Rank Your Villagers!

[0orchid]

10. Plucky There's nothing wrong with Plucky. However... all she does is talk about cooking. Every other conversation! And earlier today she was talking about making a recipe for shrimp gumbo with apple and peach cake... so I'm sorry Plucky, but you have disgusting taste in food!

9. Dora Dora is sort of cute but very boring. She usually talks about cleaning or reading and walks around with a spray bottle of some type of cleaning fluid randomly spritzing stuff, or a broom, or is sitting down reading somewhere. She needs to relax on the cleaning lol.

8. Sprocket I don't really like robot villagers or ostriches at all. Sprocket is pretty cool, though. He was my first villager to reach "true friend" status with and the first who wanted me to change his catchphrase. Now he's forever saying "gumdrop". He pings me to sell me dumb stuff all the time which is no bueno, and his gifts are usually appliances. He also recently started singing constantly which has been getting annoying.

7. Filbert Filbert is pretty cool but kind of boring. He's usually in his house talking about the bugs in his walls, bug friends. "the bugs told me this", etc. He has some really cute conversations with my other villagers though.

6. Deirdre One of my island recruits, she's super cute to me but we haven't talked much yet. I love her house too. I'm not a huge fan of uchi villagers, but she's adorable.

5. Pietro He was my first camper and at first I just planned on peddling him off to the highest bidder. I have to say he's grown on me a lot, he gives me a lot of gifts and likes playing treasure hunter with me. I have a soft spot for him now and love his flamboyance and the fact that he constantly inserts that he's a sheep into convos.

4. Willow Another cute sheep, Willow is one of my favorite villagers in the game. If she hadn't just moved in she might be in my top 3 but we haven't talked much yet.

3. Maple She just moved in too but she's one of my favorite villagers. I found her right when I was about to abandon hope on my island tour villager hunt and accept getting a rando villager. Luckily I have Maple instead, but she just moved in so we haven't talked much. I hope she's less neurotic about cleaning than Dora!

2. Kabuki I love Kabuki so much. He was my first island find and the first island villager I invited. His house is very tranquil and I like the cranky villager voice >.

1. Apple She isn't necessarily my favorite design but she's my absolute favorite villager on my island now! She constantly refers to me as her bff so it would feel like a betrayal for me to not have her as number 1, lol. Apple is always running around outside up to something weird. She likes carrying around tiny red dumbbells or doing yoga. She sends me letters pretty often too. She's so bubbly and adorable!

 

[Sanaki]

10. Axel - I just find him super unappealing to look at and he does not fit my tastes at all.
9. Shep - Ugly dog.
8. Becky - She's nice but she has to go.
7. Freya - I like her, but she's too pink for me.
6. Marina - I don't fancy octopi
5. Sherb - He's cute, but I'm eh about goats.
4. Julian - I think his house and him look super cute in this game.
3. Lolly - She's adorable and nice.
2. Diana - She used to be my #1 favourite villager, but right now she hasn't been super nice to me or inviting to talk to.
1. Wolfgang - My original favourite from Wild World, and this game made me realize how much I love him. He's legit wearing a maid dress right now. lol

 

[Taj]

10. Gigi - Bruh (Move/10)

9. Cherry - Never been a fan of the uchis, but Cherry is alright in my book (6/10)

8. Peanut - Peppy villagers are rather... extreme. Love Peanut but even she can be a bit much (7/10)

7. Fang - It already starts to get tough. I love Fang but honestly prefer Chief and Wolfgang, still great tho (7/10)

6. Rudy - I know jocks aren't super popular, and I can kinda see why, but Rudy's design is both simple and charming. Props to the red nose (7/10)

5. Coco - Haven't connected to her as well as I thought I would, but her design is still one of the most unique of all time. Also love the new dress she has (8/10)

4. Marshal - Although he's my second favorite villager of all time, he's only a bit lower because he's the villager I see the least on my island, and even then he only sings (8/10)

3. Sherb - My first ever Nook island resident, I was completely unaware how popular he was! I can definitely see why tho, he's probably the only goat villager I like (9/10)

2. Buzz - My pick for most slept on villager, he looks so darn cranky and has such a cool design imo, like a falcon! Also been a longtime fan of eagles (10/10)

1. Marina - GOATed. While I like Marshal, Buzz, and even Coco more I've connected to Marina the most (10/10)

 

[marea]

5- Stu: I sat here for about five minutes trying to even remember his name lol his color is so lovely but i want other lazy villagers.
4- Axel: He is not my favorite out of the jock villagers, and even though he is so nice i wont be keeping him.
3- Olive: just moved in today, she is sweet and cute so i will be keeping her for a while.
2- Hazel: she is my starter uchi and i actually like her the most from that category.
1- Sprinkle: she is one of my dreamies and i have her in my NL town which is why i plan on letting her move out when she asks, i want to befriend new villagers.

still waiting to get my camp so i can start inviting more villagers from other islands. I also just noticed that i have a lot of blue villagers!!

