Rank Your Villagers!

[geetry]

10. Bree. She's tolerable, just never been a fan of the current mice besides Rod.

9. Flurry. I'm sorry, but having 3 normals in my town is rather boring and honestly she's my least favorite. She will definitely be going to someone who will care for her more when she decides to move, since I know she's popular.

8. Octavian. I liked him in NL but tbh Zucker and Marina are the superior octopi. He's rather bland in this game.

7. Merengue. Another normal boring. Idk, I thought she was boring in NL and I think she's equally as boring now. Same deal as Flurry.

6. Biff. I cannot hate Biff. I figured he was a new villager when I started my island, turns out Biff just got a facelift LOL. He was a starting villager of mine in NL and NH, so basically I love him. He isn't poop colored anymore which is a bonus.

5. Rolf. I moved him in just to move out Diva from one of my amiibo cards. He'll be the town cranky for awhile though, since I prefer him to Octavian.

4. Jacques. He was in my Pocket Camp campsite for a bit, and when I saw him on the island I knew I had to have him. He's so fun tbh.

3. Melba. I know I've spent this whole post dissing normal villagers, but Melba was in my very first NL town (the town before Biff!) and she's my absolute mother. I love her to death.

2. Bones. Tbh, I did not like him at first! But he's really warmed up to me. He's such a cute lazy boy.

1. Tangy!! I love her so much. I took her from an ex friend back in high school because she moved over his road, and I fell in love with her in NL. She was my first island in NH, so I knew it was a sign. I think she's the only one out of this list who is never leaving.

 

[Verecund]

9. Huck - My forced campsite move-in that I will forever resent. His face just looks so darn pompous and I can't stand it. The only one of my villagers I hate.
8. Nate - I'm not a fan of his green unibrow, but while I didn't like him at first, he's grown on me a bit. (He talks about his bugs every day, though, and I wish he'd call an exterminator.) I'd definitely let him move if he asked, though.
7. Ava - She's nice, kind of plain-looking, though. She's given me a lot of DIY recipes though since she always seems to be crafting something when I walk into her house. She also sings quite a bit!
6. Del - I invited him from a mystery island yesterday because I wanted a cranky villager and although he's not my favourite, he's far from the worst. I like him, I just like my other neighbours better.
5. Diva - I like her and she's the only one who's sent me letters so far (two of them), but I can barely talk to her without her telling me I'm giving her a complex and it's really frustrating. My other villagers don't seem nearly as irritated when I talk to them a lot; it's just her so far.
4. Goldie - Just invited her from a mystery island today. I like her; she was a starter in my last WW town, too! I don't plan on keeping her super long-term at the moment but I'm glad to be getting her.
3. Cobb - It's kind of funny that I'm ranking him here since I was initially going to reset my island when I saw he was my starter, but I stuck with it in hopes that he'd grow on me, and he really has, to the point where I like him over Diva. He's really nice to me and always seems happy to have a chat!
2. Nibbles - I was super excited to come across her on my first mystery tour since Huck moved in (especially since my mom met Nibbles on her first mystery tour and invited her and I was super jealous); I love the squirrels! I think the main reason she's not ranked first is because she's so new and I haven't interacted with her much yet.
1. Apple - The first villager I met on a mystery tour and I had to invite her; she's so cute! She always calls me her bestie and tells me how much she loves my outfit/hair. She's so sweet!

