Goldie vs Rosie

[DoomTerminatorX]

Both have similar names. Both are adorable. Ones Normal Ones Peppy. Ones a Dog Ones a Cat. Who is better Goldie or Rosie?

 

[TheGreatBrain]

I'm partial to Goldie. She's a sweetheart.

 

[Pokemanz]

Goldie is so adorable. I just HAD to have her in my town.

Rosie is overrated imo

 

[roseflower]

Goldie is my sunshine, she is one of my favourite villagers and lives next door to my house
She was a random surprise move in and I can?t imagine my town without her.

 

[cannolis]

Goldie because I adore dogs, I'm not at all a fan of the cat villagers.

 

[Serine_Sapphire88]

Kinda a tough one. Rosie is a cheerful blue cat, and Goldie is such a sweetheart dog. I guess I'll go with Goldie because I like dogs more and I was lucky to get her to live in my town a few months ago from my campsite. ^o^

 

[patriceflanders]

Rosie by far

 

[woodlandmermaid]

Rosie, I had her in a cycle town for quite some time so I actually got to know her and she was very sweet, but I've never had Goldie (though she is cute).

 

[spCrossing]

Both...

Buuuuut If I had to chooose....it'll be Rosie.

 

[marierock13]

Goldie is a real sweetie pie, but I'm going to have to vote for Rosie on this one. I adored the Animal Crossing movie, and Rosie's characterization in particular stood out as friendly and energetic.

She's probably my favorite Peppy villager, based entirely on her appearance in the movie.

 

[LunaLight]

Goldie is sweet, but Rosie is more cheerful.

 

[buzzing]

omG GOLDIE ALL DAY EVERYDAY

 

[mabadpe]

I had Rosie from start, but I dont really like her much to be honest. She has this "I-am-such-a-star" attitude and ye, not really what I like I havent had Goldie yet, but looks quite cute too (Rosie does as well imo, just that I personally dont like her personality)

 

[agscribble]

Goldie is way cuter. I just love the doggie's floppy ears.

 

[seigakaku]

Rosie! I had her before I even joined here, since she was in my campsite! I had Goldie too but I honestly prefer Rosie since I like peppy villagers more...

 

[Holla]

I really love both, but I give my vote to Goldie as I find her just as cute as Rosie, though she is much less popular. Goldie deserves more recognition as do many villagers (I'm looking at you cutie Benjamin plus others). ^.^

 

[spiffys]

i love goldie so much, she's so special and dear to my heart. she was in my town for YEARS in wild world and when she finally left i truly felt like i lost a friend. ; __ ; i need her in my acnl town, i'd never let her go.

 

[Zandy]

It's so close for me, but I would definitely have to say Goldie!

 

[Pearls]

GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLDDDDDDDDDDDDDIIIIIIIIIIIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
You can tell by my username.
how dare rosie be winning. HOW DARE SHE