Is it possible to get 4 fake artworks at Redd's?

[Sloom Lagoon]

Redd it in my town today and there are 3 statues and 1 painting. I've looked on a website to see which was genuine but apparently all of them are fake?
Is that even possible? I've never had it before so I'm really confused...

 

[cielyca]

That would not make sense logically because why would he even appear if all his artworks are fake. I therefore conclude that it is not possible. Maybe try double checking?

 

[Mairen]

Yeah, there's always going to be at least 1 real piece of art. good luck!

 

[cielyca]

Another suggestion would be to invite a friend to your town and help you re-assess the paintings..

 

[Hypno KK]

No, I don't believe that's possible, because there wouldn't be much point otherwise. Try to check again, maybe you got confused or missed a detail.

If not, you can post a picture here and we can try to help you check.

 

[Sloom Lagoon]

http://www.thonky.com/animal-crossing-new-leaf/paintings-works-of-art/

Using this website all the ones I got are apparently fake!
'The Great Wave' has a huge mountain underneath
'David' has a cloth over his shoulder
The guy with the Frisbee has a bumpy one
and King Kamehameha has his fingers straight out... :c

 

[cielyca]

David would only be fake if he has a cloth over his right shoulder. But the real one will still have a cloth on his left. Ive seen it before. Its like the cloth on his left shoulder encircles his neck and drapes over his right too.

 

[Mairen]

http://www.thonky.com/animal-crossing-new-leaf/paintings-works-of-art/

Using this website all the ones I got are apparently fake!
'The Great Wave' has a huge mountain underneath
'David' has a cloth over his shoulder
The guy with the Frisbee has a bumpy one
and King Kamehameha has his fingers straight out... :c

that's the site I use to check the art too! This seems like a tricky situation. Perhaps something really rare and unusual did happen here

 

[Sloom Lagoon]

David would only be fake if he has a cloth over his right shoulder. But the real one will still have a cloth on his left. Ive seen it before. Its like the cloth on his left shoulder encircles his neck and drapes over his right too.

Yeah, it's over the right shoulder :/ So annoying!

 

[Reindeer]

The chance is small but I've had it happen to me before. He also has come in a few times with more than one real piece of art. It's all the luck of the draw basically.

 

[Ettienne]

Try this guide? http://animalcrossingnl.mooo.com/real-and-fake-art

I very much doubt they're all fake. This guide is much better as it includes in-game pictures of both real and fake.

 

[Sloom Lagoon]

Try this guide? http://animalcrossingnl.mooo.com/real-and-fake-art

I very much doubt they're all fake. This guide is much better as it includes in-game pictures of both real and fake.

Ahh thanks so much! Turns out the gold/ black guy was real! Woop! I was getting worried there!

 

[cielyca]

Try this guide? http://animalcrossingnl.mooo.com/real-and-fake-art

I very much doubt they're all fake. This guide is much better as it includes in-game pictures of both real and fake.

Thanks for the link. This is clearer than the thonky guide

 

[EmGee]

I found this page pretty helpful, too

http://animalcrossing.wikia.com/wiki/Forgery

 

[Sloom Lagoon]

These are all awesome, thanks so much guys!

 

[Ettienne]

Ahh thanks so much! Turns out the gold/ black guy was real! Woop! I was getting worried there!

Very welcome. c:

- - - Post Merge - - -

Thanks for the link. This is clearer than the thonky guide

Glad I could help~