Overrated and Underrated villagers

[Captain Crazy Chicken]

cute signature, rabbite

PF, your post is off topic.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Marshal is SO overhyped. He's an EVIL-LOOKING SQUIRREL!

My underhyped ones are Penelope, Beardo, Biskit, Pecan, and O'Hare!!

 

[Chipped-Teacup]

Gonna have to jump on the Marshal wagon, but also Julian. I had him in my town for about three weeks, and he kept asking to move XD plus besides his gorgeous house, he isn't all that amazing. My friend had Static (moving out today) and I really like him, and also Hazel I know she has a unibrow, but she is so cute!

 

[rabbite]

cute signature, rabbite

Thank you, although it changes on its own.

Gonna have to jump on the Marshal wagon, but also Julian. I had him in my town for about three weeks, and he kept asking to move XD plus besides his gorgeous house, he isn't all that amazing. My friend had Static (moving out today) and I really like him, and also Hazel I know she has a unibrow, but she is so cute!

Static is really cute! He's one of my favorites honestly.

 

[Earth Wolf-Howl]

also Hazel I know she has a unibrow, but she is so cute!

I definitely agree with you right here. I have Hazel in my town, and once you get past the unibrow, she's one of the most lovable villagers you can have- and believe me, I'm not normally do fond of the Uchi personality! She needs a lot more love.

I know I have Marshal too, but... yeah. He kind of is rather overrated, even if I do like him as well.

 

[groovymayor]

Overrated: Muffy. I had her, she wasn't special to me.
Underrated: Elmer! My little baby Elmer! I lost him in my old town and miss him terribly.

 

[MayorCaroo]

I definitely agree with you right here. I have Hazel in my town, and once you get past the unibrow, she's one of the most lovable villagers you can have- and believe me, I'm not normally do fond of the Uchi personality! She needs a lot more love.

I LOVE Hazel!! I almost cycled her out because of her unibrow but she's so, so sweet! Really glad I kept her. She's given me medicine (without fail!!) everytime I have a run in with them annoying bees! She's like a protective older sister, definitely one of my absolute favorites.

 

[Thegamingcrosser]

Julian is way overrated

 

[patriceflanders]

overrated: Merengue

underrated: Rasher

 

[Hyoshido]

Overrated, Marshal, Julian, etc.

Underrated, Cesar, he's my goddamn BABE.

 

[Cloud Arcanine]

Overrated: Never really seen the hype over Merengue and Stitches, the latter kinda freaks me out if i'm honest

Underrated: Pretty much every single elephant- excluding Tia of course. I don't see anyone talk about them, which is quite sad really because in my opinion, Dizzy is the ridiculously cute

 

[Pheenic]

Overrated: Marshal, i love him but yeah
Underrated: Cole, such a cutie <3

 

[Yukari Yakumo]

Over: Rosie, Coco, Kabuki(have the last two; yes they're interesting, but most is hype)
Under: Mira, Bonbon, Pierce, Keaton, Annalise

 

[Plupap]

I think Lolly is wayyyyy to boring to be that popular. Rosie looks really unnatural. I know the cats are popular, I understand Ankha, but some popular cats are overrated. Beau and Fauna are both ugly IMO with their eyes. Also, Julian is REALLY overrated. Honestly, if nobody told me he was a unicorn, I couldn't tell. My friend had him and had no clue he was a unicorn. I have Marshal and he tries to act sophisticated unlike Ken, one of my favorite villagers. I got so annoyed of Marshal acting smart, I changed his catchphrase to "herp derp". It's pretty funny now. My all time least favorite villager is Genji. He's HIDEOUS in my opinion. One of my least favorite villagers was Pippy and he looks like an uglier version of her.

Underrated, Ken is definately one. He's probably the most popular chicken but that's not saying much. My all time favorite villager is Caroline. She's well liked but not popular. Also, Moose is adorable and he's own of my favorites.

 

[The221Believer]

Overrated: Marshal. He's cute, but the smug personality does not work on him. Something about the height. I won't be keeping him, either, as his house is horribly ugly.

Underrated: Oh, Freya, definitely. She's grand, gorgeous, and named after the coolest goddess.

 

[creamyy]

Overrated: Marshal, yeah he's kinda cute but he's not THAT cute where it's a major fuss
Underrated: Derwin, Drake & Joey
They are my favourite ducks, they're adorable lazies.

 

[Dunquixote]

Overrated: I'll list some later; I'm not sure yet.
Underrated: Puddles ~ I don't care for frogs -- real or animated; but, I have to admit that I couldn't prevent myself from getting attached to Puddles. Even as I continue to meet other peppy characters ~ including ones that I guess I can now call my "dreamies," I find that there is something unique and irresistibly cute about her in spite of them all sharing the same dialogue.

 

[Rydyekal]

Gayle is sooo underrated. She's adorable!

 

[Astro Cake]

Cheri and Bluebear are underrated.

 

[Kolechia]

Overrated: Julian, Marshal and Beau.

Underrated: Bunnie and Bill... they are so cute X3 they are my babies xx

 

[FallinDevast]

Overrated: I personally think the wolves are overrated, I had Fang as a starter and I can't appreciate the aesthetics of his spiky hair

Underrated: Definitely the frogs, ducks and koalas, people only recall Lily(frogs), Molly(ducks) and barely any koala. Jeremiah, Drift, Frobert, Camofrog and Puddles have interesting coloration. Bill and Drake may look whacky but their colors are all too natural and Joey has his diapers. Melba, probably the cutest villager I have come across barely receive any mention.