For me it's Admiral and Gabi. Gabi was one of the 3 that moved in after the original 2 and Admiral was my 6th move in from the campsite. I really disliked them at first, especially Admiral, but now I kind of like both of them 
I will still unfortunately be getting rid of both of them one I get their villager pics though.
I also have a love/hate relationship with Muffy who was one of my original 2. I do like her and her character design, but she moved in randomly in my NL town after one of my dreamies left when I stopped playing for a while and I spent hours trying to get her to move away to get another dreamie but she never pinged. She's still in my NL town, I think she's literally become a part of the town now :/
I was convinced that Muffy was stalking me when I got her as one of my starting villagers and almost reseted. If I had never had her in NL, I would probably be willing to keep her in NH
Wbu guys?
I will still unfortunately be getting rid of both of them one I get their villager pics though.
I also have a love/hate relationship with Muffy who was one of my original 2. I do like her and her character design, but she moved in randomly in my NL town after one of my dreamies left when I stopped playing for a while and I spent hours trying to get her to move away to get another dreamie but she never pinged. She's still in my NL town, I think she's literally become a part of the town now :/
I was convinced that Muffy was stalking me when I got her as one of my starting villagers and almost reseted. If I had never had her in NL, I would probably be willing to keep her in NH
Wbu guys?