 

[cheezu]

10. Rowan the jock Tiger - no attachment to him whatsoever. I hope I can trade him for Mac the pug jock.
9. Zell the smug Deer - he's actually a good-looking dude and I was glad I didn't get a hideous smug but he's not my villager of choice
8. Apple the peppy Hamster - she's a cutie and I actually invited her from an Island Tour but I hope she can move on to a loving home as I don't have a huge attachment to her
7. Hazel the uchi Squirrel - I actually really like her but Katt is my uchi of choice so I hope to let her go to a loving home eventually
6. Wolfgang the cranky Wolf - He used to be my NL starter and has been a permanent resident there so when I saw him on an Island Tour, I had to invite him... but I also find him a bit plain and boring.
5. Erik the lazy Deer - now, he's adorable and if I could have more villagers on my Island, I'd probably keep him (also got him from a tour) but I need place for Zucker.
4. Boyd the cranky Gorilla - when I first saw him I wanted to run for the hills but then upon further inspection, I came to the conclusion that the gorilla villagers are very underrated. They might not be your typical type of "cute" but especially for a cranky personality, I think his looks are really fitting. Plus he's got a naked butt.
3. Norma the normal Cow - I think she's super underrated. She's such a cutie and she's got two braids at the back of her head.
2. Octavian the cranky Octopus - I love the octopus villagers and I think he's precious. Plus he's going to be a friend to Zucker (eventually)
1. Sherb the lazy Goat - I found him on a mystery hybrid Island so I took it as a sign. When I saw pictures of him released initially, I didn't think much of him but after our interaction I thought he's the cutest little thing there is.

 

[Neorago]

10. Sheldon - I don’t even dislike him, he’s just so very bland to me for some reason. He’s just... meh. So I gave him a stache & glasses. I gotta say, it kinda worked for a while there. he definitely looked more interesting, that’s for sure! lol
9. Chops - nah mate
8. Gonzo - I invited him to my island because I liked the idea of a cranky koala but haven’t really made a connection with this little dude. Cute ears though.
7. Agnes - meh. I mean, she’s alright. Pretty cool. But no other uchi will hold a handle to Rocket in my humble opinion.
6. Flurry - I’ve had her before in my NL town. She’s very cute. Not one of my favourites, but she can stay for as long as she wants.
5. Naomi - what a glow up in design! She’s cool, invited her to my island immediately when I saw her.
4. Kitt - a sweetheart and I just can’t with her tiny joey! So cute I cry a little.
3. Sterling - he’s an eagle knight in armour, what’s not to love?
2. Pango - wasn’t expecting Pango to climb this far on my list but I just love her design combined with the (imo) improved peppy personality.
1. Erik - so adorable I can barely stand it ;; this little guy is staying forever and that’s final!!

 

[Boccages]

5- Stu: I sat here for about five minutes trying to even remember his name lol his color is so lovely but i want other lazy villagers.
4- Axel: He is not my favorite out of the jock villagers, and even though he is so nice i wont be keeping him.
3- Olive: just moved in today, she is sweet and cute so i will be keeping her for a while.
2- Hazel: she is my starter uchi and i actually like her the most from that category.
1- Sprinkle: she is one of my dreamies and i have her in my NL town which is why i plan on letting her move out when she asks, i want to befriend new villagers.

still waiting to get my camp so i can start inviting more villagers from other islands. I also just noticed that i have a lot of blue villagers!!

I'm glad (and jealous you got Olive). I will get her at one point.

With that being said, here is my top 9 (I have decided against building a tenth plot for the time being)

9. Zucker. I did not want him. He moved in at random. He will be the first to go. Although I dislike him, I will talk to him every day, I will give him gifts because I don't think being a jerk about it is reasonable.

