Every villager you S-ranked in the tier-making threads now lives on your island

[cornimer]

Who would be on your island in this scenario? It's ok if you have more than 10 for this experiment haha.

My island would be:
-Tad
-Walker
-Elmer
-Jeremiah
-Tom
-Agent S
-Huck
-Ankha
-Jambette
-Daisy
-Cally

Tier-making threads for reference:
Jock tier-maker
Peppy tier-maker
Snooty tier-maker
Smug tier-maker
Normal tier-maker
Cranky tier-maker
Lazy tier-maker
Uchi tier-maker

 

[Your Local Wild Child]

I’d have so many villagers my island would just be houses lol I can probably fill Evwirt with normals

 

[Hanif1807]

Mine would be:

1. Rosie
2. Chevre
3. Dotty
4. Maple
5. Lolly
6. Bunnie
7. Poppy
8. Lolly
9. Pecan
10. Chrissy

 

[Briar]

For me it would be:
Roald
Snake
Genji
Bianca
Bangle
Bella
Ankha
Julia
Whitney
Olaf
Julian
Marshal
Lily
Roscoe
Apollo
Fang
Punchy
Lucky
Cherry
Pashmina

 

[Dunquixote]

For me it would be:

Punchy
Sherb
Rosie
Merry
Ankha
Maybe Pecan, Tasha
Raymond
Marshal
Kiki
Lolly
Lily
Poppy
Roscoe
Gaston
Spike
Static
Maybe Tom
Frita
Reneigh
maybe Hazel, Katt
Rudy
Frobert
Drift
Maybe Hornsby, Cole, Filbert, Claude.

There are so many that I’m really interested in that are borderline A and S. I probably need to update my tier lists for each of them.

 

[Seelie]

My lineup would be:

Diana
Purrl
Dom
Genji
Ruby
Cookie
Shep
Fauna
Kiki
Vesta
Lolly
Maple
Butch
Dobie
Beau
Erik
Punchy
Cole
Deirdre

Bold indicates the villagers currently on my island! So I guess I'd only need another 9 slots. :')

 

[John Wick]

What is an S rank?

I don't believe in ranks btw.

 

[cornimer]

What is an S rank?

I don't believe in ranks btw.

It's related to the tier-maker threads I listed in the main post! You have the ability to drag each villager pixel to S, A, B, C or D tiers depending on how much you like them

 

[Saga]

1. Teddy
2. Flora
3. Tangy
4. Bunnie
5. Blanche
6. Lolly
7. Marina
8. Dobie
9. Sherb
10. Beau
11. Shari

So, almost exactly the same as my current island minus Beau and Flora (I have too many peppies and lazies already), plus O'Hare (who I keep around for dialogue variety).

 

[Jassiii]

Oh dear... it isn't in order besides the top five, bold is who's on my island, and italics is who I still want on my island (Sorry molly, love her but once I get her photo she's getting punted off-- the same with Hornsby or Chief /haven't decided whether I want two crankys or two lazys/)

• Vesta
• Apollo
• Dom
• Audie
• Bob
• Papi
• Hornsby
• Molly
• Eunice
• Stella
• Ketchup
• Cookie
• Wendy
• Cherry
• Phoebe
• Muffy
• Katt
• O'Hare
• Julian
• Curlos
• Pietro
• Roald
• Bill
• Ankah
• WHitney
• Judy
• Diana
• Hamphrey
• Buzz
• Chief
• Avery
• Wolfgang
• Dobie

 

[John Wick]

It's related to the tier-maker threads I listed in the main post! You have the ability to drag each villager pixel to S, A, B, C or D tiers depending on how much you like them

As I said, WHAT is an S rank.

 

[Xara]

normal: gayle, fauna, daisy, margie, skye & lolly
peppy: sprinkle, audie & merry
snooty: diana, julia, whitney, freya & vivian
uchi: fuchsia, pashmina & katt
lazy: beau, zucker & lucky
jock: bam, kid cat & rudy
cranky: bruce, dobie, tom & murphy
smug: lopez & zell

hoo boy uh,, this was a lot LMAO. i haven’t looked at my tier lists since i made them back in may and lowkey,, i’m not surprised that my tastes have changed a bit in the last few months but it definitely was interesting seeing it first-hand and knowing that if i were to remake my lists, they’d look a little differently now c’:

pietro, baby, i’m so sorry i put you in the D rank

 

[peachycrossing9]

I would have so many villagers on my island xD, but this is who made it to S tier for me:

Alfonso
Julian
Wolfgang
Jeremiah
Bones
Sherb
Papi
Maple
Melba
Teddy
Roald
Bill
Tad
Hazel
Cherry
Pashmina
Deidre
Zucker
Dobie
Lily
Goldie
Gayle
Punchy
Fauna
Marina
Poppy
Lolly
Tia
Butch
Fang

This is the list I got. I didn't end up posting in the Snooty and Peppy villager tier list threads. But here is who would be in S tier from those personalities:

Diana
Judy
Whitney
Bluebear
Cookie
Rosie
Audie

 

[Chris]

As I said, WHAT is an S rank.

