Is peanut too pink for my town?

[LinkToTheWorld]

She was always my number one choice of peppy but I had to disregard her purely because she's so pink
I do have Bob already but he's a purple colour and for some reason just fits in with everybody else. I'm not so sure a pink villager would fit in so well
So do I stick with Rosie? Not a bad choice at all. I do love her, but I love the peppy personality anyway. Or should I get peanut and ignore the fact that she will stand out from every other villager in my town?
Or will she not? My villagers are all in my sig....
I would really appreciate any opinions. Also opinions on whether you prefer Rosie or peanut in general or who is your favourite peppy.
Thank you

 

[visibleghost]

idk what your towb theme is but i dont think peanut will be too different!! i have hwr in my town (along w filbert hehe) and she's adorable, so i say go for it!!

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

idk what your towb theme is but i dont think peanut will be too different!! i have hwr in my town (along w filbert hehe) and she's adorable, so i say go for it!!

It kind of makes it an easier choice as I don't really follow a theme - I have a half very flowery pretty side and the other side is more dark paths and PWPs. But that is the side peanut would have to move to....I couldn't fit her on the more 'girly' side.
That part kind of puts me off again....
She is super adorable, omg when I had her in my cycle town I just adored her. And she would make a nice little friend for marshal....

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

Still in need of help if anybody has any other suggestions/opinions! Would be much appreciated

 

[Ashav]

I don't think that she would look too different for your town.
Maybe she wouldn't be on the side of your town that you want, but you seem to really, really like Peanut. It is obvious that you would appreciate to have her, and then I think you should.
If it could make you happy, just do it. ^^

(as for the favorite peppy question, I don't really have one, I guess I prefer Rosie between those two but honestly I never truly appreciated one of them yet - but that's just me!)

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I don't think that she would look too different for your town.
Maybe she wouldn't be on the side of your town that you want, but you seem to really, really like Peanut. It is obvious that you would appreciate to have her, and then I think you should.
If it could make you happy, just do it. ^^

(as for the favorite peppy question, I don't really have one, I guess I prefer Rosie between those two but honestly I never truly appreciated one of them yet - but that's just me!)

Thank you for your response!
She would be moving next to Rudy and he's a little colourful? So perhaps they would go together nicely as neighbours...
Plus I could always get a lot of pink flowers and put them around the area by her house, I like to colour coordinate villagers with flowers anyway so that wouldn't be much of a problem for me
I would love her to be honest, just think she has the sweetest little face. I love the cats too but I do have 3 other permanent ones.
Will keep thinking on it today....if I decide Rosie is to move I'll start on that as soon as so I can keep my town in order.

Does anybody have peanut in their dream town so I could come and visit her again?
Like I say, I loved her in my cycle town. Would just like to see her in an actual town again if possible

 

[Pandoria]

I personally don't think having Peanut will affect your town that much! ;u; Peanut is super cute and I think if you love her more than Rosie, then there is nothing wrong with having her in your town! I'm sure you'll be able to make it work, and then feel better for the fact you have your favourite Peppy Villager c:

I actually have Nibbles, another Peppy Squirrel, in my town at the moment- and I'm growing to really like her ;u;
She's super cute and her and Hamphrey have this little friendship going on that is adorable!

As for favourite peppy's myself, I'm torn between Rosie and Sprinkle ;u; Both are super cute! c:

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I personally don't think having Peanut will affect your town that much! ;u; Peanut is super cute and I think if you love her more than Rosie, then there is nothing wrong with having her in your town! I'm sure you'll be able to make it work, and then feel better for the fact you have your favourite Peppy Villager c:

I actually have Nibbles, another Peppy Squirrel, in my town at the moment- and I'm growing to really like her ;u;
She's super cute and her and Hamphrey have this little friendship going on that is adorable!

As for favourite peppy's myself, I'm torn between Rosie and Sprinkle ;u; Both are super cute! c:

Sprinkle is adorable! You know who I think is underrated though? Dotty she's a lovely little rabbit with creepy red eyes, what's not to like there?
I do love my Rosie, it's just that she wasn't my very first choice of peppy, she just matched better than the others plus she's a cat (I love cats in this game).