8. Lionel. Not too bad. First camper on my island. He has a fatherly smug attitude to him that I like.

7. Cherry. She was the first villager on the island (uchi). Even though she was, I never grew to really fully appreciate her for who she is. I guess I'm just not into AC dogs.

6. Hopper. There are not a lot of cool looking cranky - or cute one for that matter. As far as cranky goes, I think there is not much better than Hopper. I've never had him in my previous towns before. I'm up to discover him. I installed his plot along the country road to the campsite. I fancy him as a wheat farmer somehow.

5. Gabi. I just love the personality. She is peppy. I love her, but the fact that she has the same personality as Pate plays against her. I will keep her around for a while I think.

4. Sylvana. Have you seen her house interior ? WOWZA ! She is quite cute, but she is the only one to live in the hills, outside the village. So I see her strutting her stuff alone in the hills or near the campground usually. She is actually the only one that I have an easy time to get good pictures of (using the photo app). She collaborates unlike the rest of the crew.

3. Lyman. Also the first on the island with Cherry. I was indifferent. But her grew on me by a lot. I really like him now. He's going to stay for a long time. He was the first one to ask me to move out (today). I convinced him otherwise.

2. Norma. The first cow I've ever been fond of. She is so cute. And the dress really compliments her colour scheme. I like her a lot. I'm a new fan of hers. Although, I would say she is the quiet one, the recluse one in town. I never see her near other villagers or interacting with them. Her house is right behind the town hall, so it's not like she is situated far from the crew.

1. Pate. I scanned her amiibo in to get her on my island. She's been my favourite villager since Wild World. She was villeger #9 to move in and I plan to keep her with me forever.

 

[blinkcrossing]

9. Huck- I honestly don't hate him, but i don't really like him. Nothing is very smug about him.
8. Diva - Her gifts are good, but i dont like her sassiness tbh.
7. Sydney - She was a filler villager
6. Sprinkle - Also a filler villager, but i like her, and her personality, so I will be keeping her since she's the only peppy villager I have.
5. Marina - A partial filler villager and a partial dreamie. I really like her.
4. Zucker - My second son... my favorite lazy villager i love him so much but not as much as the 3 spots ahead of him.
3. Lolly - Imported her from amiibo. She moved into my NL town and I fell in love with her personality. She was also best friends with Zell so she has love from me.
2. Zell - He was my favorite villager for several years in a row! Love everything about him, his design, personality, house. He's awesome.
1. Rudy- My son. I will die for him. i will make sure he is well fed and sleeps well every night. The first jock villager I ever liked. He's baby.... always smiley. so cute i love him so much i take pictures of him all day, and he poses great every single time! My new favorite villager.

 

[PajamaCat]

7. Rocco: He literally just moved into my town today so I don't have an opinion on him yet. I like cranky villagers though so he'll probably move up.
6. Klaus: He also just moved in but for some reason he drives me crazy. He was home when I was running from bees today so he gets points for that.
5. Sheldon: Please, for the love of God, stop talking about your muscles and workouts!!!
4. Marcel: He's a green dog. Weird, but cool.
3. Plucky: She's grown on me a ton. Always taking about something weird.
2. Sprinkle: I love her design and she's always handing out DIY recipes.
1. Maple: Normal villagers are my favorite. Plus she's adorable!

 

[Magnolia_]

9. Bitty. Ugh. I had her in previous games and I just want different villagers lol. I placed a house plot, accidentally fell asleep, and the next day she occupied the spot which was annoying. She moved in today and I'm already waiting for her to leave.
8. Henry. My first campsite villager... I wasn't happy with him, but it could have been worse. He's not staying though oops
7. Nana. I invited her from a Nook miles island and tbh I'm indifferent towards her. She keeps upsetting my other villagers though, whenever they're sad or annoyed it's always because of Nana... She's disturbing the peace lol
6. Maddie. Another one I personally invited, but I'm indifferent towards her. Maybe it's because I already have a peppy villager, but Maddie's cute at least!
5. Tammi. I wasn't too keen on her at first but I really warmed up to her. Not sure if she'll stay if she asks to move, but I like her anyway
4. Lopez. He's only been on my island for 1 day, but he's great. He's funny and the type of villager I want to talk to all the time
3. Canberra. I love her because she always looks angry (it's the eyebrows). She has an interesting personality too, so yeah.
2. Flip. A!! Sweetheart!! I've never been keen on Jock villagers but Flip is the exception. I'm definitely keeping him on my island.
1. Ozzie. What a gem. Enough said.

