana: she is SO cute! I saw her on a island and I told myself I was on a mission to find Molly but Sylvana was too cute I couldn't resist. She's really chill and super sweet. I haven't seen much of her dialogue due to the bunny event but I'm enjoying her on my island! Even considering letting Tia go if I ever get Molly... because 3 normals may be too much.
2. Frita: love her! She's one of my dreamies and was one of my starting villagers so I was really happy to get her. Even though most of our friendship feels onesided since I talk to her too much, I still love her! She was the first to become my best friend and give me a nickname. She's tried to move once which is unfortunate because she's never leaving.
1. Sherb: he is just so precious, absolute cutest! I love his design and even though the music in his home creeps me out... his home is really cute! He's always chilling around town, watering his flowers, or reading a book in his home. And he never gets annoyed no matter how many times you talk to him. (looking at you Frita)

 

[KitchenWhisk]

10. Jacques: was my forced camper, and he's ok. definitely better than some of the smugs I could have been stuck with
9. Billy: my roommate has him in his town, and I don't like having repeat islanders with people I play with regularly, it ruins immersion
8. Flo: I wish penguins had webbed bird-feet. She sings a lot, which is cute
7. Tasha: extremely excellent house, has terrible taste in workout gear
6. Midge: she moved in a couple of days ago, and I haven't really talked to her much because my islanders wouldn't shut up about Bunny day, but she's very cute.
5. Hornsby
4. Filbert
3. Bianca
2. Bruce
1. Sylvana: I usually like to let villagers come and go as they wish, but Sylvana is never ever leaving. I just wish I had her real house interior instead of the boring beginner one.

 

[Indrii]

I like pretty much all my villagers at the moment but here it goes:

10. Henry - I like his design but he’s a villager I had for a pretty long time in New Leaf and I want different villagers this time around. Plus I dunno, he’s just kinda boring in my current save. His house is nice tho!

9. Beau - He’s another that I had for a long time in a New Leaf. I do really like his design and because he was one of my first 3 island villagers, he’s got the log cabin set in his house which is really cool!

8. Sandy - She’s just a really kind, down to earth villager. I have her a straw hat and a little jacket and she just likes to wonder round watering her plants and whenever I visit she’s always drinking a cup of tea. I have her a house by the sea too!

7. Flip - One of my starters, he has always been really nice to me and his design is pretty neat, I’ve never really had a monkey villager before! I do find his constant talk of exercise a bit much though, he talks about nothing else! More so than previous games I’d say.

6. Renée - My other starter, she started out a bit harsh but she’s grown on me. Her dialogue is some of the more interesting on my island and we design is pretty cool.

5. Broffina - I know a lot of people don’t really like Broffina but she’s got a really nice design and her house is beautiful. She comes across as a very posh snooty villager whose always kind to me.

4. Hopper - He’s just a grumpy little ball of feathers tbh. His red eyes are neat and his ice-themed house is really cool. He’s also the villager that lives next door to me so he’s wandering around outside my house quite a bit.

3. Apple - Probably the villager I talk to the most, she’s always out and about reminding around or doing exercise/singing in the plaza. She’s always extremely enthusiastic and fits the peppery theme great.

2. Cookie - She’s ALWAYS outside (like I’m starting to wonder if she’s lost her keys or something!) She’s lived in my town for nearly two weeks and I’ve not been inside her house once yet. She’s really kind though and can usually be found sweeping around in the plaza.

1. Coco - My surprise favourite villager. I only invited her to get more villagers and I’ve always thought her design was a bit too much for my liking. But her house use great, her outfit is really fitting and she’s always got her head in a book. When she’s not reading she can usually be found searching tree and weeds with a magnifying glass. I bought her a little mug with a carrot design on it the other day!

 

[ariesmoon]

10. rasher: he moved in randomly before i had the chance to invite someone to fill that plot. i really really disliked him at first but he's honestly grown on me, i love the cranky villagers
9. gladys: i invited her via the islands as my third villager becus i thought she seemed cute but she's quite boring...she always gives me medicine when i get stung though so <3
8. rolf: he just moved in after i invited him from the campsite and i guess i really do have a soft spot for cranky villagers cus i love him so far
7. peck: my jock starting villager lmao i hated him at first but i've really warmed up to him i love him now...he was also the first villager to give me their photo!!
6. zucker: he was one of my dreamies and i was super happy to find him but so far he's kind of boring sadly
5. pietro: my first campsite villager, i was glad it was him and not someone less...desirable but i wasnt like ecstatic or anything but now i love him a lot and im thinking about keeping him permanently
4. octavian: ahhh i love him i wanted to cry when i found him on a mystery island i have always wanted him in a game <3
3. fuchsia: my starting uchi <3 she has the best conversations with other villagers shes so funny
2. merry: so adorable, i have a bias toward peppy villagers but yeah i just love her
1. cookie: one of my dreamies!! she moved in randomly as my fifth villager and i was so happy...shes so cute and sends me the best letters and has also given me some of my favorite clothing items as gifts :')