Most overrated villager?

[ShinyYoshi]

Marshal and Zucker.... Not that appealing but very popular.

 

[Heir]

Tangy.

I think she's kind of creepy :l

 

[Treasu(red)]

Bob for sure. I don't get it.

 

[Touko]

Marshal but I still like him :3

 

[Plupap]

Julian honestly looks hideous IMO and I'm not a big fan of Colton but I'd take him over Julian any day. Lolly is soooo boring. I'd take any other cat over her except for maybe Tangy. Also, I have Marshal and he's a bit annoying unlike my previous smug, Keaton. The only reason I adopted Marshal was because of his furniture and that I didn't want an ugly smug to randomly move in like Lionel or Chops.

 

[The Blood Countess]

I've never understood what people find so appealing about Marshal. Definitely the most overrated villager in my opinion.

 

[kaylagirl]

Bob

 

[PlasmaPower]

Julian honestly looks hideous IMO and I'm not a big fan of Colton but I'd take him over Julian any day. Lolly is soooo boring. I'd take any other cat over her except for maybe Tangy. Also, I have Marshal and he's a bit annoying unlike my previous smug, Keaton. The only reason I adopted Marshal was because of his furniture and that I didn't want an ugly smug to randomly move in like Lionel or Chops.

Why'd you bump this?

 

[Awesomeness1230]

Beau. Why why WHY is he tier 1????? Marshal is pretty overrated as well.

 

[Forek]

Idk marshal is like reaaly overrated. I just can't see him in my town. And I don't really like squirrels.


Oh god i just realized this was a necro thread. *facepalm*

 

[creamyy]

Marshal

 

[Rasha]

IMO Merengue, Zucker and Ankha because none of them look all that appealing to be honest

 

[Mick]

IMO Merengue, Zucker and Ankha because none of them look all that appealing to be honest

These I agree with.

 

[Cynicmatic Matt]

Colton. I thought he was ugly and he overstayed his welcome at my village.

 

[Quagsire.]

Colton is scary... But so popular.

 

[Alice]

Beau. Why why WHY is he tier 1????? Marshal is pretty overrated as well.

Beau's adorable, and I dunno about anyone else but I like lazy villagers.

 

[Hoppy~Shnell]

I dunno, Lolly never really appealed to me and I guess I just see everyone wanting her, hmm.

 

[DaCoSim]

Julian and Pietro IMO. I don't like either of those 2.

 

[tumut]

Colton is scary... But so popular.

Colton isn't popular at all. He's tier 4.

Stitches' color scheme of bright orange + bright pink+ green is so ugly. Beau is not that cute compared to other lazies. I'd like him better if he had actual antlers and wasn't a bright cheesy orange. Very plain.Chrissy and Francine are downright hideous and bug eyed. I also really don't like Pekoe. Also Deidre and Wolfgang are ugly.

 

[Quagsire.]

Julian and Pietro IMO. I don't like either of those 2.

It seems that people either love or hate Pietro. I think Julian is pretty creepy