I lost Punchy and I was heartbroken. I loved him so dearly, and this was my first Animal Crossing game, New Leaf, my first favorite villager. I tried to get him back, but I just couldn't cycle him out. I lost him during the 3 days I was sick. Not a nice thing to come back to.
I once lost Diana due to TT-ing. After that, I knew to never TT the way I did before. I have her back now, but it was just horrible as she was one of my first villagers & I loved my first Diana. ;;
In WW, I lost Victoria... we were best friends, and when I found out she moved, I was literally SO distraught, I erased my town and made a new one... where she was a starter... and I was like 7, so it killed me that she didn't "remember" me and i jst... *laughs nervously*
Two. Sprinkle and Peanut...I managed to get Sprinkle back from my campsite in my second town and my boyfriend picked up Peanut from my void so at least I can still visit her.