Peppy you'd recommend?

[FRANS_PLAYER]

My island is lacking a peppy due to them being my least favorite personality (obviously no hate to the peppy fans, you're entitled to your opinion!) and so far I've had Ketchup and Merry. I wouldn't mind Freckles, Anabelle, Carmen, or Dotty (who reminds me of my old pet rabbit.) Would love to hear others opinions though ^_^

 

[WalceDony]

TANGY TANGY TANGY They my cute lil !!!

 

[Underneath The Stars]

i like bunnie, so cute! can't go wrong with the cats too, rosie & tangy. i like peanut too but her coloring seems a bit off in new horizons, idk. but then again never had her in-game yet maybe it's just in pics. she's still in my new leaf town.

 

[tajikey]

I like Tutu. She's HUGE, but always so kind spirited and easy on the eyes.

 

[FRANS_PLAYER]

i like bunnie, so cute! can't go wrong with the cats too, rosie & tangy. i like peanut too but her coloring seems a bit off in new horizons, idk. but then again never had her in-game yet maybe it's just in pics. she's still in my new leaf town.

Bunnie is supposedly inspired by the core of an apple and my island fruit is apples so that would work nice!

 

[Underneath The Stars]

Bunnie is supposedly inspired by the core of an apple and my island fruit is apples so that would work nice!

well i did a good job guessing lol initially just suggested her because i saw cole on your pic so i assumed you'd have him so maybe she'd fit your island

 

[FRANS_PLAYER]

well i did a good job guessing lol initially just suggested her because i saw cole on your pic so i assumed you'd have him so maybe she'd fit your island

There is not one bad rabbit fight me on this

 

[loveclove]

Bluebear is very cute and fits the personality well

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

Bluebear is totally adorable. My S/O has Cheri and Rosie on his island, and they're both super cute and fit the personality really well!

 

[Selky]

Wendy, Tabby, Ruby, and Carmen are my personal favorites.

 

[Serabee]

TANGY TANGY TANGY They my cute lil !!!

I second this! She's my favorite peppy ☺ Though I personally like a lot of peppies! My current peppy, who was one of my first villagers (still has her basic house) is Merry, but you've had her She's another one of my favorites, though. I personally love all peppy cats!
...Except Tabby, her face weirds me out personally

EDIT: Oh! I'm also considering switching Merry up soon (again, I've had her since day one, and I started this island a couple days after release, lol). My thoughts for peppies I want are in my siggy. I'm also interested in Bonbon because I LOVE her face. It's so cute, and I think it's one of the most detailed and unique faces in the game. Also, I love Peggy. She strikes me as a country girl who dreams of making it big as a superstar and I think that's adorable!

 

[Alicia]

I have Tangy and I love her. I also really loved Peanut when I had her.

 

[Pendragon1980]

I just got ketchup via amiibo card and I think she’s absolutely adorable

 

[Masenkochick]

TANGY!

 

[Nunnafinga]

Tangy and Tutu are both good peppies.Tangy is medium size and Tutu is large economy size.

 

[Wolfie]

Rosie and Ketchup ❤❤

 

[Snowifer]

I really like Agent S and Ruby! Ruby also has the perks of having a cool moon themed home.

 

[Yorli]

Not a fan of peppys either but I love Ruby! Originally got her because I needed a peppy and her house fit my island theme but OMG I love her now. She doesn't go on as much as the other peppys I've met about being a popstar. A lot of the time she talks abou how much she loves the moon! She also loves when I visit her house to"validate her life choices".

 

[Manon_Despoina]

I love Peanut! Normally she would be too pink an cutesy for me, but I had her in Wild World (she is real og and on the cover of that game) and she was great. Now I have her for nostalgic reasons, since they really downplayed the personalities in this game..

Do you have a "nostalgic" peppy? Maybe that would make it easier to get somewhat attached to them in this game.

 

[Aurita]

I’d recommend Flora or Ruby! Flora is a cute flamingo and I love her so much and Ruby has a super cool house and she’s the “moon rabbit”

Tangy was my first peppy in NL and she was great so I’d recommend her too