For those who do not Time Travel, how did your first Pumpkin harvest go?

[DragonLatios]

I Got a lot of Orange and a 3 whites and a Few yellow and Green. But I Lucky a Other User sold me 10 of each color so i plant them around my island and half of them in a 2nd smaller pumpkin patch then my 1st random pumpkin batch i started with.

 

[Sheydra]

Not good their already all used and have to wait for my next batch. Way too into Halloween.

 

[mocha.]

Planted 20 and harvested today, I got:

39orange
3white
6yellow

 

[Imbri]

I planted 40 starts. Roughly half of them ended up orange. The rest were pretty evenly divided between yellow, white, and green. I planted another 30 the next day and will be thinning them out. Ultimately, I want 10 of each color, which will net me 30 of each every other day.

 

[GnarlyGarden]

I planted 30 starts. Of those, 18 grew up as orange, 6 yellow, 4 green, and 2 yellow (which is kind of a weird color for pumpkins anyway ). I’m happy to have gotten all the colors right away.

 

[Hsn97]

Really good. I planted 16 plants and got 48 pumpkins in my first harvest. I might plant a few more depending on how long it takes for the pumpkins to regrow.

 

[BigBadButterfree]

I planted 25 starts. I got a ton of orange as expected, I got like 12 yellow, only about 6 white, and not a single green

 

[Debeers]

I planted 60, got 8 green, 5 yellow, and 4 white plants. So I dug out 10 orange plants and planted 10 new starts. Will see how this goes. I have a visitor water them 2 days, don’t know if it matters but just throw it into the process. By the way, each plant produced 3 pumpkins.

 

[moonlights]

so I can't remember the exact numbers but I planted a lot of starts and my yield was mostly orange, an equal amount of green and white (around 15 of each), and the least amount was in yellow, around 8 I think.
I'm waiting on some more to finish growing but I expect to see primarily orange pumpkins grow.
overall really happy with what I got though, since I wanted to decorate with mostly orange pumpkins. the green and white customisation is surprisingly prettier than I expected so I want to incorporate more of those colours onto my island too!

 

[Matt0106]

I planted 40-ish, and it went great! Definitely got a lot of orange, but I got some yellow, white and green, so it worked out! Just need to get some more spooky DIYS, and my island will be good to go!

 

[Hilbunny]

I too planted 50 pumpkins and watered 3 days!

My harvest:
White: 2
Green: 5
Yellow: 9
Orange: 34

 

[stitchmaker]

Island 1 planted 108 pumpkin and got 213 Orange, 54 White, 36 Green and 21 Yellow Pumpkins
Island 2 planted 14 pumpkins and got 24 Orange, 3 White, 9 Green and 6 Yellow Pumpkins
After harvesting I removed some of the Orange Pumpkins and replanted new Pumpkins Starts. Plan on changing colors on a lot of items.
I wish we could change the color on the Fence. White during the Spring would be nice.

 

[Manah]

Way too many orange, not enough green and white. I replaced some of my orange plants, that should give me enough for everything if I water every day.

 

[Briar]

I planted 50 pumpkin starts, and this was my harvest:

Spoiler

I ended up digging up some of the orange pumpkin sprouts and planting yellow, white, and green pumpkins in their place. Now I have 10 orange, 10 yellow, 10 green, and 16 white pumpkin plants. For the remaining 4 spots, I bought and planted 4 new pumpkin starts.

 

[hakutaku]

Got a lot of orange, a few white and green, and one yellow. It worked out fine since I wanted to customize the spooky table to orange from yellow anyway lol. I used a grown pumpkin to decorate my pumpkin carving stall too, so overall a successful crop.

 

[saucySheep]

ahhhh mine was amaZing i ended up with 255 orange, 18 yellow, 32 or 36 green and ab 24 white?? idk, around that though... i will never use all of those but it was sooo fun to harvest : D

 

[meggiewes]

Pretty good! I managed to get at least one of each color. I think I got three yellow, two whites, one green, and the rest are orange. I didn't plant a lot though. I'm pretty sure I have 20ish pumpkins on my island.

 

[saucySheep]

y'all... umm... i feel like i planted WAY more than like everybody else lol

 

[Mick]

Way too many pumpkins of every colour. What am I even going to do with all these things?

 

[Paperboy012305]

I got:

14 Orange Pumpkins
4 Green Pumpkins
2 Yellow Pumpkins
And 1 White Pumpkin.

As for how many I got by watering all of them for 3 days:

42 Orange Pumpkins
12 Green Pumpkins
6 Yellow Pumpkins
And 3 White Pumpkins

I think that's good on average for watering all of them.