couldnt agree with you more
Overrated and Underrated villagers
- Thread starter cannedcommunism
- Start date
couldnt agree with you more
Dembonez19
The Beaubysitter
I think Julian is way overrated. So was Colton in the beginning, but I think his popularity has died down considerably after the fan art boom.
Boomer, Boone, and Joey are underrated, in my opinion. I love Boomer's pilot get-up, Joey's in diapers, and Boone has a blue butt! I feel like a lot of the gorillas could use some extra love though...but especially Boone (and Cesar).
Boomer, Boone, and Joey are underrated, in my opinion. I love Boomer's pilot get-up, Joey's in diapers, and Boone has a blue butt! I feel like a lot of the gorillas could use some extra love though...but especially Boone (and Cesar).
overrated: drago/hopper/peanut/every popular villager ive let move out except ankha
i dont understand why people like them so much god dang theyre annoying
underrated: rasher
HES a CUTIE!!! A big cutie!!! hes the best pig and maybe best 2nd cranky :- )
queenie is underrated too ok shes cute and cool
scoot is a major cutie i dont know why hes not popular?? i mean he has underwear on his head hes adorable
tammy too ok people think shes ugly because of her makeup but shes super cute and nice
i dont understand why people like them so much god dang theyre annoying
underrated: rasher
HES a CUTIE!!! A big cutie!!! hes the best pig and maybe best 2nd cranky :- )
queenie is underrated too ok shes cute and cool
scoot is a major cutie i dont know why hes not popular?? i mean he has underwear on his head hes adorable
tammy too ok people think shes ugly because of her makeup but shes super cute and nice
mapleshine
Proud Filipino
Overrated: MERENGUE, Marshal, Julian
Underrated: Ok, I personally adore Joey. I had him in ACWW and he was the sweetest.
I also think Goldie, Daisy and Aurora are underrated. All three are adorbs.
Underrated: Ok, I personally adore Joey. I had him in ACWW and he was the sweetest.
I also think Goldie, Daisy and Aurora are underrated. All three are adorbs.
greywizard06
Octopus Enthusiast
Marina is a little overrated. Don't get me wrong I want her in my village because I like marine biology and octopuses but I feel I shouldn't have to pay in the millions for a villager. Like come on...
I feel Marcel is very underrated. I picked him up on a whim to avoid him being voided by another user and because I have a soft spot for lazy personality type villagers. He has grown to become one of my favorite villagers and I think he deserves a little more of the spotlight for his personality type. ^^
I feel Marcel is very underrated. I picked him up on a whim to avoid him being voided by another user and because I have a soft spot for lazy personality type villagers. He has grown to become one of my favorite villagers and I think he deserves a little more of the spotlight for his personality type. ^^
Overrated: Marshal (He lives in my town and I do like him quite a lot but he is WAY overrated), Julian, and Zucker & other octopi (idk why but their octopus "beak" creeps me out)
Underrated: Filbert, Chester, Pudge, Maple, & many more.
Underrated: Filbert, Chester, Pudge, Maple, & many more.
Trickilicky
dat tung
OMG I love your avatar! ^^
Well Octopi are my favourite animal so IMO they deserve the adoration ;-) But charcters like Marshal, Julian, Lolly, Rosie, etc, I personally find boring and they don't interest me at all.
Underrated: Tex, Diva (I don't get why no-one likes her?! She's a pretty purple frog!), Flora, Tucker, and Cherry.
Miss Renee
Mayor of Opu
Marshal is by far the most overrated. He has no nose. Seriously.
You want to know who is underrated? PEGGY.
She is absolutely precious but no one seems so care about her.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh my god yes! Joey! He is a sweetie.
You want to know who is underrated? PEGGY.
She is absolutely precious but no one seems so care about her.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Overrated: MERENGUE, Marshal, Julian
Underrated: Ok, I personally adore Joey. I had him in ACWW and he was the sweetest.
Oh my god yes! Joey! He is a sweetie.
Julian is almost one of those characters I want to like, but yet I don't want to become part of the "Julian omg unicorn!!11" club. I like him for his character design as a horse, forget the horn... But in reality people like what they like, I'm not going to try and convince people otherwise, and I certainly won't let that affect my opinions of villagers.
Diva is effing rad. I fell in love with her when I met her in a dream village. I hope she shows up in my camp some day.
My ultimate underrated villager is, as a couple of folks here probably expected me to say, Canberra the koala. She's tough, aggressive, and tomboyish- definitely not the typical girly kawaii sidekick villager that gets all the fan love. I can see Canberra kicking the asses of pretty much everyone in my village if they step out of line. I just know she has my mayor's back.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
Overrated: Merengue and Julian.
Underrated: Rudy, Agent S, and to an extent, Pudge.
Underrated: Rudy, Agent S, and to an extent, Pudge.
StarryACNL
Senior Member
Overated: Julian, MARSHAL, Merengue (even though she a dreamy)
Underated: Anteaters, Some of the squirrels and the penguins! Margie, Rhonda and the bulls as well.
Underated: Anteaters, Some of the squirrels and the penguins! Margie, Rhonda and the bulls as well.
Julian and Marshal are overrated imo, I've had both and loved them (and as you can see I want Marshal back!!) but I think they're waaay too hyped. Same with most of the wolves and the really popular cats like Lolly, Tangy, Bob, etc... even though the cats are my second favorite species!!
I wish there was more ostrich love in general
I know Phoebe is semi-popular but I don't see a lot of people clamoring over them even though I think they're really cute. I wish Julia was in New Leaf!
I wish there was more ostrich love in general
I know Phoebe is semi-popular but I don't see a lot of people clamoring over them even though I think they're really cute. I wish Julia was in New Leaf!
Last edited:
Wallytehcat
Senior Member
I think Caroline is extremely underrated.
cannedcommunism
idk man
Tammy was in my village, but I let her go since my friend wanted her 
Tex, Alfonso, Olaf, Blaire, Caroline, Pierce, Drift, Patty, Snake, Chevre, Eloise, most bears, and most sheep are underrated.
Some villagers that I hated grew on me like Tex. I regret having him go away and now I hope that I can meet him again in my town.
Some villagers that I hated grew on me like Tex. I regret having him go away and now I hope that I can meet him again in my town.
Annemalcrossing
LF: Bunnie and Flora!
I personally think Jeremiah and Hamphrey are seriously underrated. I'll admit, when Jeremiah first moved to my town, (he was from a streetpass) I was like...why....
But!
After becoming friends with him I fell in love! He is soooo cute and really sweet. I let him move because I wanted other villagers, but my boyfriend took him so I could visit him!
And Hamphrey is my best buddy. He is so funny and cute
Also, Jitters is really sweet and cute as well!
But!
After becoming friends with him I fell in love! He is soooo cute and really sweet. I let him move because I wanted other villagers, but my boyfriend took him so I could visit him!
And Hamphrey is my best buddy. He is so funny and cute Also, Jitters is really sweet and cute as well!
Last edited:
Similar threads
