Help! Fauna or Skye? Who to keep?

[Rex of Elysium]

So I am caught up to today, and man. I have a MUCH better line up of villagers on my island. Still have 1 mediocre and 2 bad ones, but overall I am much more content with this island than the previous one because I am not stuck with a majority of the popularion being ones I disliked. Let me tell you who I have so far:

Muffy, Coach, Fauna, Chester, Peanut, Beardo, Zucker, Skye, Spike

While I think Spike looks cool, he's not someone I plan to keep, meanwhile Beardo and Coach REALLY need to go.

However, I am facing a bit of a dilema. I really want Ankha as my Snooty, and Judy as my extra female. However, right now have 2 Normal villagers. Should I keep Fauna or Skye? Both are adorible, and would make for fantastic villagers. However, to get Ankha and Judy, I need to get rid of one. Which would be the better one to keep?

 

[ctar17]

If Fauna was one of your first 5 villagers, then I suggest keeping Skye as Fauna's house interior will never upgrade to the pretty one she's supposed to have.

Ultimately it's your decision though

 

[Faery Whimsy]

Ooooh this is a real tough one for me. I’ve had Fauna before, and she’s a dreamie of mine, but I’ve never had Skye. That being said though, I think both of their designs are adorable and sweet.

I guess it may ultimately depend on the aesthetic you’re going for on your island - would a natural, basic looking but cute deer fit your theme more, or a wolf whose design is based off of a cloudy sky? If your island is more natural, I’d keep Fauna. But if it’s more fantastical/quirky, I’d go with Skye!

 

[Splinter]

Keep whichever the one is most popular.

 

[Xara]

i love them both but i would personally keep skye ;u;

 

[ThomasNLD]

I soon will have both on my island, but I would probably base my decision on species in this case, if you are liking them both equally.