I like to have at least one of every personality type to keep the dialog interesting. I currently have 2 Uchi, 2 Cranky, 1 Snooty, 1 Peppy, 1 Jock, 1 Lazy, 1 Normal, and 1 Smug.
In my town, I have 3 normals, 2 crankies, 1 smug, 1 peppy, 1 jock, 1 snooty and 1 lazy! I don't exactly love the normal personality, but there are so many cute villagers with normal personalities so its hard to choose who to let go lol
I really like the smug, lazy, uchi, and snooty villagers the best. But as far as uchi villagers go the personality I love, but the villagers are so weird themselves. Snooty villagers are really funny, lazy villagers are hard not to love, and smugs are really charming and fun.
Right now, I have two normals, one jock, one uchi, one peppy, one cranky, three lazies, one snooty!
When I get everyone I want, I'll have one jock, two crankies, one smug, one uchi, one snooty, one lazy and three normals (I know, I know... I wish they were other personalities but I like Fauna, Poppy and Coco too much!)
Right now I have 2 crankies, 2 normals, 1 snooty, 1 peppy, 1 smug, 1 lazy and 1 uchi.
I'm having difficulty finding a jock I like. I like Bill and Teddy, but I'm not sure.
Also, I think when I've unlocked all the PWP's, I'll replace Muffy someone else (please Muffy! Give me wisteria trellis!) . I like her, but right now I only have her because she's an uchi (and also because her house is pretty sweet lol). Plus, there are other villagers that I like more.