Overrated and Underrated villagers

[Luerna]

Overrated, pretty much everyone listed so as such so far XD

Underrated, Pudgie! I adore him, and think he's too cute! When I first got him, I hated him as I wanted Stitches, and I felt he was a discount Stitches XD But I love him. He looks so sad all the time, but it makes everything so much better when he smiles <3
Also, Rasher. Dat smiling face though omg XD

 

[Spongebob]

Seriously, the most underrated villager is Sheldon. The only time I've ever seen him in game was in my campsite. I have never seen any village with him in it. What's up with that?

OMG I've wanted Sheldon for forever. After seeing him on my acnl poster I've been trying to find him for MONTHS.

 

[Frjck]

Overrated: Beau and Marshal. Personally Beau looks similar to Lopez (who I prefer) but idk. I agree with a lot of these posts saying Marshal is decent but I don't really understand why people obsess over him! He is literally a white squirrel (maybe if they are simplistic then they would like him, but other than that he is so plain!).

Underrated: Coco! I love this little bunny to bits! She is so adorable and kind! I had her in my town for a little bit, but accidentally voided her! She was one of the best villagers I have ever had! She is the main motivation for me buying a second copy (so I dont have to cycle 16 villager out with 8 other dreamies in my town). Coco is pure cute and kind! My favorite normal villager!

 

[itsrainingnekos]

My favourite villagers are Lily, Celia, Moe and Kitty. They are my favourites.
Although I like Fauna, she is a bit overrated.Marshal is cute but he is overrated.

 

[daniduckyface]

Overrated: Marshal (for sure no offense, gonna get slammed for this), most deer (the all deer town is common)
Underrated: most eagles, Chevre, omg there's so many i can name...

 

[Shimmer]

Beau. I don't find him that appealing...

To have him super popular makes me scratch my head.

 

[loreiid]

Overrated: Marshal (I have him in my town, whoops) Marina, Zucker, Merengue, Julian

im against all the hype for marshal, but he has been in my town forever so im a bit attached.

its really boring to see all the same villagers ^^^ in everyones town.

Underrated: Nate, Agnes, and Hazel!! Nate is my favorite and i personally think we should appreciate villagers with good (uni)brow game Also Agnes is a strong uchi and she is so sassy and pushy and I love her

 

[DarkFox7]

Definitely Beau. I don't get his popularity at all. I've seen him in a billion dream towns yet I still can't see the appeal. I just don't get the hype, his design is too boring and his eyes are icky.

The most underrated villager? Wow there's a lot. Goldie, Aurora, Chevre, Caroline, Cookie, Apple, Agnes, Cherry, Kyle, Butch, Portia, Bones, Walker, Frobert, Ribbot, Cousteau, Jeremiah, Hopper, Gwen, Cube, Bella, Nibbles, Filbert, Frita, Willow, Wendy, Bianca, Rowan, Leonardo, Mott, Daisy, Hamphrey, Graham, Kidd, Nan, Gala, there's probably a heck of a lot more but I'm really tired.

 

[Soundmotion]

Marshal is waay overrated.

Pierce is underrated, actually I've never seen him mentioned on TBT.

 

[Preet]

Overrated: Marshal, Stitches

Underrated: Lucky, Biskit, Ozzie

 

[CJODell62]

I feel like a lot of villages are looked over just because of their species, in particular Rhinos (Merengue aside), Ducks, and Frogs. Not a fan of hippos but Bertha is adorbs.

I have Bertha in my first town, Westerly. In fact, she's one of my original villagers. Definitely the cutest hippo I've ever seen.

 

[beebcrossing]

Underrated: Goldie and Melba

 

[Heyden]

Yuka is underrated. The only snooty I like c:

 

[patriceflanders]

overrated : Zucker - ugly, ugly, ugly and boooooring / Stitches - really boring too after a while and hate his house (out and in)

underrated : Elvis (come on, tier 5 ??)

 

[tumut]

Overrated: Beau, he's cute I guess but boring compared to other lazies.
Whitney, Chief, and Wolfgang are all pretty ugly.
Also Chrissy and Francine are so ugly and creepy. Their bug eyes and caked on makeup makes them look like aliens.

Underrated: Jeremiah, Avery, Agnes, Ed, Cube, Purrl, Hans.

 

[Lavochain]

Overated : Merengue, I don't dislike her at all however I wouldn't go out of my way to keep her!

Underrated : Hugh. No one ever seems to mention him and I used to adore him a couple years back in my town. I can't wait to get him again.

 

[patriceflanders]

Overated : Merengue, I don't dislike her at all however I wouldn't go out of my way to keep her!

Underrated : Hugh. No one ever seems to mention him and I used to adore him a couple years back in my town. I can't wait to get him again.

I totally agree... I like Hugh too (my daughter has him and it took forever to find him, he apparently gets auto-voided a lot)

 

[Lavochain]

I totally agree... I like Hugh too (my daughter has him and it took forever to find him, he apparently gets auto-voided a lot)

What a shame for him. He was my best friend and really sweet as far as I can remember. Hopefully I can build that relationship with him again.

 

[rabbite]

Overrated: Uh, imo it's Marshal. My friend has him, but eh.
Underrated: Chester! I don't know why, but I really like his design, and he's really one of my favorites I had so far. If I had another game, I'd probably get him (somehow).

 

[patriceflanders]

cute signature, rabbite