If the game was forcing you to choose 5 villagers of each personality...

[bluetortis26]

Sisterly:
1. Frita (Sheep)
2. Sylvia (Kangaroo)
3. Canberra (Koala)
4. Cherry (Dog)
5. Tammy (Cub)

Normal:
1. Bettina (Mouse)
2. Sylvana (Squirrel)
3. Lolly (Cat)
4. Mitzi (Cat)
5. Savannah (Horse)

Peppy:
1. Tangy (Cat)
2. Rosie (Cat)
3. Audie (Wolf)
4. Felicity (Cat)
5. Cookie (Dog)

Snooty:
1. Purrl (Cat)
2. Willow (Sheep)
3. Yuka (Koala)
4. Ankha (Cat)
5. Vivian (Wolf)

Lazy:
1. Beau (Deer)
2. Hornsby (Rhino)
3. Bob (Cat)
4. Erik (Deer)
5. Punchy (Cat)

Jock:
1. Hamlet (Hamster)
2. Rudy (Cat)
3. Bam (Deer)
4. Kody (Cub)
5. Bill (Duck)

Cranky:
1. Rooney (Kangaroo)
2. Apollo (Eagle)
3. Static (Squirrel)
4. Bruce (Deer)
5. Chief (Wolf)

Smug:
1. Raymond (Cat)
2. Marshal (Squirrel)
3. Zell (Deer)
4. Jacques (Bird)
5. Keaton (Eagle)

Species List:
Cat: 11
Deer: 5
Squirrel: 3
Wolf: 3
Sheep: 2
Kangaroo: 2
Koala: 2
Dog: 2
Cub: 2
Eagle: 2
Mouse: 1
Horse: 1
Rhino: 1
Hamster: 1
Duck: 1

 

[rse]

normal
lucy
chevre
fauna
poppy
mitzi

peppy
patty
rosie
bluebear
audie
bella

sisterly
pashmina
agnes
canberra
katt
cherry

snooty
diana
freya
amelia
blanche
julia

cranky
cyd
butch
bruce
wolfgang
boris

jock
bam
rudy
kevin
kid cat
axel

lazy ( i have so many lazy favorites...)
marcel
walker
hopkins
dizzy
benjamin

smug
shep
kyle
zell
marshal
eugene

so... 6 dogs, 5 deer, 5 cats, 4 wolves, 4 pigs , 3 elephants, 2 goats , 2 koalas , 2 squirrels , 2 peacocks, 1 eagle / cub/ mouse/ cow/rabbit!!!
dogs are my favorite after all !!

 

[Balverine]

sisterly:
Muffy
Cherry
Reneigh
Pheobe
Deirdre

jock:
Biff
Snake
Rudy
Boone
Goose
(and a honorable mention to Tarou, PLEASE bring him back nintendo lol)

lazy:
Beau
Bob
Punchy
Lucky
Raddle

peppy:
Ruby
Audie
Epona (ik she's not in NH rn)
Carmen
Dotty

smug:
Zell
Raymond
Jacques
Eugene
Kyle

normal:
Kiki
Celia
Fauna
Lolly
Skye

cranky:
Lobo
Hamphrey
Apollo
Fang
Bruce

snooty:
Portia
Vivian
Julia
Diana
Tiffany

1 sheep, 3 dogs, 2 horses, 2 ostriches, 6 deer, 1 hippo, 5 rabbits, 6 cats, 1 gorilla, 1 chicken, 6 wolves (7 if you count tarou), 1 frog, 1 bird, 1 koala, 2 eagles and 1 hamster

 

[Lazaros]

sisterly
fuchsia
renée
reneigh
hazel
agnes

jock
teddy
ace (i have him in my gc town rn and i love him, please give him back nintendo </3)
genji
dom
pierce

lazy
sherb
beau
papi
elmer
erik

peppy
ruby
audie
tutu
dotty
wendy

smug
olaf
julian
kidd
lopez
leopold

normal
coco
gayle
kiki
etoile (</3)
skye/vesta

cranky
dobie
fang
wolfgang
cyd
bruce

snooty
baabara
diana
whitney
timbra
vivian

 