 

[Mink777]

10. Whitney- She just moved in so I have no opinion on her yet.
9. Bertha- Hippos are one of the worst species, but she is one of the better hippos. She isn’t outside much and has been kind of boring so far.
8. Pashmina- Getting kind of tired of her. I don’t like the goats at all, but she is one of the better ones. She isn’t that bad, but I would absolutely let her move if she asked.
7. June- Kind of new, but she made me mad earlier by watering flowers I didn’t want watered. Needs to do more to gain my respect. More visually appealing than Bertha gives her the normal advantage.
6. Zell- Zell is just Zell. He hasn’t done much, but he is a cool deer I suppose. I prefer Lopez out of the two smug deers, but he will do for awhile.
5. Zucker- Zucker is pretty cool. He’s only been here for a few days, so I’d expect him to be closer to the top in about a week if he is still in town.
4. Buzz- One of the most underrated villagers in the game, and I was quite surprised to see him in the bottom tier. I really like his design, and you can never go wrong with the cranky villagers most of the time.
3. Agent S- Agent S has been really good so far. She gives me a lot of presents and crafts a lot as well. I really like the peppy villagers, and Agent S is no exception. With that being said, I don’t want to keep her forever and if she asked to leave, I’d probably accept it.
2. Dom- The biggest surprise villager for me and the one who has grown on me the most. If you asked me before the game came out, I would have probably called Dom the worst new villager besides maybe Megan. When I got him as a starter, I was kind of upset but was also open to potentially getting to know him more and become friends. That is exactly what happened. Dom has been a great villager so far. He gives me the most reactions and always gives me bells when I gift him something. Will I let him move if he asks? It hurts to say as I probably would, but I hope I can get his picture first.
1. Benjamin- Behold, the only keeper on this list. Benjamin is great. I really love all the dogs, and while Benjamin isn’t my favorite, he still gets an A+ rating from me. He is very balanced in how he helps me out with the town as he is always doing a combination of crafting, giving me reactions, and giving me tasks on a daily basis. I want his picture, and I may let him go after I get it, but who knows, I may change my mind.

 

[Sir Zyr]

8. Chops: far and away my least favorite of the current residents. Fortunately, he'll be in boxes tomorrow (random move-out)
7. Broccolo: just sort of there, really
6. Admiral: random move in. Don't have much of an opinion yet
5. Merengue: Nice and all, but I normally don't have much reason to deal with her
4. Tammi: she looks a bit ugly but gives lots of presents
3. Robin: a carryover from New Leaf I found on an island tour, who I've always liked
2. Tank: one of my original villagers and the first to call me a friend according to my nookphone
1. Reneigh: The other original villager, very xute, very friendly, and the second to call me a friend per my nookphone (after I gave her a go board)
Not moved in yet but will be number 1: Ankha, my one and only dreamie

 

[Piroshi]

10. Claudia: Don't really like her design, and I'm not really a fan of snooty villagers in general. Her room looks pretty cool though.
9. Celia: I had her in New Leaf before. I don't really hate her, but she's a normal eagle villager, neither of which are my favorite.
8. Cherry: I really liked Cherry in New Leaf, but I just don't like the uchi villagers in this game so I want her gone.
7. Nan: She's okay, I guess. I like her house. I want her kitchen island thing.
6. Bubbles: I wasn't happy about her moving in at first, but she's grown on me. I'm still letting her go if she asks to move, but I'll be a little sad about it, at least.
5. Rudy: Rudy is adorable, and he was one of my initial villagers, but there are so many jock villagers that I like so I'll probably have to let him go.
4. Bruce: I got Bruce as a random move in. I really like him, so I lucked out. Definitely keeping him.
3. Colton: He was my first camper, so I had no choice but to let him move in. I didn't want to at first, but he's grown on me a lot. I'm keeping him now.
2. Zucker: Found him on an island. I wasn't planning on getting him even though I liked him, but when I saw him I had to. He's even more adorable in this game than he was in New Leaf.
1. Bam: My favorite villager! I found him on an island and I'm definitely keeping him. When I first started the game, I reset for over three hours trying to get him or Rowan before giving up, so I'm super happy I got him this early. In New Leaf I always had either Rowan or Bam at the start, so it felt weird not having either one.

