is it only me or

[nintendoanna]

I usually immediately sell items villagers give to me or decline to buy it but I make exceptions for Beardo lol I keep the stuff he gives me I just can't sell the things he gives me (unless it's a super ugly clothing item lol) do u guys have that one villager u can't say no to or am I just weird

 

[ChillyKio]

I only keep items from villagers if I've never heard of the item name. Otherwise, I can't even bother going to Retail sometimes, that I just use the trash can PWP instead.

 

[ZebraQueen]

I keep savannah items
She has a museum room because of so many stuff

 

[Idfldnsndt]

I usually keep the stuff that Fang gives me because we're pals

 

[HHoney]

I keep some of the items if I have an empty room. Then it's kind of like a curio shoppe

Lately my villagers keep giving me fruit. I usually would sell it but lately I plant them. I like the idea of building the landscape with the help of my villagers.

 

[namiieco]

I never keep the stuff, it takes up too much space and I don't need it.

 

[Kurashiki]

nah, i usually sell it

 

[Licorice]

I used to save Rocco's gifts in City Folk. My basement was filled with random crap from him. I don't do that anymore because it isn't worth wasting space over.

 

[drowningfairies]

I usually sell it unless it was something I really wanted/needed. Otherwise, no.

 

[stitchmaker]

If it's a garden gnome I'll keep it. I've been placing them in different spots in all my players houses.
When the villager giveaway shirts all day I'll wear them for fun.
I've kept a few special shirts and furniture from the villagers. Lolly gave me the candy gingham shirt as a gift early in the game.
The Alpine Set is now redone with that shirt. It's a nice way to remember that moment.

 

[PrincessAurora]

I hate when they give me random stuff! I do like when it's a painting I don't have though. But not if it's fake. (I'm looking at you Elvis :c)

 

[Togekid]

i'm sorry but bob's super toilet was the best thing that ever happened to me
and his ugly plaid tee
and his kiddie clock
and his train set

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

I'm a bad mayor. I sell all of my villagers' "presents" XD

 

[maplecheek]

I keep all the letters from Beardo.

Never thought about keeping the items but that sounds fun.

Maybe I will also get a museum room for him!

I <3 Beardo.

 

[Invisible again]

I usually sell all their "gifts", unless it's something I need for my house. I just can't be bothered to keep a bunch of useless junk that has no purpose for my house or wardrobe. lol

 

[Barnabus_i_am]

Usually I'll sell the item, but sometimes I can't resist buying items from my villagers, even if I know I'll sell it for less Bells later. My normal villagers will always bring their furniture to me, asking that I buy it so that they can get a new book, and I just need to buy it and help them out! Many times I can't resist Tia.
I also keep some items that villagers give me if the item or villager has a special meaning. Beardo is amazing, and when he lived in my town he gave me an azalea bonsai, and I still have it even though he left long ago. After Margie moved, she asked me to dig up her time capsule and keep whatever was in it, I due it up and found a deep blue tee. It is such an ordinary item, but I kept it anyway.

 

[watercolorwish]

i keep motts gifts and have a special room for them in my house hes my husband

 

[Sheando]

This is really interesting! I have never done this. I always sell it unless it happens to be something I want. I can never say no to my villagers, so I always let them buy stuff off me, change their catchphrases, catch fish for them, etc., but it never occurred to me to care about selling their presents. Haha.

 

[jessicat_197]

I always say yes to my villagers so i always end up selling the items bc they take up space. But if i need it i'll keep it.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I mostly sell it, usually without even checking what they've given me if I've been button spamming. Luckily I didn't last week as somebody (no idea ever who it was) gave me a throne which was ideal as I was thinking of ordering one and customising it. Saved the bells and yesterday I didn't check again and almost sold a picture of Stitches and Marshal. Marshal must have given me his during a request and Stitches' must have been in the post.
I have most furniture items catalogued now and all my storage is filled with stuff so I wouldn't really have space to keep things from villagers