[Le Ham]

Uchi: Agnes, Ursala, Cherry, Charlise, Reneigh
Peppy: Ketchup, Agent S, Wendy, Felicity, Pango
Normal: Melba, Megan, Sylvana, Kiki, Mitzi
Snooty: Tasha, Mallary, Snooty, Baabara, Bree

Smug: Rodney, Pietro, Marshal, Leopold, Kyle
Jock: Roald, Drift, Teddy, Rod, Goose
Lazy: Filbert, Chester, Cole, Hugh, Walker
Cranky: Wolfgang, Gonzo, Gaston, Hopper, Rasher

By species:
5 Squirrels
4 Bears
3 Pigs, 3 Cats, 3 Sheep
2 Dogs, 2 Ducks, 2 Wolves, 2 Koalas, 2 Anteaters, 2 Mice, 2 Penguins, 2 Rabbits
1 Horse, 1 Hamster, 1 Lion, 1 Frog, 1 Chicken, 1 Cub

 

[mochacake]

so many, gosh... you would need a giant island... mine would probably be

sisterly
hazel
pashmina
fuchsia
katt
shari

snooty
ankha
pecan
blaire
amelia
blanche

peppy
agent s
peanut
apple
tangy
ruby

normal
sylvana
pekoe
coco
flurry
lolly

cranky
dobie
apollo
chief
frank
kabuki

smug
kidd
raymond
pietro
o'hare
phil

lazy
lucky
chester
papi
sherb
zucker

jock
genji
rudy
dom
flip
kid cat

 

[Megina]

I like very few designs for Snooty/Uchi/Jock...
So this was difficult ;A;

Uchi
1. Hazel
2. Katt
3. Tammy
4. Shari
5. Fuchsia

Jock
1. Rudy
2. Dom
3. Mac
4. Tybalt
5.Teddy

Lazy
1. Beau
2. Erik
3. Pudge
4. Sherb
5. Biskit

Peppy
1. Maddie
2. Bianca
3. Flora
4. Merry
5. Audie

Cranky
1. Butch
2. Cyd
3. Gonzo
4. Hamphrey
5. Vladimir

Normal
1. Coco
2. Daisy
3. Lolly
4. Molly
5. Poppy

Smug
1. Marshal
2. Julian
3. Raymond
4. Shep
5. Hans

Snooty
1. Judy
2. Whitney
3. Diana
4. Elise
5. Soliel

 

[Lilybells]

Smug
1. Marshal
2. Raymond
3. Eugene
4. Julian
5. Colton

Jock
1. Genji
2. Dom
3. Roald
4. Snake
5. Ponch

Lazy
1. Stitches
2. Sherb
3. Beau
4. Zucker
5. Joey

Peppy
1. Ruby
2. Rosie
3. Tangy
4. Cookie
5. Bluebear

Cranky
1. Butch
2. Apollo
3. Octavian
4. Hamphrey
5. Fang

Normal
1. Coco
2. Daisy
3. Lolly
4. Molly
5. Poppy

Snooty
1. Judy
2. Diana
3. Blanche
4. Whitney
5. Willow

Uchi
1. Cherry
2. Agnes
3. Tammy
4. Reneigh
5. Fuchsia

 

[maple22]

OK...

Sisterly:
1. Ursala
2. Cherry
3. Pashmina
4. Fuchsia
5. Reneigh (the horse)

Jock:
1. Kid Cat
2. Rudy
3. Poncho
4. Bill
5. Genji

Lazy:
1. Lucky
2. Zucker
3. Punchy
4. Papi
5. Erik

Peppy:
1. Rosie
2. Audie
3. Bluebear
4. Cookie
5. Bunnie

Normal:
1. Maple
2. Flurry
3. Goldie
4. Daisy
5. Marina

Smug:
1. Shep
2. Marshal
3. Colton
4. Henry
5. Julian

Cranky:
1. Chief
2. Octavian
3. Wolfgang
4. Kabuki
5. Fang

Snooty:
1. Whitney
2. Vivian
3. Diana
4. Cleo
5. Ankha