Cheri is also a lovely peppy, never understand why she wasn't more popular. Maybe I'm missing something....she's only a tier 4
I'm thinking you're right and I would actually feel a lot better knowing I got my first choice of every personality, otherwise I'm going to be thinking about this daily every time I go on and see Rosie.
Why can't we have an extra 1 or 2 villager places 10 is not enough....

- - - Post Merge - - -

There was somebody who had a squirrel town, I looked at their DA when I was wanting opinions on Marshal. It was a massive help
Can't remember who it was who posted though

 

[Pandoria]

Sprinkle is adorable! You know who I think is underrated though? Dotty she's a lovely little rabbit with creepy red eyes, what's not to like there?
I do love my Rosie, it's just that she wasn't my very first choice of peppy, she just matched better than the others plus she's a cat (I love cats in this game).

Cheri is also a lovely peppy, never understand why she wasn't more popular. Maybe I'm missing something....she's only a tier 4
I'm thinking you're right and I would actually feel a lot better knowing I got my first choice of every personality, otherwise I'm going to be thinking about this daily every time I go on and see Rosie.
Why can't we have an extra 1 or 2 villager places 10 is not enough....

Sprinkle is just a bundle of cuteness, she's probably my favourite of the penguins other than Hopper (because of the Animal Crossing film, Margie, Hopper, Rosie, and Whitney have always been nostalgic favourites) Dotty is a cutie! I adore rabbit villagers probably as much as I do Hamsters.

I completely understand, but I mean at least you have had Rosie in your town, and will have memories of her? ;u; Cats are wonderful! The majority of them are super cute!

Yeah Cheri is really cute too, maybe she'll get more popular as time goes on or something!
I'm glad my advice was okay ;u; and I'm sure if you have Peanut you'll enjoy having her around in your town.
Honestly whatever makes you happy at the end of the day, I'm sure your town will be just fine with Peanut in ;u;

I totally agree with that- I've just started a new game and I want so many different villagers that I'm contemplating buying another game to have a more villager themed town, to be able to have even more that I love ;u;

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

Absoloutely, I really appreciate you taking time to reply
It's always helpful for me to get other people's opinions on these things. To be honest I never would have got marshal if it wasn't for asking about him and getting to see some towns with him in. I never thought he's that special and needed a good smug, I just fell in love with him it took an awfully long time to decide on these villagers, which is why I'm a bit more hesitant. There were a lot of villagers I thought I'll love and then I got them and they weren't for me (Skye being one of them).

I don't tend to see many people with peanut as their dreamie, so I also wondered if there was a reason for that or if it's just a case of there's so many lovely peppy villagers they prefer. I know they all tend to say similar things, so I was wondering if it's maybe her colour that puts other people off too. I also love Felicity but I'd only get her if I made a second town I think, she's not quite up there with Rosie and peanut for me to consider her right now.

I have a second cartridge that I'm using for cycling at the minute, but at some point I would like to have it as my second main town. I'm just very indecisive about layouts and things so it would be a major job, not quite ready for it yet but hopefully once this town is completely done I'll get motivation for it

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

Thank you to the people who offered their advice decision has been made, Rosie is going to be cycled out!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Or maybe I'll keep her and cycle out a normal since I have 3 to put peanut in a better space....
Well, I'm very near to a decision anyway
Thanks everyone

 

[Licorice]

You guys stress way too much about town themes lol If you like Peanut then get her.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

It's not so much because of a theme, since I don't have a theme in my town. It was more whether she would stand out too much against my other villagers and what not...
But I think I have decided now anyway and I can finally get Zell back too according to my villager list

 

[Corrie]

I think you should get Peanut if you really like her.

 

[kcarly11]

i don't have a dream code, but if you want you can add my FC and you can come see her if you'd like she's great lol she was a random move in and she grew on me

 

[leftTBT]

Get her if you really like her. I have Willow who is almost a neon yellow sheep, and while she doesn't fit in the best with my mostly natural colored and monochrome villagers, I still like her quite a lot in my town.