It's a grade in Japan's academic curriculum that comes above A. It's often used in video games that originate from there too.

 

[TaylaJade]

Uhh, this is a lot. @/Nintendo: Could I please have 40+ more slots? (THAT normal list... and Marshal by himself omg)

Cranky: Chief, Wolfgang, Fang, Dobie, Lobo, Bruce, Butch, Apollo, Roscoe, Gonzo and Rolf
Jock: Bam, Roald, Genji, Kid Cat and Poncho
Lazy: Sherb, Beau, Punchy, Erik and Bob
Normal: Stella, Fauna, Kiki, Maple, Melba, Molly, Tia, Lily, Goldie, Marina, Merengue, Poppy, Skye, Lolly and Flurry
Peppy: Rosie, Bunnie, Flora, Peanut, Bon Bon, Merry and Audie
Sisterly: Muffy, Pashmina, Phoebe, Fuchsia and Cherry
Smug: Marshal
Snooty: Diana, Pecan, Whitney, Freya and Ankha

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Oh boy, this is a lot lol.

1. Judy
2. Diana
3. Ankha
4. Whitney
5. Francine
6. Fauna
7. June
8. Merengue
9. Flurry
10. Maple
11. Marina
12. Marshal
13. Ketchup
14. Rosie
15. Audie
16. Dom
17. Kid Cat
18. Octavian
19. Fang
20. Wolfgang
21. Chief
22. Stitches
23. Sherb
24. Lucky
25. Reneigh
26. Fuchsia
27. Phoebe

 

[nightglow]

Ugh mine would be nothing but houses, So instead I took the S rank of each personality category and ended up tiering those against each other. As a Result: 37 houses yikes I guess that is still nothing but houses.. realistically, I don't think I would want more than 15 Villagers at a time though. That gives 8 permeant ultra favorites and 7 spots for rotation or for other super favorites.
--------------------
Cranky Villagers
Gonzo
Vic
Hopper
Wart Jr.

Normal Villagers
Melba
Goldie
Molly
Fauna
Lolly
Eunice

Snooty Villagers
Freya
Purrl
Vivian

Smug Villagers
Graham
Shep
Kyle
Julian
lily
Ken

Lazy Villagers
Bones
Papu
Erik

Peppy Villagers
Bangle
Tangy
Pinky
Victoria
Apple
Audie
Ruby
Dotty

Jock Villagers
Dom
Hamlet
Frobert
Sly
Ribbot

Uchi Villagers
Shari
Flo

 

[Pandemonium]

Uchi: Agnes, Tammy
Jock: Pierce, Mac, Genji
Normal: Celia, Flurry, Fauna
Snooty: Vivian, Kitty, Amelia
Smug: Kyle, Marshal
Peppy: Piper, Twiggy, Audie
Lazy: Bob, Punchy, Erik, Sherb
Cranky: Wolfgang, Admiral, Curt

 

[Sarabelle]

Normal: Goldie, Lily, Mitzi, Lolly, Poppy, & Skye
Peppy: Tangy, Peanut & Maddie
Snooty: Whitney, Blaire & Diana
Uchi: Plucky & Fuschia
Jock: Bam, Goose, & Frobert
Lazy: Beau & Filbert
Cranky: Wolfgang & Chief
Smug: Zell & Marshal

I had a lot more when I made the tier lists from the other threads, but I'm starting to refine my preferences a little bit. So this is an up-to-date list of my S tiers.

 

[MadisonBristol]

Cranky: Apollo, Bruce, Cyrano, Octavian
Jock: Bam, Roald, Dom
Lazy: Lucky, Sherb, Cranston, Cube, Stitches
Normal: Melba (love her so much, I made a higher tier for her), Marina, Aurora, Coco
Peppy: Anabelle, Tangy
Smug: Zell, Eugene, Marshal, Raymond
Snooty: Diana, Yuka, Ankha, Judy
Uchi: Agnes

If I'd have to pick just 10, I'd have Cyrano, Bam, Stitches, Cranston, Melba, Anabelle, Tangy, Marshal, Ankha, Agnes