Overrated and Underrated villagers

[Nizzy]

overrated: julian, molly,Rosie&nd zucker. i never really understand the hype about these ones here, it literally baffles me


underrated:Kitty ,tiffany &Monique I never understand why ppl dont love them like i do. they all are really cute

 

[SeraphicOrder]

Overrated: Lolly - sorry but she looks really simple... is she even a she? she looks like a boy but I think she's a she... she's a normal cat right? sorry Lolly.

Underrated: Static - I just got him and he looks cool. He has a lightning pattern in his head like Harry Potter. He is a rock star but he's in tier 4. Maybe because he is cranky...he should have been smug.

 

[Nizzy]

Underrated: Static - I just got him and he looks cool. He has a lightning pattern in his head like Harry Potter. He is a rock star but he's in tier 4. Maybe because he is cranky...he should have been smug.

THIS

I love static his one of the best crankys ever

 

[Amphibian]

Overrated: Beau, Zucker

Underrated: Dotty, Bonbon, Hazel, Pecan, Willow, Static, Felicity, Melba

 

[Akimari]

Overrated: Merengue. I have her in my village (she was a starter) and apparently she's in tier 1? Dear lord. When she moves out I know EXACTLY what I'm doing with her now. She's cute, but I don't totally get the appeal.

Underrated: I posted about him before in another thread, but definitely Benjamin. He's such a cute lil lazy puppy. Why isn't he more loved? ;_;

 

[gravyplz]

I find all the octopi overrated, i mean just look at them. Not to mention you catch and sell off their close relatives.
Also marshal is a bit bland, i don't quite understand the fuss

 

[flutterstheunicorn]

Overrated: TBH i really don't like the wolves and octopi all that much, and also ROSIE. Why is she popular anyways?

Underrated: The birds, especially Midge! She's adorable! Most of the ducks are pretty awesome too!

 

[Akimari]

Overrated: TBH i really don't like the wolves and octopi all that much, and also ROSIE. Why is she popular anyways?

I think part of Rosie's popularity may stem from her being one of the main characters in the Animal Crossing anime movie? That's how I discovered her.

 

[Lunar Dust]

Overrated, I gotta say Marshal. He's an angry looking, cranky squirrel. I really don't see the appeal. Same with Merengue; I have her and she isn't very exciting. Cute, but not great.

Underrated, both Annalise (she's such a cute little snooty horse villager oh my goodness <3) and the female kangaroos. Seriously, I think they all look really awesome with the joeys, mimicking their mother's movements in their pouches. It's the coolest thing, really it is.

 

[mitzi_crossing]

Overrated for me is definitely Marshal, I just don't get why people like him

Underrated would be Tucker (come on, he's a mammoth!) And maybe Drago too, I know he's somewhat popular but I expected him to be Tier 1 quality being a dragon

 

[Rosie :)]

overrated: Julian even though I absolutely adore him because he was a random move in from 2013, and I still have him, HOP ON THE JULIANN TRAAAINNN WHOOT WHOOT. XD
underrated: MELBA, BREE, (both starters), ZELL, CHERRY, DEIRDRE, MIRA, I could preach more...

 

[Shay10]

I think coach is super underrated I've had him since i started playing acnl and he is one villager i can always get along with. ummmmmm most of the first tier villagers are overrated

 

[Rosie :)]

Also daisy, she reminds me of Emma and Perseus (my dogs)

 

[tumut]

Chevre and Soleil are both really pretty looking.

Also Jeremiah, Static, Avery, Agnes, Frita, Jacques, Benjamin.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh and Beau and Stitches are pretty overrated. Stitches' color scheme makes me wanna vomit, and I'd like Beau if he wasn't bright cheesy orange and had antlers instead of horns.

 

[LunaLight]

Overrated: Punchy. Like, what the heck? He looks tired or cranky or something. But maybe that's why he's popular? I dunno but he just looks simple. Also deirdre, she looks terrifying. Like she'll eat your eyes out when you're sleeping. And Lolly; I like her a lot, but too popular. She has a grammatical symbol for eyes. Well, I guess she's perfect for all the grammar nazis and people who need to punctuate better.

Underrated: Mint. She's too damn cute, I love her. Those cute little rosey cheeks. <3 Also Apple; She has eyes like Rosie which is cute. Oh, and Merry. I love her. Although I hate her haircut. LOL.

 

[Coolio15]

Overrated: Beau, Julian, and Erik
Underrated: Deli, Bangle, Apple, and Soleil

 

[Lightspring]

Overrated: Julian. No offense to people that like him, but he's just a unicorn! He also reminds me of the unknown depths of the MLP fandom... Sorry about that...

Underrated: Cally! I don't understand why she's in Tier 5! She's just so cute, and her tail looks like a cinnamon bun!

 

[moonford]

Overrated: Most of the Wolves, Muffy, Marshal, Beau & Rosie.
Underrated: Antonio, Papi, Tucker, Flora, Sprinkle, Annalisa, Flurry, Ruby & Bunnie.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I feel like Annalise, Colton, Cranston, Gladys & Pietro or underrated too.

 

[AccfSally]

Overrated: King Marshal ( even if I have him and currently looking for him), Poppy (even if she's in tier 4 right now, she's still overrated. Even though I have her too), Beau (He was voided into one of my towns once, got bored of him), Merengue (invited her into my town once and got bored of her in a week and kicked her out), Diana, Whitney, Zucker and Drago (ew!)

Underrated: My sweet Sally, Cally, Ricky, Hazel, Henry, Ken, Chadder, Sheldon, Doc, Broccolo, all mice really, all hamsters (even Flurry), Prince, Freckles (starting to warm up to, she's actually not that bad), Caroline, Blaire, Nibbles and more

 

[AppleTart0]

Julian, Beau and Lolly are far too overrated..

Julian's a HORSE with a horn, get over it
Beau has creepy eyes, go find Erik, he's better <3
Lolly is cute, but she's so ordinary.. Kiki or Mitzi's better.. Or, maybe a better Normal like Sydney, Molly or even Merengue

Bangle, Sydney, Ren?e, Rocket, Simon and Ozzie are all extremely underrated

I really like Kiki, but she's probably underrated because people think her eyes are creepy and big (I don't though), like some people think about Coco.
And I agree, Beau's eyes are a bit...Unsettling.

But I just hate Julian for some reason.