Help on deciding Food Villagers!

[Gizmodo]

So i've had my food town for over 2 years now, and it's still not complete! i didn't play much for 5 months and lost many of my food themed villagers -.-
I wanted to see others opinions on which ones i should keep etc..

The ones that are definitely staying are:
Tangy, Marshal, Merengue, Frita (All lived in my town 2+ years) and Zucker (just cycled him back)
I'm definitely cycling back for Chadder & for Lyman (I need a jock, and his lemonade theme went well with Tangy)
So that leaves 3 spots..

Currently in my town i also have; Cookie, Bonbon, Maple and Cole&Kevin(obviously leaving)

Who else should i get/keep?
Options are: Cookie, BonBon, Mint, Maple, Flurry, Pancetti, Sprinkle
Cycle back for: Tia, Apple
Mint/Pancetti would be useul as i'm missing a snooty..
I want a hamster, Flurry would be easier, as i need to cycle back for Apple
but then i can't decide; Tia, Cookie, BonBon, Sprinkle or Maple? ahh who do i keep/get

Which villagers do you think fit the theme better?

 

[Leen]

I would definitely keep Cookie! She's such an adorable dog villager ^-^

By the way, do you have a dream address? I would love to see your town! I have never heard of a food-themed town -- very creative!

 

[Waterbottle1234]

Get sprinkle Tia and apple definitely! Especially Tia because she's a liters tea pot

 

[elle7]

I would get Apple back. Although if you really don't want to cycle for Apple, Flurry is cute too, just maybe not as obviously food themed.

As for the other two, Mint is really cute, and it could be nice to have two squirrels. And maybe for the last one, just look at what sort of villager you're missing. What villager shapes are there not that many of, like a tiny villager, or taller one like a bear or wide like a penguin or sheep. And also colour scheme maybe as well. Hope this helped a bit!

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

I can't believe no one has suggested Merengue! She's definitely one to consider.

Totally missed some names in the OP. Nevermind!

 

[sakuracrossing]

I would totally get Apple back. I love Mint and Sprinkles. Those will be adorable.

 

[SensaiGallade]

For food villagers, I would suggest:
Merengue, Zucker, Tia, Apple, Coco, Tangy, Sprinkle, Mint, Bonbon, Cookie, Bluebear, Cheri!

You should definitely keep Cookie and try to cycle back Tia and Apple!

 

[Crash]

i would definitely go with mint, I love her and she definitely fits your theme.
as for your peppy I think cookie, bonbon, maple and sprinkle all fit and would look good, but I'm kind of leaning towards sprinkle of. cookie. they seem to be the most food oriented to me c:​

 

[Gizmodo]

Thanks everyone ^_^
I'll probably keep Cookie as she's lived in my town for over a year
Hard to decide the others but since I need to cycle villagers I can try some out anyway

- - - Post Merge - - -

Tia was one of my original villagers alongside tangy, over 2 years ago, and I do miss her hm

- - - Post Merge - - -

I would definitely keep Cookie! She's such an adorable dog villager ^-^

By the way, do you have a dream address? I would love to see your town! I have never heard of a food-themed town -- very creative!

The dream address is 6500-6380-7071
It's a bit of a mess but ^^
Even after 2 years haha

 

[Gizmodo]

Right I think my town is going to be ^_^
Tangy, Marshal, Frita, Merengue, Zucker, Cookie, Mint, Lyman, Chadder and Flurry
Need to cycle back for Lyman and Chadder
And Get Mint/Flurry
I may switch Flurry for Tia and Apple if I cycle them back one day