 

[maple22]

8. Renee. I really don't care for 99% of uchi villagers to begin with, and she's one of the worst.
7. Marcie. Very cute imo, but pretty boring so far.
6. Rasher. He may be "ugly", but I had him in WW or CF (maybe both?) so I have a bit of a soft spot for him. Far from my favorite cranky, but I like pretty much all villagers with this personality.
5. Jeremiah. An adorable lazy frog who's said some very funny things so far.
4. Leonardo. He gives me presents almost every day for some reason. What's not to love?
3. Audie. I love the wolves in general, and she's no exception.
2. Marshal. I wanted to dislike him because of his popularity, but he keeps randomly singing K.K. Island and it's the cutest thing I've ever seen.
1. Flurry. My favorite girl from New Leaf, who I was so surprised to find so early on! I've hardly had her in NH, but she's my favorite based on my past experience with her.

 

[Marshmallows]

9. Lionel - My least favorite. First camper and had to invite him. A bit odd, like a creepy old guy that thinks he's attractive, and despite having a huge jet tub in his house, had fleas.

8. Moose - He came with the island. All he talks about is fitness and strength training. He's a mouse.

7. Octavian - Moved in while I was preparing my island for KK. Don't know much about him and don't know if he'll stay. I don't know if I can handle two villagers with angry eyes.

6. Muffy - Don't like her look and she bullies Zucker, but she does have a sweet singing voice. Always singing. Most likely not staying.

5. Gala - A really nice pig. A bit forgettable though, because it took me a long time to remember her. She gets under Moose's skin, which is fine by me.

4. Melba - Sweet, but she was sick this morning. Really hope she didn't bring the coronavirus to my island.

3. Twiggy - she can be a little intense at times, and a bit full of herself, but I like her personality and the color she adds to the island. Her eyebrows though... wonder if there's a hat or sunglasses for that...

2. Marina - she just moved in today, but had her in New Leaf and there's nothing to not like.

1. Zucker - the best. Almost every morning I find him sitting by the beach or under a tree eating a donut.

 

[marea]

I'm glad (and jealous you got Olive). I will get her at one point.

and i am glad and jealous you got Lyman lol he is my all time fave jock!! I would be more than glad to let you have Olive once she wants to move out, but i think you already have her amiibo.

 

[Lavamaize]

While Sherb has not moved in yet, I'm still going to include him on this list!

7. Patty- Not really my idea of a good peppy villager. Her house is kind of boring as well as she in my opinion
6. Chaddar- Not a fan of mouse villagers in general.
5. Shari- One of my starting villagers. Not a huge fan of hers, but one of my favorite YouTubers also has her as a starting villager. I'm not a big fan of Monkey villagers in general and she does not seem like a very Uchi villager in my onion.
4. Punchy - He is ok I guess. He has a nice looking house, I'm just not a huge fan of him in general.
3. Marina- I had her as a villager in NL but moved her out. I originally was planning on getting rid of her when she was ready to move, but I don't think I will now as she has grown on me as well!
2. Lyman - One of my starting villagers. At first I though I would not like him but he has really grown on me. He looks real cool with the light lime green color that is not too bright as well!
1. Sherb -He's a brand new villager to ACNH and one of my all time favorites and I was lucky enough to find him on a mystery island on my second time of looking for him. Love the blue colors on him as well!

 

[Toska]

(Rhonda is moving out tomorrow, so I won't include her. Bam is moving in tomorrow of the next day, so I'll include him.)

9. Spike- he just doesn't have that great of an appearance or personality. He moved in randomly and I definitely regret letting that happen.

8. Cranston- he was one of the 3 starting villagers I got. I used to really like him, but after hearing him say "sweatband" after every sentence I got annoyed.

7. Renèe- she's alright, but nothing special. She was one of my starting villagers. I'm not a fan of the uchi personality anyways, shes not my cup of tea.

6. Winnie- I like her, but sometimes she can be a bit full of herself. She's still kind, but she does get annoying sometimes and I've never really been a fan of the horses. (Except Roscoe)

5. Tybalt- my jock starter, who I liked more than I expected. He's a pretty cool dude, regardless of the fact that he only talks about working out.

4. Zell- my first camper, who was better than some others I've heard. He can be a little stuck up at times, but I really enjoy having him.