 

[Bread Kennedys]

7. Canberra. I'm okay with sisterly villagers but I don't love them either, so they gotta look or be extra interesting to win me over. I personally find Canberra ugly though.
6. Coach. He's alright, I don't love him but I don't hate him either. He's just sorta there.
5. Carrie. She just randomly moved in and she's not bad, but I don't see myself keeping her around either when I get any cooler villagers.
4. Wolfgang. This is where my favorite villagers list starts. He only moved in recently but I already love him loads. I had him in New Leaf I think and aside from Chief, he's one of my favorite wolves.
3. Jeremiah. I had him in Wild World and I'm so happy to see him again in New Horizons. I invited him in on a whim but he's really grown on me already. He's definitely my favorite frog villager, I think.
2. Eugene. Love this cool mofo. He's got that greaser/biker style going and I think it's interesting how they gave that to a koala. He was one of my favorites in New Leaf and he's just as cool here, I think.
1. Kyle. This dude is one of the COOLEST villagers out there! He's easily my second favorite wolf and like Eugene, I really love his cool style. He just moved in and I love him, he's been going places and singing on my island and that's soo cute!

 

[petrichr]

10. Renee - her colour scheme is.. a lot. Also she bullies me when I get stung. She is in boxes today though!
9. Alfonso - still traumatised from having him in WW. Okay, gives me DIY but I hate his colours.
8. Agnes - chose her from a mystery island just to fill my spaces. She is always inside, haven't really interacted.
7. Lopez - mandatory campsite move in. He is fine, I like the look of deer but his blue and yellow is a bit weird.
6. Norma - she grew on me appearance wise. But she has the personality of a brick wall.
5. Hornby - picked him up off a mystery island. Still undecided, he only moved in yesterday. But his personality is pretty cute for a jock.
4. Genji - one of my starters, I actually really like him now. He always gives me medicine :')
3. Ankha - this was a random move in. She was one of my NL dreamies and I was happy to give her a miss this time but her personality is pretty cute this time round.
2. Marshal - I didn't get the hype but this lil dude to so cute. And I love his house.
1. Audie - found her on a mystery island and I'm never letting her go!

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

I've got some amiibo to go through but so far I've got:

10. Snooty - I mean, ugh. I didn't know at the time that if I built all my plots in advance that rando villagers would just let themselves in. Can't wait for her to leave

9. Leopold - What kinda lion has a green mane? Fake news

8. Billy - One of the two original villagers I had when I started my island. Idk he's just kinda boring, does not look like a jock at all

7. Cesar - He would be lower on the list if he hadn't been one of my original starting villagers in New Leaf. He's ugly but sentimental. I'm gonna replace him with Dobie though

6. Sprinkle - Penguins are cute, I don't really care for this penguin though. Her eyes are kinda spooky. Bunnie will be taking her place

5. Stella - Recruited her through a mystery island. She was really cute at the time, but sheep just look so awkward in clothing. I have grown bored of her. Will replace her with Merengue or maybe Lolly

4. Ursala - She's just starting to move in to my town, I forced Deirdre out for her. I like her, she's an underrated uchi bear. I just wanna give her a hug

3. Purrl - I got her to move in via the amiibo campsite. I like Purrl she's a very underrated snooty cat

2. Sherb - I lucked out finding Sherb on a mystery island! I didn't know at the time that he was completely new to Animal Crossing, I could have sworn he was a Welcome Amiibo villager but oh well. I think I will keep him but I feel like he doesn't like me; he's already tried to leave once

1. Melba I lucked out getting her via one of the mystery islands! I didn't plan on having her permanently but now I think I do want her to stay. She's too cute

 

[Licorice]

All of my villagers are solid 10s.

