If I Try Getting Audie, WHO GETS REPLACED in the Plans?

[toenuki]

VOTES FOR MUFFY WONT COUNT I ACCIDENTALLY ADDED HER. i need 1 uchi.


I'm probably gonna regret this idea but the good news is ACNH doesnt have that 12 villager cycle so its easy to fix!


I want MOST of the newbies. The only issue is, I'm on the fence for Audie. I want one of every personality, so if i had to replace anyone (besides 3), who goes?


So Far Pietro's chances are dying... rip my Italian friend. who will Audie slaughter in the end...

 

[Lavamaize]

I would say muffy.

 

[toenuki]

I would say muffy.

i just realized muffy is on this list she gotta get removed bc i need an uchi! sorry ab that

 

[N a t]

I feel super bad for picking Muffy, I actually like her very much, but I feel like compared to your other villagers, she just seems to fit what you have a bit less than the others, in my opinion. Many of your villagers are colorful and Muffy is basically just black and white. Raymond is at least gray with some blonde on him I guess. He'd be my second pick to go. So anyways, I think Muffy could be replaced. But I hope you're happy with who ever you decide to move out! They're all good villagers really!

Post automatically merged: May 15, 2020

Well if Muffy is staying then I'd do Raymond or Pietro. Pietro because he's one of two sheep, unless you like having animal pairs or groups, or I would ditch Raymond for the same reason I originally said Muffy. Not as colorful as the other villagers you have. You have a whole rainbow of animals!

 

[toenuki]

I feel super bad for picking Muffy, I actually like her very much, but I feel like compared to your other villagers, she just seems to fit what you have a bit less than the others, in my opinion. Many of your villagers are colorful and Muffy is basically just black and white. Raymond is at least gray with some blonde on him I guess. He'd be my second pick to go. So anyways, I think Muffy could be replaced. But I hope you're happy with who ever you decide to move out! They're all good villagers really!

im gonna probably keep her for now for uchi sake. first poll and i messed up

 

[N a t]

im gonna probably keep her for now for uchi sake. first poll and i messed up

Haha it's okay. I actually added a follow up comment in regards to my runner up votes!

 

[amemome]

Extremely biased opinion incoming but I hate the smug personality.... sorry Pietro
I see you're collecting the newer villagers so I didn't vote for Raymond but... smugs ugh...

 

[metswee]

Rationally I would say Pietro bc you already have a smug and and 2 other sheep and he would definitely be easier to find again than the other new villagers....that being said I adore Pietro and my irrational brain voted for Raymond

 

[N a t]

Rationally I would say Pietro bc you already have a smug and and 2 other sheep and he would definitely be easier to find again than the other new villagers....that being said I adore Pietro and my irrational brain voted for Raymond

I actually like completely forgot that the OP did mention they were trying to get lots of new characters. Makes me feel less inclined to ditch Raymond in this situation but he just fits in less color wise but they have more than one sheep... this would be a tough choice if it were me haha no wonder they made a thread!!

 

[kojuuro]

You have more than 1 smug, and since you want the new villagers, I chose Pietro.

 

[toenuki]

I actually like completely forgot that the OP did mention they were trying to get lots of new characters. Makes me feel less inclined to ditch Raymond in this situation but he just fits in less color wise but they have more than one sheep... this would be a tough choice if it were me haha no wonder they made a thread!!

cant decide to save my life gang

 

[Lavamaize]

I would say Pietro then, as dom looks slightly better in my opinion.

 

[Saralie]

I voted for Pietro, but only because you said no to Muffy. Hate to say this, but Muffy would be my vote... Others did bring up a good point about Pietro being a repeat species and a repeat personality type.

 

[Khte]

Dom or Pietro. Muffy is already a sheep and you said you plan on keeping her (Which is the best choice btw, one of my fav villagers).
Plus I'm not too big of a fan of them.

 

[Blueskyy]

Voted Raymond to be EdGy

 

[dragonair]

What about Muffy?

(Just kidding, I picked Pietro bc you already have another smug.)

 

[toenuki]

What about Muffy?

(Just kidding, I picked Pietro bc you already have another smug.)

this queen slander shall not be tolerated any longer... audie coming for you all

 

[Ananas Dragon]

keep raymond, I guarantee most of the votes are people who want him, kick pietro or dom

 

[toenuki]

keep raymond, I guarantee most of the votes are people who want him, kick pietro or dom

the good news: i dont have him yet as this is all just a plan since i cant decide on islanders. nobody's getting ray ray and dom is broke

 

[Ananas Dragon]

the good news: i dont have him yet as this is all just a plan since i cant decide on islanders. nobody's getting ray ray and dom is broke

bruh you can't kill someone you don't have in your island.

I want to kill barold to prevent him from ever showing his face but he's not on my island (thank heaven and beyond).

but still pietro out and no offense but uh dom is wEiRd (imo)