If you had to choose, would you pick Beau or Sherb?

[Xara]

hhhng i love them both but beau. he’s been special to me ever since before new leaf came out and i love him tremendously ;u;

 

[a sprout]

i've got both, and i love them. but beau is still my buddy from new leaf, so... beau!

 

[Chris]

I have Sherb on my island and I had Beau in my New Leaf town. I think I'd give Sherb the boot if I came across Beau.

 

[Lavamaize]

Sherb all the way! I love his colors and his house!

 

[Zura]

Sherb is a big meeeh tbh

 

[bluetortis26]

beau 100%

 

[elo-chan]

Probably Beau. I've never liked goat villagers that much.

 

[swifterly]

Sherb all the way. I never understood why Beau was so popular! Don't kill me but I just don't like his design... Maybe people find his sleepy eyes cute but honestly they just look weird to me... he looks like a stoner and tbh the eyelids are just flesh colored enough to freak me out a little bit... :/

I got Sherb in my campsite a bit back and was gonna take him, to giveaway if nothing else (I already had 2 lazies), but he was being rly stubborn about moving in and I was in the middle of doing campsite trick so I let him go

 

[kyrynbunni]

I would pick Sherb only because I really prefer the goat designs over the deer ones. There's just something cute about them.

 

[skylucario]

bruh you shoulda quit without saving after you told raymond to leave.

 

[kindakooky]

I had Beau in my New Leaf town and I love him to bits, he's probably one of my favourite characters, but given the chance I'd have Sherb come live on my island in a heartbeat. He both looks and sounds adorable and even his house exterior is cute and it matches him!

 

[Iris_T]

Sherb is so cute and blue, definitely my favorite of the two! ❤

 

[Faux]

Beau, I don't like goats in this game, which is unfortunate because I really love them a lot irl.
Their face shape bugs me.

 

[Grimlock]

bruh you shoulda quit without saving after you told raymond to leave.

Yeah I panicked when I did it and tried to talk to him again and went to see Isabelle to get him to stay. I didn’t know how it worked at the time. I feel better about it now though after I learned of the campsite trick. I’ll probably do that sometime later after my smug wants to leave.

 

[Rosewater]

I like Sherb better because there's something I don't like about Beau's eyes. Shame because the rest of him is cute

 

[Maruchan]

Like them both, but definitely would pick Beau if I *absolutely have* to choose one.
Just started with my island, have yet to encounter my own irl Sherb (only seen vids of him).
To me, Sherb is a lot like Kidd, just...in a different color lol.
Am looking forward to have both Beau and Sherb in my town. I like Normal and Lazy villagers in general. ^^

 

[Aubrey895]

Beau was my favorite and didn’t think a villager could top him...but sherby is definitely my favorite.

 

[Blueskyy]

I have both of them currently living on my island, but whenever Étoile is added into NH, I'll be moving out Sherb to make room for her.

I considered keeping both of them, but they both have the same exact personality sub-type/talk-type and hobby.

Ugh I hope Sanrio villagers become compatible again. I miss Marty!