Keep Phoebe or get Mira, Muffy, Katt, Eugene or Julian?

[dreamysnowx]

So here's the deal, I'm thinking of spicing up my town with a new villager, and I had Phoebe for 4 months now and I think it's time for her to set sail to a wonderful new home! I do like her but she was never a actual dreamy to begin with since she was one of the first random move-ins on the first week I started my town. ;-;

My choices for her replacement is

~ another uchi, to fill in her spot! Mira, met her in a friend's town and she was wonderful and sweet! but I already have 2 rabbits in my town, would another rabbit moving in be too much?

~another uchi to fill in her spot, Muffy! She's pretty adorable and wouldn't mind having her!

~Katt, another uchi, my friend has her and she's pretty darn cool. c:

~Eugene, coolest koala out there! I wouldn't mind having someone as cool as him in my town <3 And he looks like he fits the smug personality!

~Julian, not going to lie he looked better in screenshots/photos, met him in a friend's town and now he's eh to me, I do like his unique design but at the same time he is sort of normal but magical at the same time?, but I do like the smug personality, and I like how he's sassy. c: but my town would be pretty unbalanced, I guess I won't mind as much after I get all the good pwps out of Phoebe!

.. or should I just keep Phoebe? c:

I currently have 2 normals, 2 snooties, 1 smug, 1 uchi (Phoebe), 1 lazy, 1 cranky, 1 peppy, 1 jock.
I know I should 'follow' my heart, but I'm so indecisive and would love to hear who you guys would pick & why. I'm easily convinced ^~^ thanks for reading!

 

[Cloud Arcanine]

In this situation I'd either get Muffy or keep Phoebe Both are amazing villagers!

 

[Yugi Moto]

Well to answer the easiest question first, you definitely shouldn't keep phoebe if she isn't a dreamie but it doesn't sound like any of these villagers are either. Am I assuming that right? Are you just trying out different villagers and seeing if you fall in love with one?

Anyways to start off I would personally go with either mira or eugene. It's different for each person when it comes to variation of species. Some ppl want every villager to be a different animal and some have towns dedicated to one animal. Honestly to me i'd say who really cares about the species. If you have 5 rabbits in your town because you like them more out of all the other non rabbit villagers then go for it, It's whatever you want really. I would say variety of personality is much more important than species tho.

Mira seems cute and she's a "superhero" and there aren't many of those in this game so that's pretty unique. Definitely at least worth trying out and seeing if you like her. Eugene is definitely my second pick after marshal he seems pretty cool with those glasses and just has alot of style and flare which is sadly lacking in alot of other villagers imo.

I can't stand katt or julian tho but I'm probably biased against them and therefore not the right person to give you advice on those two villagers. Katt scares the pants off of me with that face and I don't get the hype with Julian at all tbh. Just a horse with a horn on it's head. But it sounds like from what your saying you don't even really like him that much so I would say to not take him if I were you. Hope I helped!

 

[Yui Z]

Mira!!!!!! <3


You need a super hero in your town just in case!

 

[Libra]

Mira seems nice, but I've never seen her. I've had Eugene, though, so that's why I voted for him. ^_^

 

[dreamysnowx]

Well to answer the easiest question first, you definitely shouldn't keep phoebe if she isn't a dreamie but it doesn't sound like any of these villagers are either. Am I assuming that right? Are you just trying out different villagers and seeing if you fall in love with one?

Anyways to start off I would personally go with either mira or eugene. It's different for each person when it comes to variation of species. Some ppl want every villager to be a different animal and some have towns dedicated to one animal. Honestly to me i'd say who really cares about the species. If you have 5 rabbits in your town because you like them more out of all the other non rabbit villagers then go for it, It's whatever you want really. I would say variety of personality is much more important than species tho.

Mira seems cute and she's a "superhero" and there aren't many of those in this game so that's pretty unique. Definitely at least worth trying out and seeing if you like her. Eugene is definitely my second pick after marshal he seems pretty cool with those glasses and just has alot of style and flare which is sadly lacking in alot of other villagers imo.

I can't stand katt or julian tho but I'm probably biased against them and therefore not the right person to give you advice on those two villagers. Katt scares the pants off of me with that face and I don't get the hype with Julian at all tbh. Just a horse with a horn on it's head. But it sounds like from what your saying you don't even really like him that much so I would say to not take him if I were you. Hope I helped!

this really helped! You convinced me, I am leaning alot towards Mira now <3

- - - Post Merge - - -

Mira!!!!!! <3


You need a super hero in your town just in case!

LOL this is true c': my town needs someone to save them!

 

[hemming1996]

muffy, of course ^^

 

[LambdaDelta]

Mira's clearly the best choice

Eugene second

then Muffy

then none

 

[Gizmodo]

Get Muffy shes gorgeous
or Mira i love her too

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Muffy.

 

[dreamysnowx]

Going to go look at muffy in a dream town

 

[cheezu]

I had Muffy in the past and didn't like her because I thought her eyes were super creepy. I also had Mira and didn't like that "side smirk" of hers. My favourite uchi by far is Katt but I'm aware of the fact that not everyone finds her appealing.
I prefer Colton over Julian.
I actually think that Phoebe is cool. Do you have dreamies by the way or do you just want to experience new characters in the game?

 

[dreamysnowx]

I had Muffy in the past and didn't like her because I thought her eyes were super creepy. I also had Mira and didn't like that "side smirk" of hers. My favourite uchi by far is Katt but I'm aware of the fact that not everyone finds her appealing.
I prefer Colton over Julian.
I actually think that Phoebe is cool. Do you have dreamies by the way or do you just want to experience new characters in the game?

Well Julian is half a dreamy (if that makes senses? ><), I adore the fact that he is blue (my favorite colour) and that he has a sassy vibe. **that sass** but at the same time, I already have a smug (Marshal) so not sure what to feel about having another villager repeat the same dialogue as Marshal ;-; And his design is unique but at the same time bland, hard to explain ;-;

and the rest, I'm just looking to try new villagers! <3

 

[Gizmodo]

You have Merengue & Zucker, gimme
Also definitely get an uchi so you'll stilll have one

 

[dreamysnowx]

You have Merengue & Zucker, gimme
Also definitely get an uchi so you'll stilll have one

haha! XDDD <3

I'm leaning towards Mira/Muffy/Julian right now :3

 

[cIementine]

I'm either thinking you should keep her, or trade her for another uchi (FUCHSIA YAY)

 

[dreamysnowx]

I'm either thinking you should keep her, or trade her for another uchi (FUCHSIA YAY)

Fuchsia scares me a bit Dx

 

[cIementine]

She is amazing o:

 

[dreamysnowx]

She is amazing o:

I haven't officially seen her in-game, so I'll check her out in a dream town x

I've only seen her in pictures and she scared me XD I'll see what I feel when I see her in-game :3

 

[cheezu]

To me, it really depends on whether you have unlocked all the uchi PWP's that you might be interested in. If that's the case, I don't think missing one personality type is all that bad esp. if no one from that personality type is your dreamie.
But for me, getting a second town to experience more villagers definitely helped. At first I wasn't too fond of snooties, but once I got to meet villagers like Bree, Monique or Olivia I quickly changed my mind and fell in love with them and they escalated to "dreamie" status fairly soon.
I know I'm just giving you conflicting information... lol
But I think that it might be worth trying out another uchi just to make sure. If you don't like her, you'll be able to exchange her for Julian in the future (or some other smug).