 

[Harbour]

i honestly don't like all of them, but here goes:
9 - Elvis
8 - Julian
7 - Coco
6 - Punchy
5 - Lyman
4 - Sterling
3 - Twiggy (kinda surprised)
2 - Charlise
1 - Sydney

 

[mogyay]

10: bones - i don't need to elaborate, an absolute monstrosity, stupid campsite..
9: axel - idk, could be worse but i just don't vibe with him, he's moving tomorrow anyway
8: pashmina - u did grow on me but sis sorry u just ain't that cute..
7: audie - omg i feel so bad bc she's so well liked but i just don't rly love her, idk if it's the design or just the personality, feel like she'd be better as a snooty
6: merengue - i only took her bc i found her on mystery island and ik she's popular but she's surprisingly grown on me a lot
5: zucker - a cutie, i got him to match marina, i always love the octopus
4: marina - soo adorable, if i didn't already have 2 normal dreamies i'd probably want her to stay forever
3: sherb - SO CUTE, defo my favourite of the new villagers, he only talks about snacks and snacks is my personality so
2: fang - YAY, i'm so blessed someone gave me him, one of my faves of all time and defo staying forever
1: vesta: an angel on earth, the reason i exist

Post automatically merged: Apr 4, 2020

idk why i said bones, i meant chops, i don't even like typing his name so maybe that's why

 

[TearsFromEatingFlan]

10. Huck - I like smug but not this frog. Does nothing for me. I want 2 smug villagers on my island but Huck is not one of them.
9. Rolf - I don't like this cranky villager, he scares me. I don't enjoy talking to him and I don't like his eyes. His house is ok (outdoorsy theme) but that's about it. I'll switch him out with Walt when I get the chance.
8. Biff - He just moved into my island and while I do think he looks adorable, I am not too keen on jocks. I can't handle having two jocks in my town so between him and Genji, I am kicking Biff out. Also I hate his house interior (graffiti/street).
7. Alice - Oh Alice. She is normal hence she's very sweet but she is so BORING. I guess normal villagers are like this. She's my only normal villager right now but I don't like her enough to keep her. There are other normal villagers who grab my attention more.
6. Flo - I love the uchi personality but Flo is just okay. She was my starter villager so we've gotten pretty close. She looks cute but there are other uchi villagers I would rather have.
5. Peggy - She's so sweet! I love her eyes and hair and she is always talking about wanting to be a popstar! I enjoy her....but I also want to replace her with another peppy villager. Actually, I am going to replace her. I just like other peppy villagers more. However, I am glad to have come across her.
4. Blanche - She is new to me but I quite like her. I love snooty villagers and her look is one I think is great. Her catchphrase "quite so" is kinda annoying. I am debating on whether or not to keep her in my village as I already have snooty favorites. For now, she is one I talk to everyday.
3. Lionel - This guy is so cool! I LOVE his outfit and his white fur. He's smug so we get along fine. I am definitely keeping him forever until a better smug villager gets released in the future.
2. Genji - This game is the first time I've ever heard of him?! I feel like I've never seen him before in my whole years of playing this series. Boy did I get attached to him when I first started NH. He's a jock so it is annoying to hear about his muscles but he's very nice and motivating! I love his Japanese style and I think he's one of the best designed. I am keeping him forever.
1. Tiffany - GOD I LOVE HER!!! She is so cool and beautiful. She has FISHNETS on, I think they're hot (is that weird to think...?) I put her in the game via amiibo after another villager asked me if he could move away (I said yes and took that opportunity to move Tiffany into the new empty house). I love snooty villagers and Tiffany is my #1 bae out of my current villagers. She's a keeper for sure.

 

[Pretty Dead Boy]

6) Hugh - He just waltzed in an empty lot, and I didn’t appreciate that.

5) Curlos - He’s my first camper to move in, and I wasn’t thrilled to have him, but I’m slowly feeling okay with him.

4) Dom - I’m not a huge fan of Jock types since GC, but I really like the interactions in New Horizons.

3) Cherry - She’s tough and kind! Plus she actually likes taking care of kids. She used to be an excellent babysitter.

2) Piper - She’s got a lot of energy, but she’s been really nice to me. Gave me some sweet kicks and manage to get a non-existent infomercial jingle for the vault pole to stick in my head.

1) Maple - She’s my very first island villager I talked to and invited over to my island. She’s super sweet and pretty conspiratorial. It’s a blast chatting with her.