3. Fauna- I moved her in through a mystery island. She's super sweet and is very nice to have in my town.

2. Bam- an all time favorite of mine, who I had in new leaf. I enjoy how sweet he is and how much he takes pride in his strength.

1. Molly- my second dreamy. She's super sweet and overall adorable. Having her in my town is one of the best things to happen to me

 

[Pondo]

7) Boots- Not to be that person but I've never liked alligator villagers. He was my starting jock, but that's about it. He gave me the encouragement reaction and I don't use it often. It's awkward. Thanks, Boots.
6) Lucy- She's sweet, and normal. But I have no attachment to her.
5) Tex- He's a penguin who just so happened to be the first camper visiting the island. I couldn't not let him move in, and he's better than O'Hare or Chadder (I don't like either of them in the slightest), but he's also not one of my top 50 villagers. Not even top 100.
4) Dobie- I just-so-happened to run into him on an island. Hoping I can sell him or give him away to someone in the future. He's definitely cute, I'll give him that, and cranky, which is probably my favourite personality.
3) Audie- Another wolf, who was on the second island I ever visited. I don't know if she's a freebie for most people or it was luck. I'll probably sell her in the future, too. Though I'm starting to grow very fond of seeing her work out and sing in my plaza.
2) Zucker- Never had him before. I've had another octopus, Marina, but never this one. I like giving him my bugs and I hope his house is full of them when I next visit him. He gets so excited over them. ;w;
1) Phoebe- Ah, the glorious Uchi that I started with. I've seen that a lot of people don't really care for her, but I love her and her colours and the fact that she gave me the medicine recipe the first time I got stung by wasps. If I don't end up finding one of my dreamies (or affording them), I might just keep her around instead. (Also she shares her name with my favourite character from Friends, so there's that.)

 

[skogkyst]

Not ranked - Blanche. She just moved in today so I haven't gotten the chance to actually get to know her.
9. Marina
8. Octavian
7. Agent S
6. Cherry
5. Huck
4. Bill
3. Bruce
2. Zucker
1. Fauna

 

[Krissi2197]

I only have 8 villagers atm but I'll still do this x3

8: Hazel.
7. Kevin
6. Eugene
5. Eunice
4. Alphonso
3. Twiggy
2. Audie
1. Chief

 

[Aleigh]

I'm slacking on my villagers, but this is mine so far:

7. Agnes. I started with her. I reallllly don't like her. Someone pls help
6. Cheri. She was a random move in
5. Bam. He's not too bad but he's super basic I feel like. I also started with him
4. Blaire. She's not too bad, I just let her move into my town to occupy space to get the game rolling
3. Fauna. She's cute and I don't mind her really
2. Tucker. I love him a lot, he's really grown on me. I'm hoping to keep him!
1. Dobie. It took me three days to move him in from my amiibo card because I didn't know what I was doing, but I really love him. I don't think I'm going to keep him in the long run just because he's a dreamie in my New Leaf town, and I don't want too many of my NH villagers to be the same. I still love him nonetheless

 

[ac_smitty]

10. Buck - UGH. He's a starter and I just am not a fan of his design or his dialogue at all. I've been ignoring him for days now lol.

9. Kyle - I had him in NL and wasn't a huge fan. I was forced to invite him from my campsite, but I'm hoping he'll be gone soon. I'd love to replace him with a girl wolf like Audie or Whitney.

8. Flo - My other starter. Something about her just bothers me and I don't love her design.

7. Croque - He's pretty new and I haven't gotten to speak to him much yet. I usually don't love cranky villagers, but I think his mustache is cute lol.

6. Erik - Nothing against him, I just think he's kind of boring. Would much rather have Fauna if I was going to have a deer villager.

5. Julia - I was expecting not to like her, but she sent me a nice letter on her second day with a great gift. Not what I was expecting from a Snooty personality!

4. Nibbles - I always like the squirrel villagers, and she always gives me medicine when I get stung by wasps.

3. Marina - She is adorable! Always giving me gifts and one of the only villagers who will let me keep talking to her over and over lol. I will probably keep her for a long time.

2. Sydney - When I met her on an island tour, it was love at first sight. She is ADORABLE. She just moved in two days ago but I already know she's a forever villager for me.

1. Raymond - He just moved in today, but is a dreamy of mine and I feel so lucky that I met him on an island tour! Cats are my favorite animal and hold a special place in my heart, and I love his two different colored eyes. Everything about him is so cute and I'm definitely planning to keep him forever!