Most loved/Most hated Sonic Game?

[Dae Min]

All Sonic games are flawed. I still respect your opinion and agree with you

Sonic Colors came very close to bringing back a good reputation for the series, but the games after it kinda fumbled. (And after the disastrous Sonic Boom game, I'm kinda wishing Sonicteam would take a break to get their act together)

 

[Tao]

All Sonic games are flawed. I still respect your opinion and agree with you

Sonic Colors came very close to bringing back a good reputation for the series, but the games after it kinda fumbled. (And after the disastrous Sonic Boom game, I'm kinda wishing Sonicteam would take a break to get their act together)

Sonicteam should just be locked in a cupboard altogether.


At this point, I would sooner trust Ubisoft or Activision more to make a half decent Sonic game rather than the people who've worked on them since it went 3D.

 

[Spongebob]

Loved: Sonic Colors
Hated: Boom

 

[Dae Min]

Yeah, you're right. SEGA still struggles to make a decent looking Sonic toy, for crying out loud. lol the Sonic amiibo was better sculpted and more accurate than all of the previous merchandise combined. Someone else could probably do a better job, that's for sure

But I am faithful and stubborn when it comes to things I like. I will stick by Sonicteam until they die of starvation after being locked up in that cupboard

 

[Thievius Raccoonus]

I agree with the overall comment, but personally I think it really went flop after they tried to branch out too far with Riders, Secret Rings, Boom, Unleashed etc. That said, if they'd go back to Sonic Heroes or so. I think they would be pretty good. (particularly if they still have Team Chaotix)

 

[Spongebob]

I'm worried that Sega might die soon.

 

[Thievius Raccoonus]

I dunno about that, there's still SOME hope.

 

[Dae Min]

There is hope! At least Sonicteam is trying new things all the time instead of recycling the same game mechanics over and over.

The werehog was.. interesting, but the risk they made to even put that in is admirable.

Sonic with a sword was also a pretty cool idea in theory.

The 2D 3D mesh sidescrolling during stages in Sonic Colors/Generations is a nice addition, as well as the wisp power ups. At least they're trying to do more than just a 'get to the goal' mission

 

[Thievius Raccoonus]

That is true, they are changing things up, but I think they're trying too much, too hard, and too fast.

 

[Dae Min]

Yeah! They release games too quickly without polish. That's why all of them share wonky cameras, glitches, and a whole bunch of other common problems.

They have so many great ideas, but they need to reel them in and do some editing. Every book on the shelf has been rewritten hundreds of times before it even got published. Sonicteam should revise and edit a bit more too

 

[MrPicklez]

Is this Cory?

 

[PlasmaPower]

Is this Cory?

Cory in the House is best anime.

 

[Stalfos]

Sonic 2 is by far the best one. Sonic 1 and Sonic 3 & Knuckles are really good too. I kinda like the Sonic Advance games as well.

Sonic Adventure sucked sooo badly. It's really awful. Sonic needs to be 2D.

And he needs to ditch all of those bloodsucking "friends" that are using him.

 

[spCrossing]

probably the best thing to come out of this franchise in ages

What about Sonic Generations?

It feels like I'm the only one in this thread that actually played that game.
Seriously, go and buy that game off of Steam or something, you guys will not regret it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Worst? Sonic Adventure 1. I didn't like it that much to begin with but it's also aged horribly, making it worse than it already was. Sonic Adventure 2 wasn't much better but at least it didn't have Big the Cat.

Yeah, can't argue with that there.

But honestly, Adventure 2 aged a lot worse in my opinion.

Yeah, Adventure 1 was buggy and all that, but I at least enjoyed half of the Adventure in Adventure 1 (Sonic, Tails, & Knuckles campaign) compared to Adventure 2 where I only enjoy the Sonic-Shadow stages, the Chao Garden, and nothing else.

 

[Prof Gallows]

every Sonic game after Adventure 2 is bad

This completely. And agreeing with the fact that even Adventure and Adventure 2 weren't great by any means.

 

[undernickle]

Best: Sonic R

Worst: Sonic Adventure




bring it on, fanboys.

 

[spCrossing]

Best: Sonic R

Worst: Sonic Adventure




bring it on, fanboys.

Yes.

Sonic R is clearly the best Sonic game of all time.

 

[Hyoshido]

bring it on, fanboys.

People who don't appreciate going fast in the sunshine are losers.

I'm really feeling the Sunshine!

 

[spCrossing]

People who don't appreciate going fast in the sunshine are losers.

I'm really feeling the Sunshine!

Does it brighten up your day?

 

[Hyoshido]

Does it brighten up your day?

It makes me want to run, reach for the sunshine and forget about the rain!