 

[MrBox]

10: Eugene: I never liked him. Never will. I keep whacking him with my net every time I see him.
9: Sandy: I don't know her very well but I would like her to wear a beanie.
8: Jerimiah: I'm only having him in my town right now for a friend.
7: Rodeo: Cool design!
6: Francine: She's alright. I've had Chrissy in my New Leaf town.
5: Sheldon: He's so cute!!!
4: Merengue: I didn't like her before but she's okay.
3: Dom: Very cute. I wish he didn't talk about working out all the time though.
2: Rodeo: I like him.
1: Pashmina: Super cool! I love her.

 

[Cheburashka]

10. Diva: Seriously?? Of all uchis there could be I ended up with Diva, my least favourite villager ever, as an original villager and she just won't move out
9. Ricky: I keep forgetting, he even exists. I don't hate him but wouldn't care if he moved out.
8. Jacques: Hated him in New Leaf but he looks cute with different hats and glasses
7. Bam: My second original villager. Not much of a fan but he's ok.
6. Bluebear: She's cute but I've never been a big fan of the peppy personality.
5. Skye: She's a ray of sunshine. Sends me letters almost daily and whenever I meet her she's singing.
4. Eugene: Just moved in and I've never had him before but I love koalas.
3. Zucker: Cutie!! <3
2. Roald: My first Amiibo card move-in and the best Jock ever. Won't let him go...
1. Ozzie: The cutest ever! I bought an overprized Ozzie amiibo card just to make sure to have him on my island and ultimately he ended up being my second random move-in.

 

[Bugs]

Hans is moving in today and he's my all time favourite villager so he's obviously no. 1, other than that...

7. Renée: I hate her pinkness, and she's pretty boring imo, she doesn't seem to want to talk to me much either so seems mutual hahaha
6. Bangle: She's okay, again kinda boring never really talks about or does anything interesting.
5. Mac: He's a sweet guy, kinda funny looking which I like, he's okay but I'll probably swap him at some point.
4. Tia: She's a quirky villager both in design and personality, I love that she's always checking out the flowers!
3. Del: he's pretty cool looking, I like most of the crocodiles so he's very welcome.
2. Stitches: adorable little bear! He's so cute and he's always after bugs, which I can relate to personally.
1. Cube: when I was a kid playing the GCN game, I really wanted this guy! So when I saw him on an island I had to have him! He's a big cutie

 

[moon_child]

10. Ed - He’s the one the campsite forced on me. I don’t HATE him or anything but I don’t really like him either. He’s okay. Keeping him just for the sake of having a smug.

9. Deirdre - My starting Uchi. Had her in NL. Love-hate relationship. I’m not the biggest fan of Uchis in general, I just like Fuchsia most out of all of them. She can leave whenever she wants. Letting her stay because I want all personalities.

8. Sprinkle - My first peppy in my island. Got her when I was island hopping because she looked cute and I don’t dislike her. But she’s leaving because I invited a camper today. She’s the one I booted out because I also have Audie in my town, who’s a peppy and is never leaving.

7. Billy - My starting jock. He’s not bad. We’ve gotten pretty close. Which is a surprise because I don’t like goats in this game in general. But he’s a good guy. He can stay as long as he wants but I won’t stop him from moving because I also have Rudy in my town, who’s a jock and I’m keeping Rudy forever.

6. Whitney - Awooooo she’s growing on me. She’s so pretty. I have three wolves in my town and I prefer variety in species but I can’t help myself and I think I might keep her around for a loooooong time. She’s so classy and sophisticated. And her voice is so soothing.

5. Chief - He’s my cranky and he’ll stay forever in my island. He’s also still in my NL town. He was a starter there. I don’t want any other crankies. It’s Chief or nothing.

4. Audie - Oh my. My wolves. She’s new, she’s gorgeous, she’s difficult to find. She’s a peppy I can tolerate. And that’s saying a lot. Peppies get on my nerve but not her. Never her. She’s in my island for good.

