Overrated and Underrated villagers

[Paperboy012305]

Overrated: Beau - Yes he is unique but his blue eyes don't really appeal to me that much. Yes he's perfect for every town but not me...

Underrated: Bonbon and Penelope - I have no idea why they both have to be in tier 5, they're cute for all I say!

 

[seigakaku]

Scoot and Mitzi are definitely underrated. They're so adorable!
I think Julian and Marshal are overrated tbh, I'm tired of seeing them all the time.

 

[thatawkwardkid]

Overrated: Merengue, Beau, Julian, and Marshal for sure

Underrated: Joey, Nibbles, Nate and Rodeo fo sho

 

[SoSu]

Underrated? Grizzly. How do you not love this cranky bear with a heart of gold?

 

[neko-loverx3]

Seriously, the most underrated villager is Sheldon. The only time I've ever seen him in game was in my campsite. I have never seen any village with him in it. What's up with that?

He's such a dork. He constantly sends me letters talking about how 'buff and ripped' he is and getting me presents from his 'huge epic mountain hike'. He's such a dork. Love him though and wouldn't get him out of my town for anything uwu

 

[DaCoSim]

Most underrated IMO is my sweet filbert. I adore his sweet personality and he's adorable as well!

 

[okun0ichio]

one could argue that all tier 1 villagers are overrated but that would be going too far i guess

personally I'm not a big fan of snooty and smug villagers so regardless of how good they are designed to look, I just don't like them. I feel that horses look ugly and Julian doesn't do anything to prove that horses can look good, unicorn or not.

I'm surprised that Annalisa isn't more popular considering how sweet she is, but then again she isn't really the "cute" type that everyone seems to be crazy over so I kinda understand.

Annaisa is my gumdrop.

 

[MayorSaki]

Merengue and Beau are totally overrated. Imo there's nothing special in them and there are so many better normals and lazies.

 

[Hyasynth]

You see cute yet plain villagers like Olivia in Tier 4, yet Marshal and Lolly found their way to Tier 1? Why? Neither of them are anything special.

Underrated: Bonbon and Penelope - I have no idea why they both have to be in tier 5, they're cute for all I say!

this this this. Bonbon has one of the nicest color schemes I've ever seen. If I hadn't been offered Ruby, I would have gone for her as my peppy bun <3

Penelope is the cutest mouse next to Bree. It continues to baffle me how they're both in Tier 5.

 

[MatchaMoonlight]

I don't understand why Stitches is popular. He's creepy if you ask me. And Whitney. Don't even get me started on her. She's popular just because of the movie, I guess? But I mean, she's just a generic female wolf! Why all the fuss?

I don't understand why Pekoe isn't more popular. I mean, look at her! She's adorable! I also think Ozzie and Hamlet should get more love, but I guess I'm just biased because they live in my town.

 

[FallinDevast]

The top two overrated villagers for me are Julian and Ankha. I just find Julian too feminine for a smug, to cater for female players I guess? and I don't like Ankha's face at all, so I traded her for Molly which was the best decision I made in ACNL.

The top two underrated imo would be Bree and Melba. Bree is the most adorable little thing, I can't help but smile whenever she goes snarky on me or retell her feats in marathon and dancing (feats which fit a jock and peppy, respectively). She is a little liar at times and a gossip girl at best but her large emerald eyes does captivate me so I forgive her for being well.. snooty. Melba is up there together with the cutest brown normals namely: Molly, Maple and Fauna, so it's a little downer that she is rarely a topic. C'mon, who doesn't love koala's?

 

[Watchingthetreetops]

Overrated: marshal. He's cute, but I found him kind of meh.

Underrated: Al and bob! Both are so precious!

 

[noirescent]

I think Alice is underrated, she's in my town and I don't know why she's at the bottom of the list. I like her a lot, together with Merry. And they're both Tier 5

 

[Peegeray]

overrated: stitches for sure. he doesn't look cute and his colour scheme is awful.

underrated: i think savannah looks pretty nice, dunno why she's a tier 5. i guess most of my villagers are. i have a very tier 2/3/4 town, marshal aside.

 

[OliviaMagica]

Overrated:- Marshal Tangy and Julian just are too overrated Kinda ticks me a lil
Underrated:- Kiki and Chief These 2 r just so cool i luv em <3 have em in my town
Chief also gimmes loads of stuff and Kiki is a black cat so shes lucky

 

[thatawkwardkid]

Seriously, the most underrated villager is Sheldon. The only time I've ever seen him in game was in my campsite. I have never seen any village with him in it. What's up with that?

I like Sheldon, I'm currently plot-resetting for him, it's been about a week and a half so far.

 

[kbelle4]

I'll give my top 3 in each for you ^.^

Overrated:
1. Ankha - Don't really love her design? Never been into the whole Egyptian theme I guess
2. Marina - Don't like octopi.
3. Julian - I get it, he's a unicorn, but he was my first move in and part of my original 10, he gets old fast.

Underrated:
1. Tammy - my love <3 all uchi villagers should get more love than they do ):<
2. Boomer - just look at him! He's a pilot penguin. SO freakin cute <3
3. Molly - I find her design completely adorable and don't understand why she isn't tier 1 xD

 

[mayordex]

Overrated: I hate to jump on the wagon, but Marshal. He's cute, yes, but that's about it. I think he's so popular because of his grumpy little expression.
Julian, who actually scares me...I don't like unicorns that much. Merengue, she's cute, but again, all she really has.

Under-rated: Katt! She's so awesome! Her house is rocker-themed and she's really neat. Despite her being "ugly", she's very special and one of my favorites.

Cheri, my favorite peppy. I'll always love her. ; u ; Same with Tutu.

 

[ellabella12345]

IMO marshal isn't cute.

 

[-Apples-]

I find Caroline underrated. She is also my favorite villager ever in AC.

I don't know any overrated villagers, but I don't care too much for Ankha.