Fast forwards to very recently.
I decided to try different villagers and to see if I could fulfill my daughter's wishlist by allowing move-outs. My town is full and someone on forum wants to adopt Skye. Next time she pinged I agreed and she was so relieved that I was so understanding. On move-out day she thanked me for supporting her. I felt good. Same scenario with Yuka, except she was glad I wasn't going to create a scene. bye-bye Yuka. I felt good.
Anchovy pinged me today and told me it was his dream to travel the world tasting all the flavors of food. I'm fond of him but I wanted to hold to my promise to let go of my villagers and try new ones so I told him yes.
He Started CRYING! @.@ omg what have I done?