3. Zucker - He’s sooooo sweet. I never had him before. But now I’m in love. I’m never letting him go. I don’t even care if he has the starter house and not his default house because he’s one of my first move ins. I don’t care. I love him so much.

2. Rudy - HAHAHA. I ADORE THIS CAT AND HIS DOPEY SMILEY FACE. I won’t ever let him leave. I want to see that dopey smile all around my island. I like making fun of him. I like when he laughs. I like when he gets mad. I will never get over his expressions. That face is a face that will never disappear from my island or any of my towns. His dopey smiley face is also in my NL town. I’m never getting sick of it.

1. Molly - I wanted her for so long in NL but never got the chance to have her. She’s so smol I can’t handle the cuteness. Unfortunately, I don’t have any amiibos and I even reset some NL towns just trying to find her but to no avail. In NH, she found me. I got her off my third mystery tour and it felt like fate. Like Zucker, I don’t care if she’s in a starter home and not her default one. She’s never leaving.

 

[capnport]

10. Pietro. I surprisingly don't hate him, but his personality is annoying and he's difficult to draw.
9. T-Bone. Like Pietro, he's difficult to draw, but unlike Pietro, I like the way he acts.
8. Benedict. In New Leaf, he moved right directly next to my house (which I had placed close to Re-Tail in order to get there fast) and blocked my path to Re-Tail.
7. Daisy. I have nothing against her, but her design is boring.
6. Cheri. I like her, but... I don't love her. Also, it's easy to confuse her name with Shari's.
5. Shari. Same as Cheri, but my mom likes her, which gives her bonus likability points.
4. Puddles. Her mouth looks weird, but she's an adorable little pink frog with a bubbly personality.
3. Gigi. I love her lots and she'd be #1 if it wasn't for the next two.
2. Gayle. Adorable design, adorable personality, and she was the first to decide to call me "Sunflower." Her little snaggletooth sticking up is just so perfect.
1. Axel. One of my starting villagers. I love elephants, and jocks in ACNH are much better than they were in ACNL. I don't know if I'm allowed to say this word, but... Axel is a himbo.

 

[idiotdoomspiral]

10) moe - was my camper so i didnt have a choice, plus i have too many cats. im probably gonna use my amiibo card to replace him if the glitch doesnt affect me
9) antonio - jock is my least favourite personality but hes ok, amiibo card sentence as well
8) tangy - maybe i never noticed this in previous games but her face looks weird now
7) gladys - boring design imo, not too bad
6) muffy - good uchi, love her colours
5) rodeo - cows look a lot better in this game, very cute
4) peanut - essential villager for me, was my favourite back when i was playing ww
3) kiki - has grown on me a lot
2) dobie - sweet old man
1) kyle - kyle
0) jeremiah would be here...if i had one...

 

[mizzsnow]

9. Bubbles - just NO! made even worse because peppy villagers are my favorite but she is just so butt ugly, and the game keeps forcing me to talk to her. no, I want her to move out
8. Mac - mostly here because I don't really care for jock villagers
7. Ike - only here because I needed a cranky villager, I wish I didn't get him though because his "voice" makes me feel sick to my stomach (literally). idk why
6. Annalise - she ended up moving into one of my free plots while I was trying to look for mystery tour villagers so that soured my perception of her
5. Plucky - I don't hate her but I'm honestly really indifferent to her, would rather have another uchi
4. Alice - thought I would absolutely hate her when she moved in, realized she's actually super cute and I love her! she's just a little lower because she's kinda plain
3. Phil - also thought I would hate him when he moved in (forced campsite recruit) but his dialogue and expressions ended up being very amusing to me, I love him
2. Francine - she is just too cute oh my god. I love the human-looking villagers way too much. idk if this is in the other games but there's a photo of Chrissy in her house and on that moment I decided I needed Chrissy on my island to reunite them
1. Beau - I got him from a mystery tour, I only got him because I knew he was popular and I thought I could trade him later but he grew on me way too much he's precious