Phoebe or Queenie?

[CJChamp]

I was randomly given both Phoebe and Queenie on my island. They are both of the Ostrich species and I only want to keep one. Phoebe is Sisterly and Queenie is Snooty. Everywhere I look says that Queenie is not worth having and that Phoebe is, but to tell you the truth I am slightly leaning towards keeping Queenie but I don't want to regret it later on. What do you all think, if it was you would you keep Phoebe or Queenie and why. Thanks for the help.

 

[Jam86]

i've never had queenie before but i really like her design and i had phoebe on new leaf and tbh she's not really that good imo

so if it were me i'd pick queenie, but at the end of the day it's ur choice of who u would like on ur island ^-^

 

[Snek]

I would keep Phoebe because she is MY favourite uchi and I personally do not like Queenie. If you want to keep Queenie then you should go with your heart and keep her.

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

If you personally like Queenie more than Phoebe, then keep Queenie. Do whatever makes you happy, as it's your game!

 

[Yujian]

I'd definitely keep Phoebe. I used to have her but I hated her starter house.

 

[Klauser_Bateson]

Seems to me like you should keep Queenie. I think I would too in this case. I like Phoebe a lot, but I'm not a fan of her house interior in New Horizons.

 

[Raz]

Phoebe. Always Phoebe.

 

[Lavamaize]

Ultimately it is your choice and opinion that really matters since it's your island! If it was me personally though, I would keep Phoebe!

 

[meggiewes]

Forget what everyone says and pick your favorite.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

I think it is irrelevant what people say. There is nothing objectively better about Phoebe than queenie, it is all just opinion. Since it is your island, your opinion is the most valuable! And in the end, having the less popular villager makes your island more unique!

 

[Skandranon]

I'm biased because I liked phoebe enough to buy the amiibo card to guarantee getting her

 

[Sharksheep]

Personally I like them both but I like a lot more snooty villagers than sisterly villagers so I would pick Phoebe

 

[Your Local Wild Child]

My parents love having Phoebe on their island, and I only have negative memories about Queenie back in CF. Snooties are nicer in this game, though, and if you really prefer having Queenie I’d suggest going with her.

 

[Fye]

I love phoebe so I'm a little biased but I'd go with her! Her design is great and I love her Phoenix theme. If you like your villagers to have more homey house interiors though you might not like her as much since she pretty much lives in a volcano

 

[avieators]

it's all opinion but personally i prefer phoebe! i had her for a long time in nl, shes an old pal of mine :3 queenie's good too, although i dont have any personal experience w her i like her design!

 

[-Lumi-]

Honestly I think if you like Queenie more than that automatically makes her worth more to you. There’s not a whole lot of sense in keeping Phoebe just because she’s popular if you don’t personally enjoy her.

I have Phoebe and I don’t care for her tons. She was one of my starters so her default house isn’t the best looking and I’m just not a fan of sisterly villagers So between the two I would pick Queenie but honestly I’m not a huge fan of her design either and there’s lots of snooty & sisterly villagers! at the end of the day tho it’s mainly about who will you’ll be happy to see on your island

 

[visibleghost]

i personally prefer phoebe but that's because i have had her in new leaf and grew to really like her. if you like queenie, i say keep her. choosing the most popular villager won't make you happier than choosing a villager you actually really like

 

[Xara]

i’ve had both before but i personally prefer phoebe! i just really love how she’s designed to look like a phoenix and think she’s incredibly gorgeous and fun to have around!

however, don’t make this decision based off of our opinions; if you’re leaning more towards keeping queenie, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that! queenie is a great, villager, too, and keeping her wouldn’t be the wrong decision if that’s what would make you happy.

 

[Airysuit]

I think you should try to choose the one that makes you happy the most

 

[CJChamp]

Thanks all for the input. I will choose the one that I finally settle on. Just wanted to get some other opinions.