i'm conflicted between fuchsia and muffy! i love them both so much! i only have room for one of them though unfortunately. on one hand fuchsia would go along with the other brightly colored villagers i have and i adore her design but since i plan to have a lot of other pink animals like judy, chrissy, cookie, freya she won't stand out much. i also adore muffy's design and i think having a more goth aesthetic character would add some variety while also fitting in with my sort of 2000s theme, but i also am not really a fan of how sheep wear shirts in this game instead of scarves (it doesnt bother me that much, just a bit of a nitpick)
Muffy shares my birthday and she also shares a special place in my heart for being in my all wolf town in NL. She's definitely got guts and the strength to be the only sheep surrounded by hungry wolves
i'm not fond of a lot of them, but my faves are muffy & shari. fuchsia is chic too! but i guess my vote goes to muffy as i've had her. shari looks better on new horizons, not sure about muffy. i really liked her in new leaf and her goth rococo house. i'm thinking of scanning her in the future.