Collectible Distribution Order Plan and Community Decision

[Bob Zombie]

Note what it says in the OP:

So your order is in reverse of what order the staff will be reading it as.

That's true! Apologies - editing my original...

 

[SweetPea321]

Ocean Pearl, Oarfish, Rainbow Moon Jellyfish

 

[LambdaDelta]

btw, regardless of how this goes and if I like the final result or not, I do have to say thanks for doing this, @Jeremy

 

[seliph]

a proposal to the oarfish-in-the-middle stans, please consider all the baby oarfish

don't they deserve to see the rainbow

 

[Foreverfox]

btw, regardless of how this goes and if I like the final result or not, I do have to say thanks for doing this, @Jeremy

Indeed, gotta be pretty brave to open up this can of worms.

 

[LambdaDelta]

also, can I just pitch that while it might be a bit much to have the winning cabin members choose the pearl placement (though regardless, it seems just about everyone agrees with it in relation to the oars), I do feel the rainbow jelly winners should get priority of choice for where it goes in relation to everything else

so like if 75% of the whole forums chooses order a for it, but the majority of jelly winners choose order b, then order b should go through, despite not being an active majority pick

 

[Bob Zombie]

a proposal to the oarfish-in-the-middle stans, please consider all the baby oarfish

don't they deserve to see the rainbow

Not until they're older....

 

[xSuperMario64x]

View attachment 396907View attachment 396908View attachment 396909View attachment 396910View attachment 396911

My vote goes for this setup~ I think the Oarfish looks the nicest in the middle.

I'm honestly praying that my oarfish is on the left side of the rainbow jelly, that would be perfect!!

 

[LambdaDelta]

oh yea, and thanks too, for not having one oar winners prizes just be a body pile of decapitated oar heads

though if you'll say, since I'm curious, will it be about a 1/3rd distribution of each body part to one oar winners or just pure rng distribution that could end up having a ton of extra heads still or such

 

[Valzed]

Considering I'm 99.99% sure I'm not going to get any of these collectibles I think I'm going pass on voting.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

A lil sad that the 1 piece oarfish distribution is left up to RNG but it does make the most sense that way.

I vote for Pearl (newest), then Oarfish pieces, then Rainbow (oldest), so:

View attachment 396890View attachment 396891View attachment 396892View attachment 396893View attachment 396894

This is the best one!

 

[skarmoury]

I just wanna say that centering the oarfish will only really benefit the poliwag event winners; rainbow jelly winners from other cabins will end up having their rainbow jelly at the butt of the oarfish and personally it'd be a shame for the oarfish to not see the rainbow jelly

 

[Croconaw]

I just wanna say that centering the oarfish will only really benefit the poliwag event winners; rainbow jelly winners from other cabins will end up having their rainbow jelly at the butt of the oarfish and personally it'd be a shame for the oarfish to not see the rainbow jelly

This is logic, and to be honest, I have to agree. I don’t have a preference for an order, but rainbow jellyfish should be to the left of the oarfish. Take into consideration the non-winning Cabin.

 

[Blink.]

please do not let my oarfish be pooping out a jellyfish.

nature don't work like that

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Okay, maybe this way then? It's been suggested before but the one that I saw it in also had another proposed line-up so that makes it weird to vote on
edit: just realized dunquixote's post suggested this lineup! go vote on that one here

 

[Antonio]

You could just give it to me and I'll definitely manually give them away how the other person wants and totally not keep them for myself.

 

[Croconaw]

You could just give it to me and I'll definitely manually give them away how the other person wants and totally not keep them for myself.

That’s not suspicious at all.

 

[Antonio]

That’s not suspicious at all.

Right? Definitely not suspicious in anyway.

 

[LambdaDelta]

I just wanna say that centering the oarfish will only really benefit the poliwag event winners; rainbow jelly winners from other cabins will end up having their rainbow jelly at the butt of the oarfish and personally it'd be a shame for the oarfish to not see the rainbow jelly

you could use a shell plush in place of the pearl though, for example

plus, what about those that don't win a jelly?

(note: I'm only being half-serious. I've no opinion on the rainbow jelly placement order beyond rainbow jelly winners should get to pick)

 

[skarmoury]

you could use a shell plush in place of the pearl though, for example

plus, what about those that don't win a jelly?

Well yeah, but rainbow jelly is a prize to possess so I think for the non-poliwag rainbow jelly winners it‘d look nicer for the oarfish to point towards the rainbow jelly. Just my preference though :0 At the end of the day I think the rainbow jelly winners should also have a say on this and not just the pearl winners.