Help Me Pick a Peppy

[Rex of Elysium]

As I have stated before I really dislike about 90% of Peppy villagers. I was going to have Tammi, but thing is I got her as a DIY house. I really dislike these starting houses, and would like to get someone else instead because of that. I really wish Epona or Cece were in this game. This leaves room for a few different options:

Audie
Peanut
Apple
Candi

Who do you think would be the best fit with this line up: Hans, Rory, Hopper, Chester, Ken, Cherry, Marina, Ankha, Judy.


Note I do have Candi's card. So I can get her easily. But she is probobly my least favorite of the ones I am asking about.

 

[Jas]

i have audie and apple on my island and audie has become my favourite peppy!

 

[Corrie]

Peanut! Her and Marina can be pink buddies!

 

[Boccages]

Audie ? Really. She is like the run down vanilla ice cream pot everyone has been chipping at for the last few week. Boring.

How about Pate, Gabi, Carmen, Peggy, Bonbon, Piper, Puddles, Felicity, Merry or Piper. All better choices than Audie, Apple or Peanut. In your list, I guess I would go with Candi.

 

[Rex of Elysium]

Audie ? Really. She is like the run down vanilla ice cream pot everyone has been chipping at for the last few week. Boring.

How about Pate, Gabi, Carmen, Peggy, Bonbon, Piper, Puddles, Felicity, Merry or Piper. All better choices than Audie, Apple or Peanut. In your list, I guess I would go with Candi.

I can't stand very many peppy villagers. I hate their dialogue and designs, to the point I refuse to have more than one wasting space on my island. The 5 I listed are the only ones I consider even passable. The ones you listed I hate.

 

[Lethalia]

I was gonna say Candi but if she's your least fave, I of course wouldn't want to stick you with that! So I'll say Peanut instead.

Post automatically merged: Apr 21, 2020

Audie ? Really. She is like the run down vanilla ice cream pot everyone has been chipping at for the last few week. Boring.

Oh my God, just dragging poor thing through the coals like that, so brutal LMAO

 

[Rex of Elysium]

I was gonna say Candi but if she's your least fave, I of course wouldn't want to stick you with that! So I'll say Peanut instead.

Candi is only my least favorite of the 5 I consider passable as far as Peppy villagers go. I like her OK, but none of these are ones I am HUGE fans of aside from the one I am letting go.

 

[Goop]

I have Audie and she's quickly become my favourite peppy.
However, APPLE is an absolute cutie and I adore her so much ;w;

So my pick would be Audie if you want aesthetic/prefer canines, Apple if you want a more cutesy and adorable nugget running around.​

 

[Ace Marvel]

I chose Flora as my Peppy, but from your list I'll go with peanut. it's a small villager that will blend well with Marina and Judy.

 

[Aleigh]

I feel like either peanut or apple would look best

 

[Spunki]

Peanut

 

[SCORPA15]

Peanut is my favourite out of the lot you have shortlisted,and I think she would fit in with Marina and Judy.

 

[brockbrock]

Audie has become my favorite Peppy. But I love Peanut as well. I'd say one of those two.

 

[Altarium]

I'm going to suggest Bianca, she's the nicest looking peppy to me. What's not to love about a snow leopard?

But from the list, I guess I'd go with Audie

 

[DarkSlayer1331]

I think with whom you have and all, Peanut would probably go best. That said, I would love to have Audie. I'm a fan of the wolves in general, and she just looks so pretty. Currently I have Merry, and she's actually been an adorable button on my island.

 

[ayeeprill]

I don't really care for any of those villagers except Audie (My fave peppies are Bianca, Pippy, Cheri, and Maddie)

However, from the ones you listed, I vote for Apple! She matches Cherry well and would look good with Judy too!

 

[Sanaki]

I'd say Audie but she's a little mainstream I guess? Not that that matters but in case you wanted something a little more unique I'd say Peanut. I used to adore her in Wild World.

 

[spacewalker]

i think out of those, for your current lineup, Apple would be a good fit!

 

[Fey]

Obviously Audie, since it’s clearly an oversight that you don’t have a wolf yet!

(I prefer several other peppies myself, but shunning her just because she’s popular seems wrong. Doesn’t make her design any lesser after all—and boring it is not)

 

[Shinjukuwu]

Apple is my favourite out of the ones you listed, but I think Peanut would be a better fit for your island going by the villagers you have!