I'm having a little trouble deciding who I should keep in my town. I need to make space for either Fauna, Deirdre, or Bunnie and I have 2 jocks: Dom and Bam. Dom has been on my island since the start of the game and Bam was found on my second NMT island. I would like to only keep one or the other but I'm not sure who to move out. Dom is a new villager, is super cute and pink, and has been with me since the beginning. Bam, however, has always been one of my favorite jocks. I love deer villagers and he was in all 3 of my New Leaf towns. Both make me feel a little sentimental so I'm unsure of who I should keep. Any advice? ; v ;
Need Advice - Dom or Bam?
- Thread starter dragonair
- Start date
I may be a little (a lot) biased, but Bam is one of my favorites so I'd keep him. I guess it depends on whether or not you want to mix things up a little though, since you had him in New Leaf as well. Personally, I had both Rowan and Bam in all of my New Leaf towns, and I considered skipping one to keep Rudy, who was my starting Jock, but in the end I couldn't do it (plus Rudy had the starter house instead of his regular furniture, which helped my decision).
Jas
Teary-Eyed Grandpa
i had bam in new leaf and i really liked him! i think it's so sweet that you had him in all three of your older towns, so my vote goes to him! also as Piroshi mentioned, dom would still be in the DIY house which i don't like as much lol he is really cute though, you've got two very good contenders!!
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
I fell in love with Dom, his facial expressions are super cute and I'm really glad he is on my island, but truth be told, he does not looks like the jock type.
Funny that you'd post this, because I actually have both Bam and Dom in my town right now!
I originally intended to keep Bam, sell Dom. However there is no possible way I could get rid of Dom - he is my favorite villager in the whole town, unexpectedly. He has the cutest face I've ever seen on a jock villager and he's just so sweet and derpy, despite being a jock.
I like Bam a lot, but he has red eyes and glaring eyebrows which are kind of putting me off. I think you should live with both for a little while and see who you end up bonding with the most!
I originally intended to keep Bam, sell Dom. However there is no possible way I could get rid of Dom - he is my favorite villager in the whole town, unexpectedly. He has the cutest face I've ever seen on a jock villager and he's just so sweet and derpy, despite being a jock.
I like Bam a lot, but he has red eyes and glaring eyebrows which are kind of putting me off. I think you should live with both for a little while and see who you end up bonding with the most!
senbeiiscool
Could you pass the senbei?
My vote is for Bam! My friend has him in their town and he's super cute! If I didn't have a favourite jock already, Bam would be up there. Also because he's been with you since other AC games, I think that's really sweet 
elphieluvr
Wave-Tossed Mermaid ~ she/her
I would love Dom if he weren’t a jock. It bugs me personally when their appearances don’t seem to line up with their personality types. Guess I’m guilty of judging a villager by their cover lol.
my vote is definitely Bam. He’s hilarious and so cool looking. Even if he is always looking up lol.
my vote is definitely Bam. He’s hilarious and so cool looking. Even if he is always looking up lol.
I personally would keep Bam. I love his design and he's one of the only jocks that I personally think is really cute. I had Dom in my town for like a day. He creeped me out and I got rid of him. Lol. I definitely did not like him at all.
monsieurberry
Senior Member
I vote Bam because I have Dom and that’s one less island with Dom lol.
yes lmao
lol, well then it sounds like you already made up your own mind
Here, I'll pull up a coin flip generator. Heads is to keep Dom, Tails is to keep Bam. Call it 
I see the poll is 50/50 and really, I think both characters have merits. Bam is my starting villager and has cute freckles, and Dom's appeal is that his appearance doesn't bely his personality. Can't go wrong either way. I'm nostalgic though, so I'd probably go with an older friend like Bam, but that's all up to personal taste imo
I just found the question "Do you really want three deer?" pretty silly considering I already said I love deer villagers and it would actually be 4 deer considering I want Deirdre as well lol. Still unsure of who I'd want to keep, but 3 deer is not a deterrent for me.lol, well then it sounds like you already made up your own mind
Dom looks like he's about to cry any minute now, especially when he scrunches up his chin while crafting, and it's one of the most hilarious things i've ever seen in my entire life. It also goes to the point of twitter memes but also. Could you say no to this beautiful sheep? yes? i thought so. (no, i'm kidding, give him a chance, he's hilarious.
That's fair, I guess I personally would err on the side of a little more variety. I also just really love Dom, so I'm kind of partial
THE TWITTER MEMES ARE ONE THING THAT MADE ME START RECONSIDERING TT ^ TT
if it is the memes, then i may as well send you this one for you to enjoy.
honestly, give the jock sheep a chance. not only is he fluffy and p/ in-line with a few pastel villagers, he's also a jock and looks like ... well, a fluffy pink sheep with round beedy eyes that are THIS close to spill over with tears, probably.
Tbh I know this doesn't really help but if you love them both that much I'd personally keep them both, I'm looking at your signature and notice you could safely boot out your duplicate lazy and smug villagers for Deirdre and Bunnie so you have all the villager personalities, with duplicates of Normal and Jock.
But if you're really set on having one leave, I say Dom so he can properly get his original house on somebody else's island -- unless the update changed something, your first 5 villagers get their houses reset if they get adopted.
But if you're really set on having one leave, I say Dom so he can properly get his original house on somebody else's island -- unless the update changed something, your first 5 villagers get their houses reset if they get adopted.
Similar threads
