I have to choose someone to boot (need help) :(

[junebuggy.99]

So I'm getting Bruce in my town soon because I don't have any cranky villagers, but I already have ten villagers and so I need to boot someone out. I would like some input on this, and I'll probably have to come to a decision by the end of the day since the person giving me Bruce will likely be ready tomorrow.

These are my current villagers:
Leopold
Pietro
Filbert
Piper
Bea
Pango
Claudia
Cousteau
Pashmina
Sydney

I'm set on keeping the first three since they're my favorites. I would like to keep Claudia and Cousteau since they're the only two of their individual personality that I have (snooty and jock). I'm also very attached to Pango and Sydney. I can't move Pashmina out because I just got her and she's my only sisterly villager.

I think that I would be most willing to give up Piper or Bea, since they share a personality typing with another villager (peppy and normal). I'm leaning towards Piper, since I really enjoy Bea and I've never had her before NH. But honestly any choice I make will be a tough one. I suppose I could give whoever I move out to someone who wants them


What do you guys think? I told my friends, it would be nice if they let us have more than ten villagers

 

[cheezu]

I'd boot Piper but it just comes down to my personal preference because I prefer Bea's overall design.

 

[Figment]

I think I would boot Piper, since that's who it sounds like you're leaning towards.

Bea is really cute! I don't think I've ever seen her at all before looking her up just now.

 

[salem_]

i think id keep piper! birbs are rare to see, also she looks cute and has a nice home

 

[Miss Misty]

I would personally go Piper since I find peppies more annoying than normals.

 

[Cadbberry]

I would go with Piper, she is a nice looking villager but I think Bea seems to be your preferance

 

[Aliya]

I’d boot Piper. Bea is really cute and normal personalities are so sweet!

 

[naranjita]

I'd yeet Piper because I personally don't like bird villagers too much and Bea is adorable!

 

[FireNinja1]

If you're leaning towards having Piper leave, then I would say go for it.

 

[Hatsushimo]

If your heart is telling you that it's okay to let go of Piper, I say go for it. It seems to me like you've thought the decision through, and your reasoning (already having a Peppy that you love) is airtight as far as I'm concerned.

 

[Clock]

I’d boot Piper because you like Bea more than her and you never had her before.

 

[BalloonFight]

I would keep Piper over Bea, but I'd personally be booting Pango out of your entire list. If that's a definite no go, probably boot Bea then.

 

[AquaMarie]

I recently scanned Bea's amiibo and liked her a lot. I'm definitely going to be inviting her to move in one day. So personally I'd keep Bea and get rid of Piper.

 

[Xara]

you seem to like bea more than piper so i’d boot out piper ;u;

 

[Reploid]

Hi Piper, bye Piper.

 

[Blueskyy]

I prefer Bea over Piper so boot Piper. I like all of them more than Leopold.

 

[kojuuro]

I think you prefer to keep Bea over Piper, so I think moving out Piper is best

 

[Rosewater]

Sounds like Piper should go.

 

[bluetortis26]

Pietro

 

[Alannah20]

It sounds like you like Bea more so I'd boot Piper