If you had to choose, would you pick Beau or Sherb?

[Grimlock]

I didn’t like either of them when I first saw them, but they quickly grew on me after I invited them. I currently have Sherb on my island. I used to have Beau on my old island before I reset because I accidentally told Raymond to move away. The joy con drift has annoyed me for awhile now, but when it caused me to lose Raymond I wanted to throw my “joy” cons at the wall. I was going to have Nintendo fix them in March, but, you know, life happened.

Anyway, I‘m having trouble deciding whether I should have Beau or Sherb as one of my lazies, but I can’t decide which one I want more because I like them both. I’m only going to have 2 lazies on my island, and one of them is going to be Barold. He’s like a pug; he’s so ugly he’s cute! lol

 

[moon_child]

Sherb. He’s so cute and I like his coloring too. So nice to look at.

 

[Underneath The Stars]

sherb. a huge fan of his color.

 

[Maiana]

I've had them both and-
I kept Sherb.
But Beau actually grew on me a lot ;m; he would always gift me clothes and tell me I'm a fashionista.

 

[Lazaros]

Sherb.
I didn't have Beau in NL so I can't compare, but I have them both on my island as of right now, and while Beau fits my villager theme more, and Sherb just stands out, I can't not like a little, sleepy blue goat. And also - he's named Morpheus in my first language, so that's a nice touch.

 

[Believe]

Really depends on the theme of my town! If I'm going for a more natural / woodland theme then Beau hands down. If someone a little more pastel and cutesy then Sherb. Both are great though

 

[raqball]

I have them both and hands down Sherb.. Well, I got rid of Beau the other day so technically I no longer have him..

 

[juneau]

I prefer Beau! I have Sherb right now and I'm really trying to like him, but his eyes are just really off to me.

 

[Lurrdoc]

Sherb. Beau is cool, but Sherb imo is cooler.

 

[Loriii]

I have both in my island. Don't make me choose! haha well, there are days I like Sherb more, and there are also days that I find Beau too cute.

 

[Aliya]

I currently have both of them and couldn't imagine my island without either of them, but if I had to pick one, it would be Sherb! He's my favorite of the new villagers. They are both super sweet though.

 

[Arithmophobia17]

sherb all the way... he's so cute and sweet and he's my birthday buddy lol

 

[Bioness]

It depends on the theme for your island. Also I try not to have villagers with similar houses, which is why Beau and Flora would be a bad combination.

 

[Khaelis]

I like both of them pretty equally, but I'd probably go with Beau.

 

[ForgottenT]

Beau easy, I don't like Sherb at all.

 

[Blueskyy]

I had Beau in NL and I have Sherb now and I felt like I had Beau for a time just because he was popular, but I didn’t love him. I actually love Sherb and never want him gone.

 

[Dormire]

Oh no. This is hard. But I'd choose Sherb...because...Sherbert....

 

[cloudmask]

both are cute but beau is cuter imo...i guess it depends on whether you want a more colorful villager or a more natural-looking villager

 

[PugLovex]

i have both in my town but probably beau

 

[Lovi]

Deer are an animal I feel very deeply connected to for personal reasons, but, Sherb is my heart and soul, and the moment I saw him I knew I needed him around. He's my baby through and through, and if I had to pick it would always have to be Sherb, sorry Beau!!