FinalArcadia
☆ princess of jurai ☆
Glow and Hikari were the toughest ones to decide on, with Dedenne almost as tough too
Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins
- Thread starter DinoTown
- Start date
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Your responses are understandable, both a and b. Those 2 questions wasn't supposed to return AI, but I wanted to understand your motive.
For the last part, I see where you are coming from but doesn't Damniel not answering your question seem suspicious to you? Why were you ok with a "no" response".
Post automatically merged:
Shawo and Volt were the hardest.
Post automatically merged:
Not your question, the question.
i mean kind of weird that he was flat out refusing to answer it when asked directly but i still don't think it's AI bc i personally couldn't see the value of the question
like it's definitely not as easy as 'he didn't answer this question that i asked everyone therefore he must be a wolf'
Post automatically merged:
that said my townlean on daniel is wavering a lot lol
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
here's the results. the participants on the left and all the players on the right. volt wolf reads the most people at 5, and ace wolf reads the least at 2
GTH was a fun exercise done in my MU semis, and I found it difficult to answer when I was a wolf that game, so i was curious to see how it would go here
Post automatically merged:
also if i got something wrong please tell me ill fix it
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Oh, I agree that it's not as simple as that but what irrates me is a lack of reasonable reason behind his actions. Like he didn't mention not seeing the value of the question as a reason for not responding. His reason was because he can.
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
I'm more town than mafia, that is a first.
Honestly I just winged it off gut feelings
Post automatically merged:
Isn’t it 6 people or can I not read
i read cake as mafia simply due to them not posting too much, figured they might be trying to stay under the radar? like i said tho i have very weak reads on everyone atm
also @Dinosaurz , game's over spill the tea on tea plz
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
@FinalArcadia @voltairenism why do you guys sus read guava?
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
anyway if anyone wants to elaborate any of their reads, feel free too.
tbh there was no strong reason to TR cake and dedenne. glow and epona i find tricky to read but i think they seem interested in solving which im okay with them for now. tonally shawo and guava sound town. not the strongest reads but that's what i heart is telling me rn
tbh there was no strong reason to TR cake and dedenne. glow and epona i find tricky to read but i think they seem interested in solving which im okay with them for now. tonally shawo and guava sound town. not the strongest reads but that's what i heart is telling me rn
Oh yeah.i read cake as mafia simply due to them not posting too much, figured they might be trying to stay under the radar? like i said tho i have very weak reads on everyone atm
also @Dinosaurz , game's over spill the tea on tea plz
well last game I played it was a different set up iirc 3 “cell” blocks that had a cycle one at a time. each cell had 1 Mafia. In my cell there was a member tea who I instantly was sus off and basically she ended up being mafia and I made them eliminate her like day 5 and we won. You just reminded me of her play style.
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
oh youre right that's 6 people yikes
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
i dont know dedenne as mafia but so far her behaviour is the same as past games where she was town
no clue as I said I default assume everyone is mafia, so I should say why I think people are town and I'm going to do that in a bit
daniel's giving me big town leader vibes, idk why but it's not sitting right with me
i just feel like he's dominated a lot of the discussion and it feels like he's steering things which isn't necessarily a wolftell but i caught up with the thread just after the GTH game and it just felt very LAMIST and performative to me when i was reading it
but then he posted the little table with the tallies and explained how he found it difficult to answer as a wolf in his last game so that alleviated that a bit
fwiw i think the only way daniel is mafia here (which i'm not ruling out) is if he's the godfather bc i don't see him sticking his neck out like he has otherwise
i just feel like he's dominated a lot of the discussion and it feels like he's steering things which isn't necessarily a wolftell but i caught up with the thread just after the GTH game and it just felt very LAMIST and performative to me when i was reading it
but then he posted the little table with the tallies and explained how he found it difficult to answer as a wolf in his last game so that alleviated that a bit
fwiw i think the only way daniel is mafia here (which i'm not ruling out) is if he's the godfather bc i don't see him sticking his neck out like he has otherwise
tbh, I was so close to outting a snap townread on daniel, for the game, but while I was eating I made the conclusion that.
1. it was a game he took off of MU.
2. he doesn't really understand what the game was for.
Maybe this is me misunderstanding it, but the first reaction to getting like 2 pages full of content shouldn't be "I'm going to go tally up the results." But rather.
How do these peoples reads matter in the scope of their game vs how they reacted to it.
For example - hikari claimed to force themselves to out mafia reads, because they felt that they couldn't out multiple people as town.
How many people here felt obligated to out town/mafia reads due to how few/many they had before? And how many of the reads people outted contest their own.
For example: something that's interesting about the specific statistics is that volt outted 6! seperate scumreads. THIS is more meaningful than how many people didn't scumread me for example.
Also I don't think that outting 6 scumreads probably means they were genuinely outting their first impression of said player (which can happen as town or mafia!)
1. it was a game he took off of MU.
2. he doesn't really understand what the game was for.
Maybe this is me misunderstanding it, but the first reaction to getting like 2 pages full of content shouldn't be "I'm going to go tally up the results." But rather.
How do these peoples reads matter in the scope of their game vs how they reacted to it.
For example - hikari claimed to force themselves to out mafia reads, because they felt that they couldn't out multiple people as town.
How many people here felt obligated to out town/mafia reads due to how few/many they had before? And how many of the reads people outted contest their own.
For example: something that's interesting about the specific statistics is that volt outted 6! seperate scumreads. THIS is more meaningful than how many people didn't scumread me for example.
Also I don't think that outting 6 scumreads probably means they were genuinely outting their first impression of said player (which can happen as town or mafia!)
ah okay, thanks for the background.
I think to put it into perspective. Daniel said "This was really hard for me to answer as wolf." Because it's hard to fake reads if you haven't been actively reading the game, so you end up throwing out reads and trying to force an even amount of mafia/town reads.
If I were to look for mafia in this pile, I'd probably start away from both hikari (who admitted to fudging the results a bit) and volt (who probably did read the game.) Especially since this is likely the first time this game has ever showed up in the forums, I think it's fair to say that most people's reaction to this will be really raw.
If I were to look for mafia in this pile, I'd probably start away from both hikari (who admitted to fudging the results a bit) and volt (who probably did read the game.) Especially since this is likely the first time this game has ever showed up in the forums, I think it's fair to say that most people's reaction to this will be really raw.
Similar threads
