Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

Dinosaurz (Pietro) town
Hikari (Poncho) town
Epona (Whitney) town
glow (Daisy) town
shawo (Raymond) town
 
alright congrats guys we're done. hopefully thi

im gonna tally up the results
Post automatically merged:

alright congrats guys we're done. hopefully this made you think more of players you've been conflicted on

obvs i didn't include geoni so yea

im gonna tally up the results
Post automatically merged:

haha draft go brrr
 
Early **** me too bro
Post automatically merged:

I forgot a who a few of you are lmao
 
i deadass didn't have any strong mafia read so srry to the people i called mafia 😔 didnt want to say all town lmao
 
...
epona said:
alek is a pretty strong townlean for me atm bc their frustration reads genuine, it's a tonal and meta read mostly but they seem to be actively trying to move the game along and the response to daniel shutting down their RQS looks townie to me

daniel is where the 'most likely' thing comes in. i've seen him ask questions to absolutely everybody's posts as both alignments so that's not necessarily AI but i don't really see why he'd place two random votes that early on d1 as mafia, and i also don't really think he'd write off alek's reaction as townie so quickly if it's wolf/town so he's a tentative townlean atm
Click to expand...

@Alek i'm pretty sure this is the post you were looking for? in which case idk what you're referring to bc i said he questions everything as both alignments lol
 
anyone have any difficulty figuring out players? I had trouble with glow and epona the most with dedenne and cake just shots in the dark
 
shawo said:
ok actually I can't finish this thread till after I eat.

Anyways, if I had some thoughts it would probably be...

I still think a lot of people are quick to out townreads, regardless of "why." Not because I think outting a fast townread is bad, but because I genuinely just do not see it.

Someone saying "daniel and antonio is town" is only towny if it's something I can see and understand - even if they can justify it with a post that seems logical. In fact, I'm actually more inclined towards the few reads that were the equivalent of "x was towny because they seemed town." because anything more than that seems a bit protective.

However, on that note, Epona actually explained their own reads like, 2 pages after I left off. So I'm gonna come back after I eat/have a clear head so I can give some better reads.
Click to expand...
Post automatically merged:

Damniel said:
anyone have any difficulty figuring out players? I had trouble with glow and epona the most with dedenne and cake just shots in the dark
Click to expand...
guava epona and cake
glow is mafia for me even if shes town
Post automatically merged:

had trouble with dan too, because it's gut mafia but his posts feels town
 
Alek said:
The Results
Please READ EVERYTHING

The reason behind me asking you such a question is because I wanted to see your perception on the matter due to one statement sticking out to me from individual #1. I also was willing to see how willing you guys were to answer it and how you answered it for reactions purposes, so I’m give you guys my reactions first before elaborating on individual #1.

What I was looking for in my reactions: If people were willing to answer a simple question regarding a mafia perspective on how to be incognito. I assume mafia would be less willing to share their perspective on the matter or downplay me like I don’t have a clue what I’m doing.

The Question: Would mafia have to consider a town perspective or how a townie would need to play in order to hide within the game?

The answers/reactions:
Epona is the first one to answer, which I liked.


However, the answer stood out to me. Why mention Glow? You also mentioned that you being Analytical is not AI but people consider it a towntell, got any examples?

Overall, I liked your answer. You also said it depends on the player, I want to make sure that is remembered.


Dedenne and Epona response to me pressuring a response also is suspicious. Like, if we are all Town then why would you be against somebody asking a question? Wouldn't you be more against someone not answering such a simple question?
Click to expand...
to be honest i got nothing from this question or the answers to it but i'll respond to the bit about me lol

a) i mentioned glow bc she was the only person i could specifically think of who fit into the question you were answering i.e. do people try to conform to their own town meta when playing as mafia
b) i didn't say people consider me being analytical a towntell, i said people consider me being inconsistent/all over the place a towntell bc they assume i'm analytical as mafia but that's wrong bc i'm indecisive and inconsistent as both alignments lol

anyway the reason i tried to get you to stop pushing it is literally bc you were clogging the thread and daniel had said multiple times that he wasn't going to answer. it doesn't go any deeper than that i just wanted to move on
Post automatically merged:

that quote kinda messed up but i think u can still understand the format
Post automatically merged:

Alek said:
Was this before or after i started the questions?
Click to expand...

before
just click the green arrow beside the post and you'll see the original idk why i'm doing all your investigative work for you here lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

voltairenism
Mafia Zelda Mountainous Mafia
Replies
4
Views
875
Wiisp
Wiisp
Fridaynightcatlady
My pitch for Animal Crossing for the Switch 2 - Animal Crossing: Let's Go Exploring!
Replies
0
Views
278
Fridaynightcatlady
Fridaynightcatlady
Awesome Gamer 2009
Funny game challenges you made up?
Replies
0
Views
91
Awesome Gamer 2009
Awesome Gamer 2009
iocatio
Hello!
Replies
2
Views
274
Mimi Cheems
Mimi Cheems
M
Giveaway ✨How It's Done The Island Watch Party✨
Replies
1
Views
1K
Phoenix45
P
Back
Top