But Pumpkin was first? I would feel bad taking him from them, when he is obviously their dreamie too.
Twi gets to choose who gets Stitches, I'm sure it's because of how long you've been a member on TBT.
It's fine it's her rules that she can pick who she wants, but you should really take first come first serve out of the rules because it really isn't then, lol.
That is in the rules, but it also states "First-come, first serve. However, the cycler has the final word of who gets the villager. If the cycler finds first person is questionable for some reason, the villager will go to the next in line."
On a side note, I honestly haven't felt like cycling lately for a multitude of reasons, which is why I'm borderline inactive. -____- Luckily, no one really seems interested in who I have up for grabs. XD